Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
IkeThePike

Decoy vs. Live

32 posts in this topic

Been spearing a now for close to a decade. Just a few questions to that may enlighten my narrow mind.

1) I always use live suckers. Usually the large-pike variety. Anybody else use any other type of live bait?

2) How do you guys feel about live vs. decoyed? I have luck with live and never with decoys? Plus live usually swims around by itself (less work).

3) Finally, I've been checking out these threads and saw some neat northern/muskie decoys. Wow, I have never even thought about using such a large decoy. Does a 16" decoy draw in larger pikes and/or curious mid-size 30" pikes?

4) I'm not sure why I didn't come by this site many many years ago. But I may be hooked now. Much easier on here than talking to the deadbeats at the local bait shop.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Been spearing a now for close to a decade. Just a few questions to that may enlighten my narrow mind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your input... However, I'm not really an "old timer" just been doing it since i was able to throw the spear.

I'm not sure i could find a large enough shiner? I'm not sure how big they get and if large ones are even available at the bait shops i shop. But for sure, shiners are must for me when tip-up fishing.

And good point. My largest pike has been around 13lbs... If I ever get one big one though I will probably take it and never take another. I just need one +40", not too much to ask for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i use both. two holes in my house. use a live in one and artifical in the other.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

usually have one of each down. I have had pike come into decoys and slide right by the sucker and not even bat and eye, then other times I have had pike swim right by the the decoy while I am working it and head for the sucker. Just depends on the day and the mood of the fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mrk seen what i do, and i ahve show alot of people that, and after people have seen my setup, i beileve there going to it as well.

I run a fake and a live at the same time, on the same line. The reason i do that is becuase i have all the movement on my fake decoy from the live when when the live is swiming around.

I never once have to touch my line, until i have to pull it back when a fish is taking it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, Bass N' Spear. Two on one line, genius! I'm going to go start rigging up this weekend. Do usually run the live bait on the bottom or top? Thanks a bunch!!

I'm still curious to hear stories of how a 20" decoy has worked.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i run the live on the bottom, becuase that way it will look like is swimming on the bottom of the lake.

Dude, you neeed to come to our Spearing Get to gether.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When and where? My schedule is kind of iffy at the moment. Graduating school this December and still looking for a job. Think I'm taking a two week sabbatical after I graduate and heading up Blackduck area. Ha...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2) How do you guys feel about live vs. decoyed? I have luck with live and never with decoys? Plus live usually swims around by itself (less work).

3) Finally, I've been checking out these threads and saw some neat northern/muskie decoys. Wow, I have never even thought about using such a large decoy. Does a 16" decoy draw in larger pikes and/or curious mid-size 30" pikes?

I only used a live decoy once last year, that was at the get-to-gator. I used to use a live decoy all the time, sometimes alone, sometimes with a fake. Last year I decided to use only fake decoys, mostly my own homemade ones. Would I have seen more fish with the live minnow, probably, but I get more satisfaction when they come into a decoy that I made.

As far as the bigger decoys go, I havn't used them yet. I will let you know later.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When and where? My schedule is kind of iffy at the moment. Graduating school this December and still looking for a job. Think I'm taking a two week sabbatical after I graduate and heading up Blackduck area. Ha...

check the post above that is sticky, says 3rd annual spearing get to gator. Here is the link.

http://www.fishingminnesota.com/forum/ub...g_Outtin#UNREAD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I rarely if ever use a live decoy. It's always been more work than it's worth. I carve all my own decoys so I have a wide variety of decoys to choose from to see what's working. A lot of guys will run one large brightly painted "confidence" decoy on the outside edge of the hole as an attractant and leave it sit still.

For the most part I run one decoy at a time. I find I have more success this way and there's less in my way when they do come in. Although I have been known to run a puppet show from time to time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always run a live decoy sucker and a red and white decoy.. The fish will always tell you what they prefer that day

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thats right browning.

For myself, i have always used them as one. The reason i have always done this, is that you are going to have action from you live decoy, to move the fake one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I first started 35+ years ago we never used live decoys, mainly used a red and white or some type of home made decoy. Used anything from a golf ball with stripes painted on it to a large dare devil without the hooks. Today I use both a live and a red and white at the same time. Most of the time I never move the red and white, use the live for movement. My biggest fish (a 42 and 46 inch) have come when using nothing but a red and white.

Everyone has there own favotite setup, so try a few different things and use what feels right for you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i need to post a picture of a "decoy" that my uncles used when they were kids. they said it drove the pike nuts, and even when they came through to hit it, and they missed, they would always come back to hit it again!! i guess as if to destroy it - on a mission!!! it was basically a red head and a tail made of stiff tinsel - like on a christmas tree, but it would stay out behind the decoy in the water. their original one was destroyed, and they all grew up and got jobs - they got out of spearing..... but my one uncle tried to reproduce this decoy from scratch. i will take detailed pics for you guys, but i first need to view the pic posting guidelines to figure out how to get my pics up....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so bass how do you attach the live decoy line to the fake decoy, just screw another eyelet into the bottom of it? just curious if there was something special ther that needs to be done to keep it swimming straight while down in the water. Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How far below the fake do you run the live decoy? Does it depend on water clarity?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I run two decoys on seperate lines. its work but it passes the time. I like a live decoy when it sits kind of motionless and then when it gets nervous you can kind of judge if something is comeing in and I will use the fake decoy aggressively jiggin it and this ussally draws them in sometimes they come in so fast theres no time to spear them but thats a rush in its self

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I run mine on the same. and the reason i do that is so the live deocy will make the movement for the fake decoy. I run my live about a foot off the bottom, and then my fake about 2 feet up from that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Bass N Spear, I have the same question as Cass Master. How do you attach the live decoy to the fake decoy? I remember from one of your past threads that you explained it and even had a picture? But I am not able to find it. Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

005_16A.jpg

Its not a very clean photo, which i can take another one once i get out. I tie it directly to the decoy right in the middle. That way when the live decoy moves, your going to have normal movement from your fake decoy.

You dont want to tie the live to long, becuase the decoy will swim up high, and if the live from the fake decoy to thel ive decoy is to long, then it will flip over the top of the fake decoy, and you will have nothing but problems.

The key is that if its clear water, i will shorten the line becuase i will have my fake decoy lower, and if its dirty, i will have it longer, beucase i want the fake decoy to be up higher, and the live decoy closer to the bottom.

Does that make since?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I have been meaning to try to stick a yote too whenever I was out I hoped one would show up instead of a turkey.
    • should have set up in the grass! Uncle went back for evening set up at a pinch point hen and tom came through to go back to roost but no shot!
    • Beside the fun of fooling a turkey and sticking it witj my bow,this is why I love turkey hunting. Slow smoked with apple on the pellet smoker. 
    • Does anyone have a water driven backup sump pump? They look like the cats meow if you live in town. Or does code even allow them? If they are not allowed what is the best battery backup ones?
    • Got out Saturday morning. Perfect weather. Jakes and hens. Had a new group of 6 hens come in with no tom or jakes.   Did have a yote come out of nowhere right into my dekes. 12 yards. Just as I was drawing on it , it must have scented me and booked. A second yote crossed about 50 yards out. Sticking a yote is on my bucket list.   All in all a great morning.    
    • Good season Wild, onto next year. Should be some changes but I don't expect us to do anything crazy. Need to sign Granlund and Nino and that will use up a lot of our cap space. Can't afford Hanzel and possibly Haula and Vegas will be taking a player off our hands. I'm more interested to see who can sustain or step up their scoring next year or if anyone regresses. Granlund, Coyle, Nino, Zucker, Dumba, Spurgeon and Brodin all had career years, those are good problems to have. They showed us a lot but I think they still have room to grow and that is what we need. We have a nice cast of vets but they are likely too old to lead us to a cup, they would be in more supporting rolls. Hopefully our now seasoned young core and continue to build on their impressive seasons. Always disappointing to lose, even worse when you can't score against your old coach but I like the our team and hopefully we can keep getting better.
    • I'm not the most techy 40yr old out there, so I will try to explain what I'm looking to do and hopefully someone can point me in the direction I need to go. I have a cabin in the Chippawa National Forrest, no phone at the cabin and our cell phones dont work at the cabin either. My teenage son wants to take the wheeler and go riding alone. I worry he's going to get lost or if the wheeler breaks down he can't call my cell for help. When we drive my truck around; the gps in it works all the time.  I know I can put a GPS app on my sons phone so he can track his route in reverse to get back to the cabin. But what if he breaks down?  Does anyone know if there is a gps app that I could "pair" up me and my son's phone so I can see where he is at? kill 2 birds with one stone per say, he can use it to navigate himself on the wheeler and I can see where he's at incase I need to rescue him.  Thanks for the help.
    • Hit the Red River over the weekend for the 2nd time this spring. First outing wasn't great with a handful of smaller cats all under 10lbs. This weekend was a different story as we ended up with 15 cats Friday night. 5 over 10lbs, 2 of which were high teens fish. All caught on cut river bait.  Cats were on the shallow side of the river. Water was high and flowing pretty good. All fish were caught and released. Great night of fishin w no bugs to bother us and very nice weather! Gonna give it another whirl soon in a boat this time. Have a look!!
    • I've never tried my booya poppin pad crashers Yet but are they really bad or just not as good? Just wondering.
  • Our Sponsors