Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
DocEsox

Strongest Freshwater Fish...Part II

11 posts in this topic

Didn't see this till now and the old thread is way long. It asked for strongest freshwater fish.....IMHO....credentials...currently I have caught 292 species of fish in my lifetime, roughly 80 or so of those would be freshwater. Everyone's opinions have been persuasive and I will agree that sunnies can kick butt for their size. Sturgeon have stamina and just large size. Salmon and steelhead can produce sizzling runs, as can large, native rainbows up here in Alaska. As my moniker suggests I have caught lots of pike and some large musky....neither of which are spectacular fighters but on the strike they could rip most other fishes heads off. Have caught hundreds of lake trout up to 30 lbs. and they aren't even on my radar for strongest....love all the charrs but they aren't even the best fighters in the salmonid family. And much as I enjoy the beautiful arctic grayling (here's a 19" from May this year):

KashGraylingwRod.jpg

Grayling are not considered anywhere near the top here in Alaska. This year I had the opportunity to compare smallies recently (out of Montreal, Quebec) with peacock bass (southern Florida). Some great fish of each species from Oct and Nov:

Smallie24.jpg

Smallie15.jpg

DoublePcks.jpg

Pck5.jpg

Agree with the tenacity and strength of the kings....had one in May which hit while I was fishing trout....was using a 5 wt flyrod with 10 lbs tippet....took me an hour or so to get her in:

Kashkinghoriz-1.jpg

A nice native Kenai River rainbow around 12 or so pounds:

Bow10.jpg

But IMHO none of these is even close to the raw fury of hooking a dime bright sockeye salmon. If these little turds grew to the size of chinook you would never even get a good look at them. I've had them run through my legs, smack the guy next to me in the head so hard it nearly put him down, jump up the bank several feet and then back into the water and they never quit.....ever. Quite tasty too. Silvers (Coho) are pretty good also but would rank behind reds and kings for me.

1. Sockeye (red) salmon

2. native Alaskan rainbow

3. Chinook (king) salmon

4. Peacock bass (put largemouth to shame)

5. Smallmouth

There you have it...my list of 5. Now when it comes to saltwater it is a whole different story....but we'll leave that for another thread.

Brian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As in the other thread, I have to agree with sockeye (after noticing the "freshwater" that was not in the original post headline), thus eliminating tuna:) My only question is whether we should consider sockeye in the freshwater catagory, as they spend much of thier life in the salt, and we just happen to catch them mainly in freshwater. But boy, do they pull!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we are going ounce for ounce, than the bluegill gets top spot, if they got to be 30 pounds you would need to be strapped into your seat to reel on in!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

King Salmon.....contest over.

A 20lb sturgeon or a 20lb flathead, nice fight, but it doesn't compare to 20lb. King.

Yes, the Sturg and Flattie will show some impressive strength in some current, but when a King rips off 485' in the time you can muster a holy #%$@!, you know who's King in this comp.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SMB hands down. If those guys got to 98lbs like Kings can you would need a conceal/carry permit to protect yourself. Holy cow, could you imagine a 20lb smallie? Honestly, it scares me just a bit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The king I have in my avitar(sp?) was the best fight I have ever had.

The thing about this one was it was caught on the kenai with the fast current working with it. It would turn against the current and burn off 100+ ft of line like nothing. It was awesome!! We ended up landing it about 500yds down river from where it was originally hooked. (45", 43lbs)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Those peacock bass look they would be tasty, maybe because they look like a yellow perch. Picture a 30 lb. bluegill, I think that would win...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm so jelous of those pictures! Looks like you've been in some fun places Doc!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've also caught Peacock Bass in Hawaii and they fought way harder than any small mouth bass I have ever caught. Never fished for Salmon, but I hear they are quite the fight too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Well this warm winter should help out this coming year pretty well.
    • Well, today was both awesome and extremely disappointing. We hadn't been hunting my pintail, wigeon and mottled duck spot because I had heard it got beat up pretty bad over the weekend and I wanted to let it rest for a few days & build some birds back up. Got all set up & had enough pintails work to make it interesting, but the wigeon were pretty much a no-show. The majority of the pins (a couple thousand!) landed to the west about 1/2 mile away in an area I've never seen birds work. Buddy shot one, and we had a flock of 8 buzz us while we were picking dekes (as they always do). On the plus side, we were only 1 bird short of our pintail limit (2 hens didn't make the pic) and 2 of them shot their first pintail. One guy that has been hunting for 25 years shot 2 gorgeous pins that are wall bound, the other guy that shot his firsts got a drake and a hen. All had sprigs but some were pulled before the pic to save for mounting as we didn't want them to get broken during transport. Also not pictured are 2 drake shovelers and a drake and hen red. All in all a slow day but my buds were ecstatic. Tomorrow, we head to a lake that I've never hunted but has had a lot of cinnamon teal (as well as bwt, gwt, wigeon, gads, fulvous and whistling ducks, pins and mallards) shot out of it this year. Wish us luck!!  
    • Well they build a few bikes but not really the shows shtick!
    • The state’s deer herd is growing, the 2016 harvest suggests. http://www.startribune.com/based-on-2016-harvest-state-s-deer-herd-appears-to-be-growing/410595495/  
    • A site I came across that is a pretty good database for what is going on nationally   http://www.deerfriendly.com
    • I don't identify as Republican.   You identify as Libertarian, right?
    • When we fish portables we all have our own  
    • Special SE Minnesota deer hunt to expand after sixth CWD discovery   http://lacrossetribune.com/sports/local/special-se-minnesota-deer-hunt-to-expand-after-sixth-cwd/article_a99fda2a-244d-5def-b71a-0b7d0dffad05.html     https://sportingjournalradio.com/2017/01/17/cwd-in-mn-what-does-the-latest-positive-chronic-wasting-disease-test-results-mean/   Audio interview with Cornicelli
  • Our Sponsors