Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Adam Wolf

Keeping fish on the ice

15 posts in this topic

To me it seems more people keep fish in the winter than the summer. Just wondering why that is and if it's true. Is it because of the species of fish you target, or ability to keep them cold, or is it just what we do here in MN?

I'm generally a C+R guy but kept a few walleye last weekend and was thinking about why I did.

Two years ago in the winter I caught a 23 inch Bass and had another guy on the lake take a picture of it for me, he was surprised I was letting it go and asked "Aren't those things good eatin'?" It surprised me since the thought of eating it never crossed my mind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fish from cold water taste better. The majority of people don't keep bass of any size to eat. A fish of that size is good to put back in the lake for reproduction purposes and to be caught another day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A 23" bass would most certainly be going back. After all the measurements and photo of course. Would have to get a replica.

But I would have to say that I do keep more fish in the winter. Well, any fish in the winter is more than I keep in the summer. The winter is when I target pannies so I would say it is a species thing. Summer is dedicated to Bass. All c/r.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i follow the same "size rules" that I have established for myself if I am going to keep a fish regardless if its summer or winter,

At any time of the year if i have enough for a meal then they are all going back anyways.

For me the difference is I fish a lot more in the winter thus end up keeping more during the winter months.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm pretty much 97% catch and release....I'll keep an eye' or two in Canada but that's about it. I can't believe some of these people eating huge, warm water bass.... sick As far as the winter...yeah, I suppose it's much more obvious too when someone decides to take there limit during the winter months. Many guys will just transport the fish in the livewell during the open water months.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ditto... im more of a C&R person but I will keep a meal of panfish or walleyes once a week. I think the reason people keep more in the winter is because they fish panfish and walleyes more. Ive noticed that in the summer people focus more on bass and muskies (at least on waconia they do, if you don't get plowed over by a [PoorWordUsage] skier).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I fish for sport in the summer, and to eat in the winter. For one it is a lot easier to keep fish from spoiling in the winter, second I target panfish mostly in the winter.

I try to be a selective harvest guy, and be sure to keep those smaller fish.

Granted I only probably keep about 20 crappies all winter, but I am ~100% C&R in the summer.

I think this is pretty consistent with what I have seen. In general people are keeping more fish in the winter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like others have stated, I also target panfish more in the winter than the summer. I keep enough each winter for a few meals as my family loves eating crappies. I mainly target bass in the summer and its all CPR. I do keep the occasional northern in the summer as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Almost always C&R here ... fish mostly for sport and enjoying the outdoors.

Since watching a video of sunfish fry on the ice, I've been craving them .... I plan to keep more sunnys for the frying pan. Most lakes around here have way too many anyways.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I keep every eater size legal walleye I catch...

which is equal to about 2 a year cryblush

99% of the walleye I catch are illegal to keep (pool 2) and I always CPR. Northern, bass, catfish, carp, and all those weird river fish get CPR'ed too.

I'll keep some crappies or sunnies during the ice season sometimes, but only enough for a few meals a year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just don't fish in the summer as much as in the winter. When I do get out in the summer I take my 6 year old daughter along with, so I am usually chasing small panfish to keep her interested. In the winter I am usually targeting bigger fish, and keeping more to eat. Still do a lot of C and R in the winter too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am not shy about keeping fish as long as they are legal to do so. The amount of research going into creating the limits and the lack of me fishing every day kind of eliminate the element of feeling guilty about keeping a few fish.

That being said, I mostly keep fish during the winter; crappies, sunnies and eyes, primarily. I rarely keep any in open water, just cause there usually is a cookout at the end of the day anyway. I heard that the smart fishermen makes sure to stock up on steaks and burgers instead of counting on eating fish anyway. I guess in the winter, I'm mostly cooking inside and its cold, so frying a few up warms the house up a bit. Plus, the meat seems to taste better coming out of a cold lake. I bet during the last year I got 900 walleyes and I think that maybe 25 of them ended up swimming in hot oil, the rest are still swimming in the lake, to be caught again.

When I was in school, I did eat a lot more fish. I was without funds, and the crappies were a easy catch so I ate more than I care to think of, but I bet it evens out over the years. There is something to be said for actually living off what you can catch too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have my "own" set of slots that I keep for fish. If they fit the range, I keep what I want as long as it's legal. If I have fish at home that I haven't eaten yet, then I do C&R. When my parents come to the cities though I keep more fish. They love to eat fish and my Dad doesn't fish unless he's with me. So we keep some and have a couple of fish fries over the holidays while they are here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i kleep more in the winter ...but in the summer i dont ever keep any thing other then a cupple walleyes winter ill keep some panfish and once and a while a small pike or a small bass they really are good out of late ice

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I keep less in the winter cause I am living more by myself (live with my family in the summer). I never freeze fish in the winter so I try only to keep 1 or 2 that I am going to eat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • 44 IN THE BOAT HERE ON HIDDEN BAY. One thing you always can count on here at Lake Iwanttobethere is that after a lousy day there will be a nice day. Warmer, party cloudy skies and it is warm where I sit at my desk here in the den. The brown dog is at my feet, his paws on my right foot keeping tabs on me. Yesterday was a rain day and normally I look forward to rain days as they give me time to catch up on indoor projects. Rain days in the dead of winter however do nothing more then create work. Ground is frozen so all we have is runoff which here in the cabin means a wet floor in the basement. Overnight the water freezes and now we quickly go through the ice melt trying to get rid of the ice so it is safe to walk on the sidewalks.   Ranger Rick is reporting that his trail system at Samantha Lake is a mess. The rain and warm weather has eaten away at his trails. The short cut across Samantha Lake is not recommend to use as their is water on the ice and getting on and off the lake is unsafe at best. No fishermen on the lake yesterday but then again it rained more then a half an inch. Big hockey game on tonight the Wild against the Black Hawks. We will see if putting the seventy inch TV in will draw a beer drinking crowd. I would love to be there but have been under the weather the past few days and will be watching from home.   I have gotten a few e-mail’s asking about Lake Iwanttobethere and it is a good time to be a little more clear about the Lake. The wife has never had her named mentioned in the eleven years I have been writing about the lake. She told me she did not want anyone to know her name so she is always refereed to as "The Wife" of my four kids only the boys names have been used as they own business in town, the daughters have never had their names mentioned except the one who paints is sometimes spoken about as at Christmas she paints store front windows. None of the eight grand kids names have been mentioned but they are often refereed to a granddaughter number two or grandson number three. The two ten year olds are spoken about often and are refereed to as "The Tenners"   Almost every one in town is based on someone I know. A few of them have passed on but I still write about them, kind of my tribute to them. I could still be writing about my old dogs Bud and Barney as they left me with a ton of stories untold but I shared my loss with you over them and have moved on. Now I leave it up to you how much the Lodge and Resort are. One of you called the Resort a bar and it is far more then that. The Lodge is a place for members to hang their hats. There are lockers in the basement for their stuff and a chair in the Main Room to sit and be left alone. Not everyone drinks, for example everyday Tom sits at the end of the bar with a cup of coffee every morning and does his crossword puzzle. I never mention him much because that is just what he does. The FELLOWS on the other hand seem to be doing something all the time that you may find interesting. The Resort is a place for the guys to get away from the Lodge if that makes any sense.   The Resort has become like our Lake Iwanttobethere old guys home. Marv, Elmer, DOC and Vic are the core and none of them are married and they are doing just fine thank you. Chuck, Hammering Hank, Skinny and I are the next wave, the in betweeners so to speak. Married but still looking for a hideaway. Where is Lake Iwanttobethere? I’ll save that for another day.
    • Season has been over for awhile but now I have a couple of Grouse who just strut in my back yard taunting me. Duncan has tried to put the fear into them but no matter how quick he is they are up in the trees before he can get halfway across the yard. He does come back with that stupid lab look on his face so I guess everyone is enjoying themselves here late in the winter. I hope to hear them drumming this spring.
    • cool!!  and thanks again for the info!!  i look forward to getting it.
    •  Used to, then he lost it to Vince and Nick Cage in a Segway race on Tropicana.
    • Your going to like it. Definitely not "the best", but still definitely worth the money. Mine came slight damaged... one of the flanges where the leg attaches to the barrel was bent slightly. It was easily fixed but I decided to contact RK about it... They said to send them pictures, and within 2 days I had a phone call offering either a full exchange or $100 credit to my card. I gladly took the credit. I fired it up around Xmas time in 15-20 degree weather. I was worried how it would do in the cold. It handled it like a champ and only took about 15 min longer to smoke an entire pork loin.
    • Unless you have a source for 14' sheets you would end up with vertical and horizontal seams. No real problem with that, that I can think of. 
    • Speaking of automation     http://www.cnn.com/2016/12/01/health/robot-sex-future-technosexuality/   Ok, which one of you fellas has one    
    • America has a nasty habit of declaring unwinnable wars.
    • I thought he had the 65 Chevy with primered flames  
  • Our Sponsors