Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
JIGGIN'

In the market for a new portable

12 posts in this topic

Lost my old fish Trap 3 to a garage fire this fall and I am in the market for a new Fish Trap. Got my eyes on the X2, but don't know anyone who has this model. Looked at the Yukon and Voyageur, but the X 2 seem a bit more rugged and quality for the money. Who has an opinion on this? What model Trap gives you the best quality for the money? I need to fish 2 people for sure. Don't want something too cumbersome, but would like a roomy fish house. I like the sled on the X2 much better than the others as well. It is 145 lbs, so to lug that around is that a big deal. I have no wheeler or sled to tow this with so I am at the mercy of using my pickup and muscle power. Thoughts guys??? What would you buy. Haven't considered the Otter sleds at all, as I like the reputation of the Fish Traps...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And you don't like the reputation of Otters? Just kidding. Check out Otters. You say you like x sled. You'll like a Otter better.It"s where they started.Try it,you'll like them. grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FYI ... Gander had some blow out deals - I think the Yukon was $399 and swivel otter seats for $49. Bro Brosdahl will be at the Forest Lake store today.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sounds like you're sold on a Fish Trap but, for that kind of money, I would at least check out the Canvas Craft NorpacR2 insulated shelter. No condensation inside, less wind noise, warmer. Give 'em a call and they might honor the Ice Show price yet, too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've had the Fish Trap Voyager and the Otter Magnum Lodge. Both very nice units. The otter has a sled that is unmatched in my opinion. The new fabric and pole system has only made the Otter better. I did like the lighter weight of the voyager when it came to pulling by hand. If you are using a sled or wheeler to pull it long distances buy the otter and be sure to purchase the hyfax. Just my opinion. Not to throw you for a loop but Frabill has just gotten into the mix with their new model the Predator. Heavy sled, fabric, and great pole design. All for $600.00. All worth the money.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I;m not totally sold on the fish trap, just really have like their products in the past. It seems that there have been so many advancements since I had my trap 3 I bought in 1999 that I really don't know what is out there for the money. Any which way it seems like a guy has to drop at least 600 bones for a good unit to fish 2 guys all day in any conditions. I am mostly looking for peoples personal experience with what is currently out there today with best value for the price. I am keeping and open mind until I decide to spend the cash. Thanks for all opinions on a new shelter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would really consider an insulated one.Never have any frost on the material.If something like a fire ever happened to mine,i would only get an insulated one again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry about your loss Jiggin.Have you looked at the teamwild line of fish houses made by otter.The price is right and Iwas pretty impressed. The one man houses dimensions are bigger than any one man fishtrap.I think the two man sold for 349 bucks last year.I was looking at the yukon last year and almost bought one until I saw one of the teamwild houses bought one with no regrets.good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I recently picked up an x2 for this season and i absolutly love it. Its a great shelter all around. My fishing partners won't even let me take out the suitcae sytle again. Poles look like they could make it through a hurricane and the fabric is top notch. I also like that the travel covers have a zippered access on top. I pull it by hand across the ice and its not too bad either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As with everything it depends on your wallet. Have had my Voyager for 4 years and really like it. Plenty of space,fairly light, and easy enough to heat with a basic Mr. Heat. I probably fish over 40 days a year in mine and it is holding up just fine

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Looks like the rust belt should of went with a better rustproofing package.........     Donald Trump may have positioned himself as the champion of American workers but Republicans on the Hill are already embracing his “do as I say, not as I do” modus operandi. Under the backing of Paul Ryan, the GOP leadership stripped a provision from a water bill Monday that would have required American-made iron and steel products to be used in infrastructure projects in Flint and elsewhere funded by the Safe Drinking Water State Revolving Fund (DWSRF). Democratic Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown blasted Republicans, who removed the “Buy America” provision (which passed the Senate with strong bipartisan support) while the House and Senate were reconciling the bills. In other words, GOP leadership scrapped it behind closed doors. “By stripping meaningful Buy America rules from the water infrastructure bill, Washington leadership is choosing China and Russia over Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin,” said Brown. “This was the first major test of whether Washington establishment Republicans would live up to President-elect Trump’s promises to put American products and American workers first – they failed, and American iron and steel workers will pay the price.” Now, Brown is teaming up with Democratic Sens. Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin and Bob Casey of Pennsylvania to insert the provision back in the bill. They want to reattach the provision to a nearly $12 billion Water Resource Development Act (WRDA), which authorizes dozens of infrastructure projects around the country and is on track to pass the House this week. “I’m not giving up on this fight,” Baldwin said in a telephone interview Tuesday. “Why would we pass a bill that only benefits Russian and Chinese steel corporations when we could be providing certainty to American manufacturers of steel and iron?” That sentiment was shared by some steel worker groups earlier this week: “From our end it’s a little baffling,” said Roy Houseman, a legislative representative for the United Steelworkers. “It’s been a program that’s been really successful, and it has bipartisan support. We’re just very confused by the Speaker, who’s not listening to the rest of his caucus.” In essence, “Buy America” sounds as nice to Republicans as it did to Trump, but in practice they would rather preserve the "Buy Chinese" option that Trump uses to build his skyscrapers.
    • If there are any twins fans left, I wonder if these new young bucks running the club have asked mauer if he would lift his no trade clause?  I think we know the answer.  I find it interesting to watch these winter meetings trades etc but we are never involved.  It seems like we are missing something as fans.
    • Sorry BD2 --I think the trout is the most dependent on everything Now the king of conservatism is a-----------------------carp   This could get interesting!
    • Sorry but the Walleye is the most Liberal fish in Minnesota. In most lakes it depends solely on the government and taxpayers of the state for it's very survival and proliferation. Lot's of other fish breeds are able to take care of themselves without help from the Government, those are the conservative fish. 
    • They make a variety of suits to suit your fishing style really. If you are a run and gun style fisherman, or if you're a guy that sits in the fish house all day they, and most brands nowadays have one that will suit your needs. I'm more hot blooded so when they first came out I ordered the Lite suit, a little less insulation but just as durable. It has been discontinued but it I think it was replaced with the Predator suit. 
    • Nah....walleyes would be hard-line Republicans;  conservative with little or no imagination, terrified of doing something new or different or pushing ahead with anything not tried before. Show me a 6-pound walleye and I'll show you Barry Goldwater with scales  or Ronald Reagan when he was not napping. PF is right, catching a walleye,  even a nice big fat one, is about as exciting as a naked tussle with Rosie O'Donnell or dragging a bag of seaweed into your boat. We used to catch some really big ones in MT and after a bit we learned that the big perch fought better and were way more tasty!  No kidding, those perch....12-15" were way better eating.  But then we were catching them from cold clear water. But if you are really new to fishing and don't possess a lot of skill by all means become a walleye fisherman-anybody can do it.
    • Well it's "Throw Down" time! For years I have kept a bag of sunflower seeds in the cup holder of my SUV to nibble on as I ride along. In the last few weeks since about the last weekend up north Deer hunting I would come in and think, man I really down some seeds, that was a pretty new bag? Then checking my oil one day noticed some empties under the hood!  Um, someone's having a party? Went to pick up my Deer at the butcher today and again found the new bag almost empty! Checked back seat floor and found a few sprinkles on the floor! That's it, don't mind the little guy along for a ride but don't touch my seeds! Thought about setting up the trail cam to plan some strategy, but just went with the blind two trap set front and back seat floor. Report when I get some results!
    • Read it again grasshopper, I never said any such thing.     Pence LOST jobs, Johnson gained jobs and the money didn't come out of revenue that was already being produced. Johnson's money came out of NEW tax revenue that would have never been earned if they didn't do the deal.   I don't know what that quote is you posted but I never said any of that.
    • Catching a walleye is about as exciting as reeling in a bath towel. Not sure how that justifies being an elitist. Bullheads put up a better fight.    I always considered walleyes to be the liberals of the fish world. 
    • When was the last time? 1835? That was the last time the national debt was paid off.     How would you know that? We've never taken a trillion dollars off the debt EVER.      
  • Our Sponsors