Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
2 DA GILLS

Pointers & Cripples - Need some help

9 posts in this topic

OK - I am sure I am going to get a whole range of answers and someone will tell I am doing something completely wrong, but I am going to ask anyway.

Is there something I can do to help my dog understand the difference between a crippled bird and the ones I actually want him to point? At times he does fine with it, but other times he points the cripples and it is a never ending point & chase. He is in his 4th hunting season and I would estimate that he has had 300+ birds shot over him between hunting and training.

There are some different scenarios here:

1) Bird is pointed in grassy area - flush (dog has visual on bird) - shot - cripple - chase - recovery. Those are easy ones.

2) Bird is pointed in cattails - flush (dog has no visual on bird) - shot - cripple - dog still holding point - dog called to area of downed bird - cuts track - back into cattails - pointing game begins

He has been FF trained, but his pointing instinct is very strong - almost too strong. It is really only an issue with very heavy cover such as cattails (where I do a lot of my hunting). Any tips or training tricks I can use, but still make sure I maintain his steady points? I do not want to lose his rock solid points, but I am a bad shot.

Maybe my solution is to join a trap league next summer and become a better shot. The birds are being pointed for me - there is no excuse.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Having only trained flushers, I've always wondered when another owner of a flusher gives the command "dead bird". IMO its not needed but I guess if there's an amount of time from shot to recovering it could help to coax a flushing dog to work.

In your case you want the dog to do something that is opposite of what you trained him to do. To him the cripple is just a live bird. I know some pointer guys that will say that comes with the territory. I know one in particular that doesn't feel that way and has no problem commanding his rock solid pointer to flush in some cases. One scenario is just like yours, cripples in cattails. It sounds like the dog is solid on his pointing and IMO wouldn't do the following unless he was. If your getting him on that many birds it won't be hard to incorporate another training exercise with a command(dead bird) for that purpose, breaking off a point to retrieve.

Its just a matter of how you do that.

Start out with retrieving sessions in cover. Send him off like you do, when hes about to pick the bird up give a command (dead bird). Lots of reps there, and actually something that could have been done at his first retrieves.

I'd simulate a hunt and start out with a dead bird hidden.

If he points let him hold a point, then command him to retrieve followed by dead bird. To keep him honest I'd mix that in with live birds in your normal pointing routine.

I'd then change from a dead bird to a shackled bird.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First off, every dog can be different. My 11 year old gsp has pointed cripples most of her life. Sometimes she'll chase and fetch, but she's just as likely to point it. The new 8 month old just has a knack for knowing. I can't explain why.

That said, I do work on the "Dead Bird - Fetch" command a lot. Even the older female understands that when I give that command it's OK to break and catch the bird. Even on a bird that goes down dead and they are heading to retrieve I give the command so that hopefully they begin to put that command together with physically picking up a bird and bringing it back to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If he's been through the Trained Retrieve then he should understand that when the command is given he is to retrieve no matter what. That he is not suggests that he may need a refresher course or some situational training.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

gspman,

That is the response I anticipated. The strange thing is that he spent a month with a pro trainer in August and he said his FF was solid. That being said, I am not sure that the cattail scenario described was worked on specifically. Grassy areas - no issue. Cattails - problem.

This fall we just started using the "dead bird" command to help with the search. It has worked on ducks, but not as well on pheasants.

Thanks for the suggestions and comments.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure how my Britt figured it out, but when he hear's the shot and sees the bird go down, he heads straight for the bird and retrieve. Wish I could say I did something to teach him, but that credit goes to the dog. grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My setter Buddy points dead birds fairly regularly and I see no problem with it. He is very honest with grouse and that just carrys over to pointing dead birds. I do use the dead command but I am very careful with it because sometimes I think he is pointing a dead bird and it is another live bird holding tight in the same area.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Chris..... Frank is correct with regard to the "dead bird" command.

I use it with Belle and do not have an issue with her pointing a cripple. Need to start with training sessions. What is really cool about it is now when a bird is shot that she does not see, I can take her to the spot and tell her dead bird. She immediately starts circling until she picks up a scent and then starts her track if it is a cripple. You can use the command in the yard with a dummy and also when throwing out a dead bird. Then work up to a shackled bird that Zeus can see, fire a shot in the air and then send him with the dead bird command. He should chase it down. This should not stop him from pointing birds that have not been shot at. Hopefully her with make a connection between a gun shot and a dead or crippled bird.

We had a funny situation a few weeks back in SODAK. Belle pointed a rooster and I flushed it right in front of her. I then shot the bird out about forty yards. I sent her for the retrieve and when she got to the spot where it went down she went on point again. I started to walked up to her and a bird flushed to my big surprise. I thought it was the same bird, was completely off guard, shot and missed. I really felt bad thinking a wounded bird had gotten away. Belle then went forward about 5 yards and picked up the first bird which had landed very close to the bird that we missed. How she knew the difference is beyond me...

Hopefully we can get out in December and discuss further..

Good hunting.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had a bird come down alive in a giant crp field this weekend. As I was walking toward where it went down and where the dog was the grass in front of me moved and then froze. Thinking this was the bird I watched Dixie follow the trail my way and point about 2 feet from where the grass quit moving. I said "fetch" and she dove in and got the bird.

I think once you can get your dog to break point and fetch what it's pointing it'll be fine. This might come with more experience or you may need to do the situational training as mentioned earlier.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • little early fer that fish aint it!!!!!! I wanna see pictures of you camping come tomorrow morning when da blizzard comes thru!!!!!!!!!!!! nice pictures though!!!!!!!!!!!
    • whitefish maybe? 
    • If I understand correctly this only for bows. I have a crossbow and from what I understand it is considered a firearm. Is that the case? My son has a bow and has the archery tag.
    • so ... dillon has a bird to enter and 1957 is still hunting? looks like we are in good shape, but lot of guys still hunting in MN and WI, i assume   ended my season friday. got the blind set up before the shower started. it quit right before sunrise time and there was lots of gobbling on the roost a couple hundred yards away but none where i heard them close by when scouting a couple days earlier. a few distant gobbles on the ground, then nothing after the rain and wind picked up again. finally saw a hen step out of the woods about 830 and start heading toward me. soft yelps kept her coming, then out steps a big tom and several more hens heading my way but when they got to an opening in the fence from the stalk field into another timber, the tom paused, i had the bead on him, decided it was too far, and then they were gone the rain quit a half hour later and i ramped up the calling with some louder yelps and cutts. a few minutes later a head comes over a rise in the field and its a solo tom. he ignored the dekes and headed toward the fence gap where the others went, stopped and fanned without gobbling, but some soft yelps, clucks and purrs kept him coming my way. dropped him at 40 yards after stepping it off to where he lay, i kept going to where the other tom left the field and it was 55 big steps, so glad i didnt shoot went 23, 10, 1 but the rain cut loose again on the way back to the truck so i didnt take pictures  
    • If you were anywhere close to southern Minny I would invite you over and let you drive mine and show you the things I look for both in the jeep and plow since mine seems pretty close to what you are looking for. If you have any questions PM me.
    • Good luck PFUNK! Looking like that will be my next day out too. forecast looks good as well!
    • I think the TJ might be the best choice with the 4.0 which is what I did.I bought the plow used after the fact. I got the plow for 1200 but the wiring was not good nor was the mount so I had a new custom, heavier duty mount made at a fab shop and I bought a brand new wiring kit from Western. I also bought all stainless bolts for it so there are no rust issues with them. Wiring the plow was a task. I basically had to remove the entire interior including console, seats and many dash parts to run the wiring.   One thing to consider- There is really very little room for much of anything in them. Running new wires, adding a speaker anywhere or even having 2 guys, 2 guns, a dog and a cooler is a tight fit. The back seat works for kids but not adults and mostly I take my back seat out so I have at least some room to put stuff. Running the wiring to run the plow took probably 8 hours or more spread over a few days and for a bigger guy it's pretty much impossible to reach under the dash and run wires,connect to fuse blocks even with the seat removed.    But the ability to take off the top and cruise the gravel roads with no doors while hunting is not possible in basically any other vehicle except maybe a Manx Dune buggy which has also been on my bucket list and those aren't 4x4. 
    • Anyfish is correct,I will add you can buy a archery tag and hunt the entire rest of the season in any turkey zone. 
  • Our Sponsors