Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Dbl

First high ISO Basketball 50D

20 posts in this topic

Finally got a chance to give the 50D a good workout at two basketball games Friday night. Impressions;

1. The 6400 ISO shots are CLEANER than 3200 ISO on my Mark IIN! The 3200 ISO shots do not require an additional pass with noise reduction in post processing.

2. The focus speed is a bit better than the 20D/30D but no where close to the 1 series bodies.

3. Having the extra pixels to crop is a big plus when using the 70-200/2.8. I can shoot a bit further down court with out sacrificing quality. Big improvement over the Mark II or 20D/30D files.

I am posting two shots both untouched, these are straight out of the camera. I had a friend shooting with me last night and I gave him the 50D for the second game. He shoots a 5D and 40D. After we had the shots I needed I asked him to crank the ISO up to 6400 even though it was not really required in this gym.

My conclusions are I will have no problem at all shooting this camera at 6400 ISO. I wish we would have cranked it to 12800 but that will wait for next game. I will make up for slower focus by shooting more shots! This fast may become my camera for 3200 ISO and above shooting, exactly what I was hoping for when I bought the camera. I can eliminate processing time with the 50D because I would not run those files through Noise Ninja, with the Mark IIN that is usually a must.

So here are two of his shots completely untouched, straight from the camera nothing done except a slight rotation and crop and re-sizing for the web. They are just a bit soft and lacking punch because I have those settings set way down in the camera for JPEG. I prefer to control that in PP.

ISO 6400, f2.8, 1/640s, with the 70-200/2.8 on a 50D. Noise reduction in camera on high. Photo credit to Dave S.

431248387_EnQ8Y-XL.jpg

431245494_7XTqA-XL.jpg

True with any camera but shooting at these ISO's you MUST make sure that histogram is bumping up against the right side of the display. This gym has about a 2/3 stop difference from mid-court to the basket. You can see a bit more noise due to a very slight underexposure in the first shot. The background makes a difference as well.

For Steve, my friend used his 5D for one half and I must say I like his JPEG 3200 ISO shots much better than the Mark IIN, but JPEG results looked nicer in the 50D, not surprising given the processing in camera.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great shots Dan! I shot a game last night too. The first half I shot with my Mark II and the second half with the 50D. I was using strobes (still working on that learning curve) and did some comparisons on my own. Still haven't got the formula down perfect yet, but getting closer. I'll post a couple of 50D shots because that's what we're talking about here. I was shooting at ISO 3200 and had my 70-200L on. Shots taken at f/6.3 and 1/250th second. Noise nat an issue. Neither of these have had NN applied. A couple of observations. 1. is that we tend to shoot in a little different style and 2. because of the strobes my backgrounds are really dark. I've got a couple of games coming up next week and will have to play with the ISO 6400. One of the gyms I can't use strobes in.

I should add, the first has almost no crop, the second I've cropped out about 25% of the image.

GBB1.jpg

GBB2.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice looking shots Ken! I love the light falloff in these. Very nice work on the lights, no shadowing that I can see at all. You are getting nice soft light, bouncing off the ceiling? I would say you are just about dialed in!

Why the 3200 ISO? In your faster moving shots are you noticing some ghosting? The reason for dropping that ISO lower is to get around a 3 stop difference from your ambient, which it almost looks like you have based on the dark background. ISO 3200 should let way more ambient in than it looks like here.

For others that might be interested, ghosting is caused by the flash with its very fast flash duration exposing the scene. The shutter speed being much slower still allows the ambient light in exposing the subject even more. In sports of course we have fast moving subjects so the flash is one exposure and the ambient is let in from the slower shutter speed with the subject moving...we now have a second image visible or ghosting because the subject has moved. The cure is to lower your ISO to let less ambient light in preventing another image or exposure from appearing (Assuming your f-stop and shutter speed are already fixed).

You are obviously not getting as much ambient in because your backgrounds are darker, but what flash settings? If you use lower power with a thyristor flash your flash duration is shorter. High power and your flash duration is longer. Narrow gap between ambient and flash would give less ghosting. So are you using fairly high power on your flash?

I am normally down in the 640 to 800 ISO range at f4.0 and 1/250s. Flash power around 1/4 maybe a touch more at times. Just curious where you are at. What are your normal ambient settings in this gym, it must be really dark?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan,

As I said, I'm experimenting a lot. Shot some with ISO 800, 1000 and 1600 with both the Mark II and 50D. Had the strobes bouncing off of the ceiling at 1/4 power and at 1/2 for awhile. Just seemed that these dialed in last night for the best shots. More playing around to do. Didn't find any ghosting last night at all with all my settings. Indeed, the one adjustment I had to make was to "recover" as many turned out a little hot. So, will dial back again next time until I find the "perfect" settings.

This is a dark gym. Normally at ISO 1600 I have to shoot at f/2.8 and struggle to get 1/160th second.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is really dark! Explains some of those settings. Good luck nailing it down, looks like you are darn close.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some nice work here guys! I might have an opportunity for indoor stuff tomorrow as some ex-NHL er's are in town.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MM, here you go. This is the untouched file again. No processing except NR strong in camera. The second firmware update obviously addressed some high ISO concerns. There was considerably more chroma-noise in my early testing that is not apparent after the firmware update. All-in-all I couldn't be happier, this camera will do what I was hoping...give me good results at 6400 ISO. I will be doing some test prints as well to satisfy my curiosity.

100% crop

432257824_moRq9-XL.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks man.

What is the current firmware? 1.0.3?

I bought the mark 3 and will be ordering a 50D this week. I'm going to have Chris at Canoga pull it out of the box cuz I want to make sure it has the most recent firmware.

If that isn't enough,I found a sweet deal on a 600mm F4IS,it is scratched up a bit,but only $3500! I'm trying to get them to back burner it until I can save some $ but if I like the 50D,the Mark 3 will get sold,and that will help.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep 1.0.3. You've been busy smile Its no big deal if it is 1.0.2 the update is easy and painless.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That 600 is a real club. I dunno how far I'd wanna lug it from the truck-but it's a no brainer at that price,a little "L" touch up paint,and I should be able to make some $ on it. Just enough profit for a 85mm 1.2 [my next target] and I'd be happy! grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hate to tell you but you will never be happy! There is always one more you need!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan,

Meant to mention and forgot. Tried to put the new upgrade on the 50D, and didn't work for some reason. Downloaded and got it onto the card, but the camera wouldn't read it off of the card. Any thoughts?

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ken, it was very specific on the location of the file on the card, my guess is that is the issue. I will find the directions around here and e-mail it to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

but if I like the 50D,the Mark 3 will get sold,and that will help.

If you end up selling the Mk3, let me know, fella. smilesmile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, Dan. I can see it on the card, but I guess it's not in the right place. It makes a difference, huh?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As per the directions I have;

Quote:
Insert a CF card that has been formatted in the Camera into the CF card reader.

Copy the firmware update file to the first window that appears when the CF card is opened (the root directory).

Remove the CF card from the card reader.

I will send you the link. I've done a few firmware updates on cameras and this is the first one that required a specific location. Weird, but it did work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

dan, I noticed that the photo credit says Dave S.? is that the same one that does allprosportspix?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It has been a number of years since I was coaching girls basketball, but seeing that official in the background brought back a lot of memories. She was a pretty good official....sorry for getting of topic....Great pictures

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

dan, I noticed that the photo credit says Dave S.? is that the same one that does allprosportspix?

Nope a very good friend who does some cross business with our company, mainly a portrait shooter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0