Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
mrpike1973

do I need a fish finder?

16 posts in this topic

I mostly tip up fish for pike; Do I really need to blow money on a fish finder? Everybody has told me that I should. I would like some opinions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do you use a GPS? Do you fish the same lake that you are familiar with? How many tip ups do you fish?

I use my flasher when tip up fishing to set my bait, it saves me a ton of time.

I can also see how active my bait is without having a camera set up.

Hope this helps.

Ed

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If that's all you do a weight should be sufficient. I too use them often to check depth of bait for tip-ups but I would not say that a $300-$500 dollar box is justifiable for that sole purpose.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

use an up to to date lake map it would work wonders. a flasher is not needed for tip up fishin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi i only fish pike only panfish when the season is over im only able to fish a couple of lakes i just dont know if its worth buying a finder my last car cost 400 bucks so money is a little tight but if i cant live without a finder i could start saving thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If $ is that tight I would say no. Or just get in with a few guys who have them and ask them to try them. Im sure they would help you at least find the depth with their units.

They are very handy for tip ups but not a must have.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No need if money is tight. When fishing tip-ups a simple lead depth finder should work just fine. Like others have said, if you're only fishing a couple different lakes, just find contour maps and go from there. A flasher is not necessary for this type of fishing unless you have money to spare.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks for all the replies i'm not trying to sound down on my luck but its hard when your on a tough budget just dont want to go broke fishing thats why i like tip up fishing a couple tip ups small ice house and a auger your good to go i think some people miss the beauty of fishing it can be simple or it can be as spendy as you wish. i feel when i talk with some people like if you dont have the most up to date stuff your not a true fisherman. if you can afford it and enjoy it i think its wonderfull more power to you. there is nothing on this earth i love more than watching a flag pop up. i feel after your comments that if i can afford one some time great if not i'll enjoy what i have and be thankfull thanks guys and gals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agree with Mozy, especially if you are already familiar with the lakes you target.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is a marcum LX-1 on that popular auction web site now for a starting price of 100.00 and buy it now for 150.00, 3 color . not new but it works on a budget....located in PA

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never used mine for tip up's. My buddy uses his for tip ups and I can set one faster with out and we get about the same number of flags. When using big minnows they will swim out of the cone (in shallow water) and swim up so it is sometimes hard to set depth until minnow clams down. Just my two cents.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you primarily fish pike, than it is during daylight hours most likely.

A $99 underwater camera would be a option I would consider. As you can see key structure and learn pike habits...and have fun.

Jigging for pike and watching them on camera is a HOOT!!!!

If a economic flasher is an option the LX-1 is a good unit for the money.

Watch for deals on both units near Turkey day. wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If all you do is tip up fish, then you probably dont "need" a depth finder. However, I will not fish without one any more.. its my crutch, its what I enjoy most about ice fishing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"In that song, she'll be coming around the mountain, who is she?"

Mother Nature

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its really not needed if your just tip-up fishing, BUT if you had one I bet you would find yourself using it quite often and doing more panfishing with it than you expected. Panfishing is much more fun and productive with a flasher, I do a lot if tip-up fishing but I always am fishing for panfish at the same time for something to do while I am waiting for a flag. If budget is tight and you think you might want a flasher, you could go with a used one and get one around $100.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think a flasher is necessary for tipup fishing. Lake maps and a click on weight to test depth should be fine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Went out today in the metro areas without any luck. Didn't even see any ramps in the usual spots, and I thought they were earlier than the morels. 
    • Day 4 Morning   I think we were both tired of trying to call birds across private fences, so we decided to try going for the distant gobbles I heard when I shot my bird.   There was actually a decent gravel road that went into this area and allowed us to have an easy walk into where I felt the birds should be.   We got in early to try to get there ahead of any other hunters, but it didn't seem to matter.   Forest roads were abundant, so walking was easy.  We went right to the spot I had a bird gobble from a few days prior, and waited.     It didn't take long for the flock to start making noise, and we only had to move a little ways to get close to them.   As usual the turkeys all came down and went away from us.  They set up shop on a long ridge and seemed content to just stay there.   We had no easy approach so set up our own position on the forest road we were on which was covered in tracks.   Other birds were gobbling in the distance the opposite way, and when one sounded close we chose to go for him.   Nothing came of that little walk other than the loss of a $65 custom call...  On the plus side we found a nice deer skull.     Back to the flock, one gobbler would respond to a crow call, so we knew they were still up on the hill.  We made a painfully slow walk straight at them since they were high enough up they hopefully wouldn't see us.  When we got to the timber they stopped responding, so we guessed they went over the top.  We worked our way up and found where they had been feeding.  Just shy of the top we set up to call just in case they were over the lip of the hill.     We received an immediate response to some lite hen yelps and clucks.  A hen with the gobbler was not at all pleased that we were there.  We got into a bit of a yelling match with her.  She was coming closer, dragging the gobbler with her.  When I heard drumming I motioned for my uncle to get the gun up since he was still calling.  In a few moments I saw a tail fan cresting the hill.  He angled left, looked around, went behind a tree.  I heard him go into strut and drum...   BANG!           
    • Day 3 Afternoon   We went for a short walk into the area I thought I heard the birds gobble in the distance when I shot my bird.  We couldn't find any birds and were nearly done with our walk when I glassed across a cow pasture and saw birds up in some trees!   I quickly checked the map and found that they were dangerously close to public land.   We made a dash for the car.   The walk in to this spot was pretty short and very close to houses and the farm that had the cows.   We ended up close to the fence and I felt the turkeys we saw should be just below us.   Some whitetail deer spooked and then turkeys started filing past along the fence.  I counted four or five hens, but no gobbler.  We stayed a bit and crow called thinking maybe a flock got busted up.  In the end we just backed out without spooking the hens off. 
    • North Metro Bass Academy Custom Tackle is having a 15% off sale this week 4/23-4/30 on all custom jigs orders.  We are also running 10% off all of our Tungsten Weights .... Flipping, Worm, and Drop Shot.  This will be our last sale before the season opens - so get in on it this week.  Tight Lines!  All of our products are on our web page North Metro Bass Academy   [/URL] [/URL] [/URL] [/URL] [/URL]
    • I agree.   I have said in the past, i learn to be a better hunter when they aren't easy.  Turkeys seem to become an obsession if you allow yourself to let them get in your blood! Love the chase.
    • ya but its fun! It was nice getting out i am learning alot watching them and being out there gets me more experience since i shot mine this year after being out a total of probably 6 hours for two days
    • Frustrating buggers aren't they!
    • well gobbled like crazy in the morning finally got a hen to come out she came 1 foot away from blind. Then 4 more came behind her 2 toms and 2 hens then the hens went back to the woods and one tom followed the other tom stayed in the open strutting back and forth just out of range then a crane came and he strutted at that then a goose came and he strutted at that they all came out just out of range and cut to our side. They sat there strutting at each other and couldn't get them to come in. One of them came back started walking to our decoys once again just out of range. Uncle tried to get out and go through the dirt bike track he's currently laying on top a jump within 60 yards of them no other options to sneak he chose the wrong way to go should have crawled against the burn... Man these buggers suck going to change blind spots next time know where they roost and see where they strut on the property. should of had a fan decoy out I bet that would have drawn them in
    • Well our lilacs were just starting to bud out yesterday and I was thinking we should go take a peek today. Unfortunately we got 2 inches of snow overnight and it's still coming down! I'm pretty sure Hubbard county will have to wait at least a week to ten days with the temps forecast.
  • Our Sponsors