Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
catflisher

Just wondering...any Carp thu ice stories..facts??

21 posts in this topic

I would like to know to. I think it would be fun to try to catch some. I have seen them from time to time. Corn do you think that would work it works well in da summer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We caught a good number of carp, last winter, while perch fishing in a small SD lake. Most were in the 3# range but some were around 5#.

They provided a good fight on 2# test.

tweed

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No one has any ideas or exp catching them under the ice

no but I wish I did. There aren't many lakes around here with a healthy carp population. I'm going to give it a try on a couple lakes this winter and see what I can come up with.

I've heard of guys fishing them with a tip-up and bread ball. Others tell the story of a nightcrawler. I'll going to try some of my fly patterns through the ice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it is possible, and I read some stuff from a guy who has successfully targeted them and caught them through the ice. As time allows, carp through the Ice is one goal I have set...... as in consistantly catching them through the ice.

I have one or two areas in mind and at least a framework for an attack plan...... and a buddy or two to bounce ideas off of, fish with and compare notes with.

Some people have said carp do not bite in water under 50 degrees, that is the magic mouth shutting number they say, but it has been shown by accidental catches while fishing for other species through the ice, and by seeking and catching them through the ice that it can be done. I have caught a ton of carp on the fly at an open spot on the river during the dead of winter..... granted the water is slightly warmer than the main body, but only by a couple of degrees.

Please keep us posted as you guys experiment with ice carp. I'm totally gung-ho about the potential.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A friend of mine caught a fish around 20lbs two years ago on a panfish jig and a wax worm. Totally accidental of course, but shocked us when we got it through the hole after a half hour fight.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actually catch a lot of them fishing the backwaters of rivers. Though I am targeting pannies and crappies, the carp seems to like small plastics that imitate larva stage insects, such as ratsos and shimpos. Just make sure to use a big enough hole, I have had carp get stuck in a 6" hole!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This has nothing to do with ice fishing but it helps me get through this time of snow and ice.

I'm looking into carp on ice. I'm not much for this ice fishing thing but this is somthing I'll try,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I headed out to target some pannies today when this guy took my by suprise....

IMG_2300-1.jpg

~20" and 3 lbs

Caught on a small ice jig tipped with 3 eurolarva, I was fishing in a small lake with a max depth of 7' this fish came in at about 2' off the bottom and smacked my jig once and I missed and then hit it again and I hooked up. I think there is more out there as I marked lots of very negative fish and the gills and crappies were very aggresive.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tell us about the redhorse. what kind of water? Was it a fluke or do you think someone might be able to target them if they had the desire? Do you remember what kind of redhorse it was?

I would love to find a place to ice some redhorse!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have heard that in the winter all the carp in a givin lake school up into one big massive group. Is there any truth to that? I heard this when I was fishing on a lake and talked to a man that was going to net the carp for the lake association, and he said he had them marked on his sonar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that's awesome. I wonder what parts of a lake generally hold carp like that in the winter. I know Minnetonka has had problems in the past with carp induced thin ice and many others too. What depth, bottom structure do these guys relate to?

Thanks again for showing that

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those who haven't seen elsewhere I pulled my first targeted carp through the ice last week. Keys were:

Current (i was fishing 4 inches of ice in one hole and 8 in the other)

Shallow water

Learning after the first fish that two 6 inch holes are not big enough to bring a carp through the ice.

A suspended waxworm took one and a single peice of corn on the bottom took the other.

Lots and lots of time and patience as most of them just swam by. Took many many many many carp swimming under my holes before I found one that was feeding.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I tried to purchase the screws yetti uses from Fastenal who is their vendor for the screws. They are only sold in large reels designed for a self loading screwgun. I finally called Casey at Glacial lake docks where I purchased my yetti and he sent me out the amount I needed. They work great to add additional fir strips. The plastic used to tie them together comes right off as you screw them in. Hope that helps. 
    • Sorry...was wrong on the specs.   Manufacturer is Core Ice.  It was 1450# for a 12' and 1250# for a 8'.  
    • I believe you want to use a zinc coated or galvanized steel according to the charts.  I'm sure someone will come along to correct me
    • In the back room there is a company that is using bonded foam panels (similar to garage door panels, but really clean looking), and had weights of 1250# for a 12' and 1450# for a 16'.  Aluminum trailer frames that could convert to a skid frame.  Can't recall the name.  I'm sure they were spendy, but I can see a concept like that going somewhere for the hardcore fishing crowd.   Yetti, Firebrand, Big Bite, and Glacier all had really nice display models.      Lots of campers (disguised as fish houses) out there at prices that make me want to jump into the business.  I was in two different manufacturers houses with prices well over $30k that had wire nuts for connections.  That is going to be a fun adventure for someone 2-3 years down the road when they find out their manufacturer saved $15 on their wiring.           
    • Thank you for all the help!  Ended up going with the Marcum VS485C.  After some research, there were a few other Marcums that were on the list (825 & 625), the Aqua Vu HD, and the Pan Cam.  The mini cams from all manufactures weren't what I was looking for, but they are cool and do have their place.     After seeing everything in person, I think the Aqua Vu HD had the best camera/screen.  The Marcums were a little bit behind, but the 825, 625, 485, and Pan Cam had similar real life clarity.  The 485 won out because of the $300 price point vs the others at $450-700, and was almost identical for resolution, other than the HD.
      I honestly think these cameras are all about 5+ years behind in technology in comparison to the broader camera/tv screen market.  Running off a 7-9ah battery is probably one of the limiting factors.  Another may be the cold.  The main reason (IMO) is that the manufacturers are hoping they can incrementally rape us by trickling out technology each year, similar to the computer manufacturers of the 90s/early 2000's.  For the price of a middle of the road underwater camera, I can buy a Chinese made 50" TV (these all have Chinese made 5-8" screens) and a GoPro or Sony Action Cam (which is 10x's the picture quality).       
    • Any newcomers in the wheelhouse business at the Ice show in St. Paul?
    • Im sure it's hard to see through your Liberal tears.  
    • Well Molly doesn't have any snow on her.   You been drinkin?  
    • 70 pages dealing with Donald Trump and I can't find much that says anything on the positive side, of course in the past year and a half he hasn't said much that's been positive either.
  • Our Sponsors