Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
ZIGZAG

WHAT IS BETTER A.T.V. OR SNOWMOBILE

38 posts in this topic

Most of the time an ATV would be better. You would likely get more use out of it (outside of ice fishing).

If the snow is deep and/or it is really slushy on the lake, that is where a snowmobile is going to be better.

Would you ride either recreationally(other than for fishing)? Do you hunt and would you use an ATV to hunt with? That might help you choose.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The sixty four million dollar question !!!! Whats your budget ??

I picked up a sled last year for a grand and have been very happy with it, of course we got a foot of snow last Dec 1st. You will get as many different opinions as there are guys on this site.Both have pros & cons,whatever works best for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like the sled just for slush, cracks and pressure ridges(lot of that stuff on Red and LOW) . Not to mention sleds spread out the load better on thinner ice...of course I think ATVs handle the load and gear better then a sled ever could.

Always a tough call.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

get the ATV and put tracks on it...problem solved.

of course you just increased your budget by 25-50% eek

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a newer Skidoo trail sled that I primarily use for trail riding. Well, I like to ice fish also so I manufactured a bracket that allows me to hook it up to the portable fish house. I have used it for ice fishing to pull the portable probably 10-15 times. One of the times it was nice to have the sled, not an ATV since the snow was too deep. The other times I could have easily gotten by with an ATV.

Obviously it ultimately depends on how much snow is on the lake and no one can predict month to month/year to year. It just seems that the last few years there has not been a ton of snow on the lakes at the times I have been fishing them. I have had to use the sled on almost glare ice, which is not good for the sled.

I would figure a sled would be safer on thin ice since it spreads the weight out over more surface area. A sled would also be better when there is slush in-between the ice and snow because with a little momentum you could power right through it. Sled would be better if you have to or accidentally cross a crack.

Theses are all things to think about. If I could only have on it would probably be an ATV. Not to mention most importantly that it can be used year round.

Good luck on your decision!!

Matt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are only going to use it for fishing and plan to fish mostly in the Northern part of the state, I think a sled is the best option.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IMO.... for the all around unit, a wheeler. If your a serious Ice Fisher get a decent sled. We do LOW with portables and a permanant house, A snowmobile is mandatory for access most times of the year other than first ice. Just my 2 cents!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ATVs handle the load

I do not know about that grin I have seen some AC Bearcat "Wide Tracks" with cleats, haul a huge load and pull stuck fish houses out of the ice wink. I know what you where saying thoug grin !!!Pull!!!! grin

I am sick of my wheeler with slush and any deep snow. With the right Hyfax bare ice is no prob. You are getting threw with out getting stuck.

My wheeler sits during ice time!

I am snowmobile all the way! cool

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

An atv will be the most versatile for sure, but unless you put tracks on it you're going to be stuck when you get over a foot of snow. I have an atv, not a sled, and a lot of times it's great ..... but at times I can't use it and need a sled.

If you wouldn't use the atv for anything other than ice fishing then I'd lean heavily toward a sled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cost wise I see alot of sleds for under a thousnd but you won't see any atv for that price.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arctic Cat Bearcat for sure. I have 3 and we never get stuck no matter what the conditions are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cost wise I see alot of sleds for under a thousnd but you won't see any atv for that price.

Like my ride, not the coolest looking thing around but it is ultra light at 362 pounds fully loaded with auger and fuel(sled was stripped for weight). It has a wide track and fully tubbed out bottom so it loves slush, actaully eats it for dinner. It may not look the coolest or be even close to the fastet with break neck speeds of 60 mph but it will go just about anywhere I ask it...even across spans of open water.

pi5send1ym8.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like many have said, I have the wheeler for no snow conditions or for very cold conditions with a hard snow pack, but just bought a sled for LOTW because a wheeler generally sucks up there unless you like to shovel yourself out quite a bit.

Nice ride Jonny, how did you rig up the auger rack on front?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just recently got rid of my ATV and purchased a sled. The ATV sat all summer, and I couldn't get around in deep snow. I'll get way more use out of the sled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Atv all the way for me, but then I have yet to find a lake with enough snow on it to stop my machine. I also use it for racing in the summer so I get to use it year round.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you don't hunt and don't get yer jollies from riding a wheeled device down a trail, get a sled for ice fishing. Hands down. And rig up yer portable ice house to be towed. You'll go everywhere, certainly further than a 4 wheeler in a foot of ice and slush.

One piece of ancillary advice - if you get a sled that has slides and like to use it when no snow on iced over lake - get some "ice scratchers" that mount on your tunnel and dig into the ice to spray ice ice flakes on your slide cage to keep them from melting when you "gun it".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Like my ride, not the coolest looking thing around but it is ultra light at 362 pounds fully loaded with auger and fuel(sled was stripped for weight). It has a wide track and fully tubbed out bottom so it loves slush, actaully eats it for dinner. It may not look the coolest or be even close to the fastet with break neck speeds of 60 mph but it will go just about anywhere I ask it...even across spans of open water.

I just bought an 89 Pantera a few weeks ago for ice fishing. Looks to be the same as yours. You mentioned that it's tubbed and has a wide track and that you stripped it for weight. I'm pretty new to snowmobiles, was it already tubbed and had the wide track? Also, what did you strip off for the weight?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

pi5send1ym8.jpg

Jonny P, yer my hero, dude. That is a bitchen sled, slightly classic, and heavily functional. cool (Did I really type "bitchen"? cool )

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another thing to keep in mind is that the liquid cooled sleds get their cooling from the track throwing snow onto the heat disipators.Run to long without snow or water on top of the ice and your engine will get hot.

Around here you would be replacing skags and or ski's on a regular basis due to the parking areas being gravel and having to park so far away from the ice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd go with a wheeler just for the sake of using it in the summer for trail riding and work around the house. I just picked this one up a few months ago and built some boxes for all my gear so I don't have to pull a sled in at night.

Image009.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How well are your headlights gonna work on that? Looks like yah got room for almost everything on the quad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Lilac blooms are here, just haven't opened. Hearing some reports of good finds in the Houston and Lewiston areas of MN. I checked some new public areas today on the MN side. Could be decent later but too cold and wet right now. Will check some early season spots tomorrow but won't hope for much with the cold weather.
    • Nice!  Must have seemed forever waiting.
    • 6 months later and he is home
    • Three favorites at the moment.  By the time they upload, I may change my mind.
    • A few from Maplewood State Park on April 16th.  Non-professional, but they stood still long enough for me to get 'em.
    • You might be able to figure things out this week.  How big is your sump basket?  Is the  pump kicking in now?  Sit there for 15 minutes and count the number of times it cycles.  That should give you a decent idea on how much water is coming in.  Then figure out about how high the water has to go before it flows by gravity.  The spec for the pump will say something like that it can pump 2,000 gph at 10 feet of lift.  (the gph drops dramatically the higher it has to pump the water).  The answer to your specifics will give you an idea of how big of a pump you need.  If you match the size of the pump as close as possible to the amount of water your will face you can maximize the amount of time the battery backup will last.   Faced with this problem I took a standard boat sump pump and modified it so I could hook up a garden hose.  The I took an old shop extension cord and wired the pump so I could hook it up to a car in the garage.  So just prior to having Noah float by I could hook things up in the garage and be good to go for as long as I had gas in the car to pump up the battery.   Now that I am adult I bought a generator and wired the house to take care of things.
    • Inevitably at least twice each season I will leave the house, drive 45 minutes and walk some of my favorite grouse spots for hours and hours, seeing nothing.  Admitting defeat on that day, I will drive 45 minutes back home, only to find a covey of birds in the driveway...
    • Colonel E.H. Taylor Small Batch Maker's Maker's 46 Bulleit Glenmorangie Highland Single Malt   Copperwing Distillery in St. Louis Park has a nice smooth whiskey. Supposed to introduce a new bourbon in a couple weeks too.
  • Our Sponsors