Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Cast Master

P-line vs Gamma?

40 posts in this topic

Will someone please explain the differences/pros and cons of these two lines. I honestly don't know much about them, but see that a lot of people are using one or the other for ice fishing. I have always just spooled up my ice rods with my "left over" Berkley line from the open water season, but feel like I can do better. How do the underwater visibilities compare? How about stiffness? Are these two line types good all around, or do they have specific applications in which they shine best. Best for pannies and walleyes, or can they be used equally well on my pike jigging rods?

Any info and/or comments would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Both lines are very good. I am not sure how P-line is made, but I can tell you a little more about Gamma(I am on the ProStaff)

Once the line is Extruded(how fishing lines are made) The company runs the product through Gamma Radiation, hence the name. This alters the chemical make up of the line creating more areas to bond, which allows the line to be more limp, yet keep its strength.

I cant say anything bad about p-line its a great line, but I have been more impressed with Gamma than I have with any other line in my life.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I second Gamma, but Pline Flouro-Ice was probably the most talked about line last year. I'm going to try it this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Deitz

Is Gamma a monofiliment line that is then treated with this process or floro?

What about knot strength/ease of tying?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gamma's a polyfiliment, which is closer to mono than anything else, the difference is that poly means many, whereas mono means one, and filiment is self-explanatory.

Gamma is much limper than flourocarbon, so ease of tying would be easier, but with such light line you might not notice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know the difference of the two but I have used Sufix. 3lb is all I use and I love the stuff. Never had a break off from fish unless I didn't retie which is my fault. There 1 and 2 pound is not for me. Doesn't pass my tests but you may like it. It's a strong and but limp line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Deitz

Is Gamma a monofiliment line that is then treated with this process or floro?

What about knot strength/ease of tying?

RR, Gamma is a copoly(most lines these days are), Gamma Edge is 100% florocarbon...

as far as your knot strength question. That is one of Gammas best selling points.. Far superior knot strength.

People could say I only say these things because I am on their staff.. But I truly believe in the stuff! Best line I have ever used.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

P-Line FlouroIce is a line I use a lot. Flourocarbon means invisible under water, minimal stretch so easier to detect lite bites, and stiffer. Maybe a little touchier to get good knots tied.

Gamma is a copoly, a blend of line types, with the best characteristics of each. Limp, easy to handle, easy to tie good knots, low visibiility under water. Whether open water fishing or ice fishing, I don't use much mono any more, I use Gamma copoly instead of mono.

There are a few lines and flouros that I've tried on my gear that I absolutely hated ..... and I mean hated. LIne jumping off the spool, line twisting and coiling, bad knots, too stiff to get good lure action or bite detection, etc. But I absolutely love ..... and I mean love ..... fishing with P-Line and Gamma.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was fortunate to get a chance to run some of the new Gamma lines as they first hit the market some years back now, and I was skeptical it was anything really "New"...but it proved to me quickly it was most certainly a superior new concept in line, and held up very well to serious use.

The Gamma Polar ESP Ice line is amazing user friendly stuff. On ice reels that I do run mono, it is Gamma ESP Ice for sure. I use a lot of Power Pro Ice line too, and as needed I run a Gamma leader. They work very well together.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i used p line all last winter on everthing i had and i really liked it i don't know any thing but it but i like it and am going to use it this year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's clear some confusion.

Both Gamma and P-line are monofilament lines and both are copolymer lines.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gamma also has 100% Fluorocarbon line, not sure if that would qualify to be termed a copolymer, as it is pure fluorocarbon?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ed, true, Gamma does have Gamma Edge which is 100% pure Foro, its in the dark black and gree box.. but they also have Gamma regular, but its just called gamma.. its a copoly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yup..the competition grade Gamma..good stuff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

just wondering how either of these lines work outside .do they stiffen up ? i tried, i think it was the p-line and when it got cold it really stiffened up

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's the real beauty of the Gamma Polar Ice ESP, it is flexible in the cold.

Pure 100% fluorocarbon does not play well in the cold, just too densely made. Makes reasonable leeder material but you get better fluidity of lure action with the ESP.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

gman, All lines will stiffen up. Thats all there is to it. The lighter the lb test the less it seems to get stiff. Braid lines will be worse yet as they will absorb some water.

I dont fish in a fish house all that often, if the conditions allow, I much prefer to be mobile and moving which leaves me outside much of the time. I use 3 lb test for crappies and gills.. 4 for much of my walleye fishing, 6 lb on a few if fishing a lake that has larger fish(mille lacs, LOW).. I use Gamma and dont feel that the line is too stiff... just my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the added info guys, I will be picking up some of both to try out this year!

One more question, does anyone prefer using floro when fishing light jigs in deep water? I know that the line is heavier than mono and will sink, but does it help (much) to get the jigs down faster?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

RR56- That about the only rod I have Floro on..I have quitea few UL panfish rods as that is my main target specie in the winter.. I have many with regular 2 and 3 lb copoly.. but I do have a couple with 3 lb floro, for getting ultra light jigs down in deeper water, thelure also has a different action that at times seems to help. Got to be careful when tieing the knot with Floro though, and Floro is much more expensive too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A lot of flourocarbon lines out there are copolymer lines - two or more materials in a monofilament line. Most of the time it's a flourocarbon coating over nylon. Only recently (excluding leaders) did floro lines come out with pure 100% flourocarbon lines. Flourocarbon line was just too stiff for spooling.

I used Yozuri Hybrid last year and will use it again this year. It's quite stiff and coils off the spool when it gets cold. But it's also very water repellent so outside fishing, is awesome with it. I will compare P-line flouroice this year.

In general floro material is more stiff compare to nylon material. When you get down to 2# line, maybe the more stiff line will be more beneficial at times.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just noticed that P-line flouroice has a slightly smaller diameter than regular P-line flouro. Did I notice wrong?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gamma is the same way Slip.. The ice lines are a thinner diam. I expect the companies do this to have a limper line.. I know with the Gamma, the diam is smaller, but so is the actual breaking strength.. Yet still rates higher than that what is listed on the package.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Deitz I still have trouble finding those 4# gamma ice line. I remember you said Thorne bros had them last year, but any idea when are the Gamma ice line going to be avialable?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • We spent the past week in Door County Wisconsin on vacation with 4 other couples and our campers. I had it all lined up for 6 members of our group to go out on a chartered fishing trip in the early morning of Thursday. The charter called me at 8:00 Wed. evening to inform me that the boat had broken down and wouldn't be fixed until later that day and there were no available re-scheduling opportunities until Monday.    GGGRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!
    • Well looks like the draft came and went without much fireworks, sounds like Fletcher didn't like any of the offers so he is going to wait to make a move. Hard to see us fitting under the cap or filling out a full team without moving Scandella or Pommers so we will see what happens.

      Of course drafting from the 3rd round on doesn't lead to many super exciting players but it sound like we got a couple midgets with some skill and several projects. Our big off season move might have been keeping everyone through expansion. 
    • My only concern is the timing of all of this. We seem to be loading up for a run in the next year or two but the Warriors are still sitting there stacked beyond belief.  Can we add enough and develop our young guys enough to be a legit threat to the Warriors.  Lebron, Irving, and Love barely made the Warriors break a sweat in the finals.  I'd like to see them time their final acquisitions to correspond with the end of the Warriors run. 
    • Maybe line up all the non-compliant VW's and gas 'em all out with diesel fumes. 
    • Glad Lavine is gone! Added nothing but slam dunks to the team. I've been out of town for the past week, so I was very delighted to hear about this trade today.
    • Not unless they ban the toothpick crossbow here too. Takes those beetles out clean.   
    • That's called seasoning. Two years ago I took a trip to Germany and we spent a few days in the black forest where I got to see some authentic old world smoke houses dating back to the 1500's and the amount of buildup on the walls, hooks, poles etc is part of what gives their hams,bacon and sausage their flavor. They use juniper wood for smoking. Absolutely delicious.  But yeah, foil, Pam and other things can help. You can also use a power washer to clean them.
    •   "We have found they do not like limburger cheese, hot dogs, or Makers Mark bourbon.  I am thankful for that."   Thanks for making my nite.  
    • Also woodpeckers beat on stuff to mark their territory.   I am pretty sure that there aren't any bugs on my metal downspouts.
  • Our Sponsors