Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Rippinlip

Record Book Antlers?

10 posts in this topic

Looking at all this antler growth out there and from reading on here, there seems to be alot used.

Do you think they will have to start putting asterisk by the deer in the record books that are eating over food plots, if that could be determined?

Seems to me we are growing alot of "steriod" antlers, is this going to cause a overwhelmig amount of deer going into the record books? How may it affect the min's in the Pope & Young and the Boone & Crockett books?

Just curious?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

imo it wont affect it any....to many bucks in other states shot over food plot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What about Texas where the feed them directly out of feeders?

Better put the asterik next to the guys name that hunts next to a corn field too. The corn those deer eat isnt any different in nutrition than the corn I plant for food plots. It will grow the same sized deer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't believe any rules will ever be put if effect for food plots. Pretty much no way to control or enforce it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea, then put "City" deer under a different category.

smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Providing deer with the opportunity to get at the minerals they need to grow big and healthy is a FAR shot from "steroid" antlers!

Setting fruits and vegetables in front of your children and saying "eat this, its good for you", is A LOT different than putting a needle in their arm!

Once you hear iof deer in the book that were injected with a growth hormone.... then yes.... we have a problem!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yeah, deer in other states shot over apple and grain piles.

the recent boom in antler growth also has a lot to do with mild winters. deer don't have to eat just to rebound from a drastic winter, as they are still eating healthy in the dead of winter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its like Barry Bonds and steriods, he never tested positive for roids, you hav to prove it, you have to prove some of these deer were shot over bait or food plots, some record deer in mn could have been shot over bait where in texas some record deer might not have been shot over bait where it is legal. I dont think you can throw things out there without knowing facts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you are refering to me throwing things out there without knowing the facts, i think you are taking what i said out of context. my point was so what if people shoot deer over a food plot. in NoDak, Wis, and Iowa, you can bait. although it is more or less called a feed site, not bait pile. I personally think we should be able to bait.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Youtube is the way to go. So many cool little self filmed fishing shows on there. Heck I have a channel myself where I record my fishing trips. Uncut angling is cool, I also like Peelindrag because he is out of Michigan like me. Screw those commercial filled, cheesy scripted fishing shows on tv. Times have changed in my opinion.
    • Krylon and Rustoleum both have aerosol primers for plastic.  
    • I had the fasteners they recommended but it still needs to be filled to prevent floating . I don't recall what spacing I used but was told later I did every thing correct except for the water .
    • I bought my first house almost exactly a year ago and am looking to put it in a garden which is kind of a new adventure for me. Since I don't have the best soil in my yard, I am thinking I am going to build some raised garden beds out of some 2x12s. I am looking for some suggestions on this. Is 12" of soil deep enough? Any do's or don'ts from people that have done this before?   I've never done a solo garden before, so I am kind of in uncharted territories. I want to make some salsa and possibly pasta sauce so what all should I grow? Tomatoes and peppers are on the list... what else?   I'm located in Duluth so temp/thaw wise, we are at least a week or 2 behind the metro still.

    • I think he just got triple owned, I just scored a ton of points in my imaginary troll game. YES!!!!  
    • I am making some bluebird houses out of PVC.  They need to be white.  I have painted some with Zinser primer but it doesn't adhere very well.  Any idea what I should do to get the paint to stick?   Thanks for your time.   Tom
    • I don't think Trump can do that much damage in 4 years, if he makes it that long.
    • Phony politicians of all stripes have reversed their position on the fence numerous times, since it is just a political football that is typically dropped once the election is over.     One of the obstacles is land ownership, and we are supposedly a nation of laws that stands for the right to own property.     In 2007, as the Bush administration was extending the fence, it sent letters to property owners threatening to sue them if they did not “voluntarily” hand over their rights to their land. The letters offered no compensation for the use of the land. Some intimidated property owners signed the letters thinking that they had no recourse. Others refused, and the governmentsued them for access. Although the government can—and did—attempt to use eminent domain to seize property from landowners, the lawsuits took years to complete (7 years in one case), causing substantial delays. DHS’s Inspector General (IG) concluded in 2009 that “acquiring non-federal property has delayed the completion of fence construction,” and that “CBP achieved [its] progress primarily in areas where environmental and real estate issues did not cause significant delay.” The IG report again: For example one landowner in New Mexico refused to allow CBP to acquire his land for the fence. The land ownership predated the Roosevelt easement that provides the federal government with a 60-foot border right-of-way. As a result, construction of fencing was delayed and a 1.2-mile gap in the fence existed for a time in this area. CBP later acquired this land through a negotiated settlement. The IG found more than 480 cases in which the federal government negotiated the “voluntary” sale of property, and up to 300 cases in which condemnation would be sought through the courts. Because the right of just compensation is protected by the Constitution, there is little Donald Trump or Congress can do to expedite these issues. A related issue is the impact on tribal lands. Although technically owned by the federal government, tribal lands are held in trust for Indian tribes, which federal law recognizes as distinct, independent, political entities. The Tohono O’odham Nation, which has land on both sides of the border, hasalready pledged to fight the Trump administration on building a wall there. In 2007, the tribe agreed to allow the construction of a vehicle barrier on their land, but the Bush administration then waived laws that protect tribal burial grounds, and during construction, human remains were dug up. If the tribe refuses to cooperate, the Trump administration would need a stand-alone bill from Congress condemning the land. Even on federal lands, it can take months to get various agencies to agree to allow Border Patrol to move forward on various projects. In 2010, two-thirds of patrol agents-in-charge told the Government Accountability Office that under land management laws, the interagency compliance process had delayed or limited access to portions of some federal lands. Some 54 percent said that they were unable to obtain responses to requests for permission to use the lands in a timely manner. In one case, it took nearly 8 months for Border Patrol to get permission to install a single underground sensor. Only 15 percent, however, said that these issues adversely impacted the overall security in their areas.
  • Our Sponsors