Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
blarkey

mistaken doe

32 posts in this topic

how many of you guys have shot what you thought was a doe and when you recovered it had big spikes on it and had to use your only buck tag on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It happens. If you are woried about it happening you have to look at your critter really good. It is part of the "know your target" part of hunting.

I will say this.... I have no sympathy for anyone who shoots a spike when they thought they were shooting a doe. You did not know what you were shooting when you shot it. Now you are paying the price.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I understand it can happened ,but when you are out driving deer and shooting everything that is brown that is running at a thousand miles a hour. I don't feel sorry or bad for you at all for it is called hunting not driveing and chasing deer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shot a spike at waning hours of shooting light a couple years ago thinking it was a big doe. This year I had a fork come in and I was sure it was a single doe and was at full draw but realized at 10 yards it was a fork and let him walk. I watched this deer come in from about 60 yards out. Sometimes the ears can hide those little racks pretty well. Sometimes the horns are pretty obvious and other times they are camoflouged pretty well.

Tunrevir~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You really hit a nerve now I did just that last year. I was out to shoot a doe and was in a great doe stand and it was getting late and it gave me a great 30 yard shot it went 10 yards. I was happy no tracking, when I walked up to it it was a small 3 pointer and the horns do not go post the ears. Well yes I was sick but I tagged it and said I will never shoot another deer like that again I must see the hole head like make sure there are no spikes on that head again.

Well there is always next year and a good lesson for all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did it a couple of weeks ago in WI. It was 60 yards and walking through the brush. I had a good shot and good opening, I just couldn't see the 3.5 inch antlers at that distance.

I thought I was getting someone else their EAB sticker, instead I was burning mine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the brown it's down crew won't answer this question because they like the "gee i wonder what i just killed", as they walk over to their brown deer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My buddy shot a a Huge DOH this year, 3 pointer on one side, a little nubbin on the other side. He was sure it was a doe since it was being tailed by two smaller bucks with their nose down, he never got a solid straight on look, just a side view.

We were hunting in an intensive harvest area so he was more bummed he burned his buck tag, but it took that nubbin buck out of the gene pool. The right side of the rack was just a little nubbin, about and inch across and barely above the skin. the other side was a decent 3 points, no brow tines however

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

now what would you do if you shot a buck that had already lost his antlers? my dad was out bowhuntin one night a few yrs back and seen this what looked to be a doe coming at him but was grunting walked under his tree and had 2 red holes in his head!! and 3 days later my uncle found a set of antlers by the grain bins!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I know its a buck and it's late season, then I let it go. A couple of years ago I passed on a 4 pointer who was outside the ears. His left antler was completely missing and he was a mature buck and here I have him at 10 yards. My theory was that if I won't put the antlers on the wall then I don't shoot them (with the exception being the mistaken identity I described above).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i shot a one pointer the other year, thought it was a doe about 35 yards stopped didnt see the spike was covered up by the ear, walked up thought it was a big doe, NOPE and it was barley over the 3 inch mark so it was a legal buck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did it last year on opening day doe came wihin 60 yrds and I watched for 20min tring to see antlers well with a couple of bounus tags in my pocket it was a go. when I walked up on it I seen it was a spikie I have never made this mistake before and hope never to do it again. all I can say is that it was really tastey and dont regret it one bit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always know my target, so I can say that has never happend to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2 years ago, the same thing happened as Mr. Clean. Never saw the antler behind the ear, only had one point sticking up, couldn't see it. Looked just like a doe walking through the woods.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that's an interesting scenario archery stud..what if you hadn't had your eab tag yet, then what?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i shot a one pointer the other year, thought it was a doe about 35 yards stopped didnt see the spike was covered up by the ear, walked up thought it was a big doe, NOPE and it was barley over the 3 inch mark so it was a legal buck.

When I was younger I shot a fork with my bow one evening in good light and I thought it was a doe. I had a guy I hunted with all the time and I told him I shot a really nice doe (I was 15 at the time) and I needed help tracking it. He was the first one to the deer as it ran about 150 yards from where I shot it and he tracked in front of me. He asked me as I walked up behind him, "I thought you said you shot a doe"? I said, "I did shoot a doe". Well come to find out it was a fork. I even went as far as to say it wasn't my deer LOL. Of course it was but to this day I picture that deer coming in and I watched it for a long time. I never seen horns. Those ears can hide horns. though I've made sure it hasn't happened again. wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use open sites for both rifle and muzzleloader (obviously for muzzie due to legal reasons). I had this happen rifle season in '05. I took a shot much longer than I should have with the rifle I had, but I still hit right where I had hoped to. The distance at which I shot there would have been really no way to see horns without binocs, which I still haven't purchased (been on the to buy list since).

Unfortunately, it was a small spike instead of an ok doe. I'm more of a meat hunter, so it didn't really bother that I burned my tag, but it did bother me that I didn't know I was shooting at a buck instead of a doe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

About 5 years ago I saw a fawn with a doe right behind it, last 10 minutes of shooting light so I let fly. Found her after about an hour of tracking and discovered he was a she. Like Picklefarmer said, I thought it was someone elses deer. But since he was still warm and I was the only one in the area, it was mine. This was a week or so before the rut and the only thing I could think of is they were family members. Used up my buck tag and went fishing the rest of the season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jigglestick,

I don't know. Fortunately for me I had my EAB so I didn't have to worry about the what if.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thought he was as she. Saw him standing broadside to me. I was on the ground. The full spike was away from me, at least partially covered by the ears. Brush in the background also helped camouflage the antler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm glad that it happens to others also it did [PoorWordUsage] me off to use my buck tag but it also tasted really good also something to live and learn.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i guess live and learn???? Now i really make sure its not a spike but who knows could happen again

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

now what would you do if you shot a buck that had already lost his antlers? my dad was out bowhuntin one night a few yrs back and seen this what looked to be a doe coming at him but was grunting walked under his tree and had 2 red holes in his head!! and 3 days later my uncle found a set of antlers by the grain bins!

I believe that state license says an "anterless" deer, and thus would qualify as such.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've shot two bucks that I thought were does. Both were running during slug season. Both were opening day & we had a large party where tags weren't an issue. Neither of them were the result of drives. The first one a doe came through & I shot at her, she took off running & I thought I'd missed. Then this what looked like a yearling doe came running in behind it & I dropped it, much tougher shot then the doe, only to then see the doe laying about 30 yards in front of "her" in the brush. We all had 5 tags, but I was really surprised to find out the yearling doe was a small 6 pointer. He had a white rack which matched the snow & the background was all brush. He was much smaller than the doe. The other one was an even smaller racked 6 pointer who came running by me at about 25 yards & I had about a 3' opening in the brush to shoot through, the ears were up & hid the horns. He cut into the brush right in front of me & collapsed in plain site where I then could clearly see his rack.

After those two, I'm really picky about what I shoot at, as I've decided not to shoot small bucks, unless we've not had any luck. I let a spike with 2-3" antlers walk by at about 60 yards this year. It was built like a doe, looked like a doe, & I could only see those little pencil stubs when he turned away from me. I was within a second of shooting a doe at < 10 yards once with my bow, when I saw the short spike on one side hiding behind his ear, the other was broken off. It can be very tough to tell & honest mistakes can be made very easily.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with some of the comments regarding, "knowing your target"; but this can be a tough one at times.

I think shooting a yearling buck by accident, is a far cry from shooting someones horse, dog, etc.

I believe all "know" the target. The target is a deer. Most make very concious efforts to determine whether its a buck or doe. And something with 5 inch antlers hiding behind ears or whatever is a tough thing to determine at times.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Good luck.  Hope your efforts pay off.
    • I'll be getting out again on Tuesday with the bow. It has been very hard finding time to get out this year, between work and a 4 month old at home. Last time out I spent 12 hours in the blind and saw quite a few birds during the middle of the day. Had multiple times where I thought it was going to happen but the Toms wouldn't commit 100%. Making a small adjustment this go round and hoping things come together.
    • Was thinking for hunting and maybe put a plow on it to use at my place up north. Wouldn't be my main driver. Was thinking around 15K for budget but that was before I did much looking mostly on line so far. But might step up in price for the right rig. And a lot of that would depend if I liked the newer V6 engine and 5 speed auto or 6 speed trany and less miles etc. Just by looking at dealer prices on line I would think a guy could find a pretty nice late model for around 20 or less. I think if I bought a nicer later model I would drive it more as they look like they have made the interior a lot nicer and more comfortable than the older ones. On the other hand if I ran across a real clean older one with the in line 6 and not to many miles for the right price that would be an option to. The drawback to a newer shiny one it might take a while before I ran it down the brushy trail.  
    • I am submitting this bird for Sutty on his behalf.     Forum Member: Sutty          
      Date: April 28, 2017
      Team Name: Team 2
      Youth Hunter(17 or younger): No
      Turkey Subspecies: Eastern
      State/Province Bird was Harvested In: Minnesota
       
       
      Turkey’s Stats
      Beard Length 10 inches
      Spur Length 1 & 3/16" 
      Weight 22lb 4oz
      I certify that the measurements listed above are accurate to the best of my ability.
      Forum Member: John Sutton                       Date: 4/28
      Witness: Josh Tschida                     Date: 4/28          
    • Our MN hunt this year was just about as easy as they come.  Sutty and I arrived at different times, he was late, and set up on opposite sides of the field as planned.  I could hear the birds gobbling in the valley below in their usual spot, and they sat there a long time in the cold.  Sutty couldn't see because he was on the back side of a finger of trees because he didn't want to spook anything out since he was late...  Eventually they got down and proceeded to sit on the far hill for a while longer.  I could see a 6 or so males, but suspected most were jakes, and a few hens.     Just when I was getting tired of waiting, about 8:30am, I saw one gobbler enter the field and walk straight towards Sutty's position.  As the bird got in front of Sutty, another nice gobbler came into the field.  I called to him but he wanted nothing to do with me.  Sutty shot the first bird, and the second one didn't know what happened.  Of course Sutty came running out of his blind and scared off the second bird that he didn't even know was there.      Sutty just bought a new house and had to head home asap to help his wife with packing things, and his daughter didn't seem too interested in shooting her own bird this year.  Now that she saw how ridiculously easy it is she probably won't be interested next time either.      I figured I should get to the edge of the field the birds were coming out on, and as I started moving my blind I bumped some hens that hadn't yet come up all the way out of the valley.   I finished getting my blind in place and sat a while, but it seemed we had scared the remaining birds out of the area, or maybe they were just laying low out of the wind.  In any case I went to get some lunch and let things settle down for a while.     After a couple hours of eating and casting for fish that weren't there, I decided I would head back up to sit in my blind.  Just as I reached the top of the hill to see into the field I saw three big gobblers walking across the field.  I ducked down and ran around the edge of the field out of their view to get closer.     I crawled up to about 10yd from the field edge, as far as I could go without being seen, and started calling.  They liked what they heard, but wouldn't commit right away.  After maybe 10 minutes of me cutting and purring, and all three of them strutting and gobbling out at 60-70 yards they started coming.  I couldn't see them well through the brush I was behind, and they didn't want to walk through it.  If I was at the edge of the field I could have shot them, they were within 40yd.  They proceeded to do a big arc along the field edge back to where I had just walked.     After a couple minutes of not seeing them I picked up my call, they gobbled, and then I saw them marching in where I had just walked.  When I last saw them going this direction I had shifted to face that way, I was now facing the tree I just had my back against, which put my butt in a thorn patch and the barrel to one side of the tree.  The birds started walking to the other side, so as they got behind the tree I eased the barrel to the side they were going to come out on.  They started coming up the other side back to the field they were just in and were too close together for a shot.  Finally one eased out in front and I let him have it.  He tipped backwards and rolled back downhill, and didn't even kick until I went over to grab him.  27 yards with the range finder after the fact.       Both birds turned out to be very nice old birds with long spurs.     Sutty's weighted 22lb 4oz, 10" beard, 1 3/16" spurs.  I believe this is his best turkey to date.     My bird weighted 25lb 8oz, 10" beard, 1 1/8" spurs.  My best turkey by weight and age.     Sutty and his bird.        Me and my bird.  I shot from one of the trees above this rock I think.      
    • Got it done in mn.  More to come when I get home.
    • Go to a license agent and buy one for your desired season. Season C, is on process thru May 2nd. Season D, is May 3rd thru May 9th. Season E, is May 10th thru May 16th. Season F, is May 17th thru May 31st. Season F also allows anyone with an unused tag from earlier season to hunt this period as well.   Hope this help PF.  
    • How do the over the counter licenses work this year? I missed last season but would like to get out this year even though I didn't apply for the lottery.
    • What exactly will you be using it for? Driving around the country with the top down, hunting the back woods, fording small creeks?   Do you have a particular budget to stick to?
    • at times the prop will stop on mine, usually when I move it to turn, need to tear into it sometime, I have use fishelectronics for misc. parts
  • Our Sponsors