Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
gonehunting

Mr. Heater Big Buddy vs. Cooker

47 posts in this topic

I'm sure this has been talked about before but I need some suggestions. I am looking at purchasing a Big Buddy Heater. I have always had good luck with a cooker style Mr. Heater. The only downside is the hot burner being so close to the portable fabric(ie. door). Have not burned a hole yet but am waiting for that day. Does the backside of the Big Buddy heater get hot like the cooker. I am guessing not? Also, is the Big Buddy capable of sitting in a pool of water created by the heat? With my cooker there is always a 1/8-1/4 inch of water pooled up. I am kind of particular with my equipment and I do no want a Big Buddy heater that will malfunction or rust from sitting in a little water. If you know of some other posts comparing the two let me know. Otherwise give me your opinions. Have all the kinks been worked out of the Big Buddy heater other than the element blowing out in wind?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The back side of the buddy heater you can actually back it up and even have it touching the walls of your house. and then you can also put your gloves or whatever behind the handle on the top of the heater without it burning anything, the heat is directed pretty well forward. If you search big buddy heater im sure you will pull up some posts about it, latest is having the hose filter (personally i dont think its a big deal, but some have had problems) and the actual piolet light is up off the floor i would think about 3-4 inches so i would THINK that having water pooled up underneith wouldnt be a problem unless you go for a swim. in that case i think the heater is the least of your worries.

Hope this helps smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

on the top under the blue bar over on the right hand side it says search with an arrow, click on it and a search prompt comes up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heater Cookers are notorious for burning tarps, Buddy's are less prone to do this. Buddy's have low oxygen sensors so they have a greater safety threshold built into them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The heater/cooker have also been known to warm up the flooring of some suitcases to the point of it deforming. It's kind of neat to see it turn choppy ice into a nice clean clear solid ice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both. The cookers can be more dangerous, but I think they heat better. I've burned the tip of an icerod before after pulling up a fish. If I use the heater cooker, I always put it in a 5-gallon bucket to add a little more safety.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

anyone have any ill effects of setting the big buddy heater in a little bit of water??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so haad,

What do you mean you put it in a five gallon bucket. Do you use the five gallon bucket for transportation? Do you use it on top of a five gallon bucket, when heating?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No problems with putting it on top of a little water. Most of the key components are more than high enough so you don't have to worry.

If your shack is that warm where you are getting large puddles, I would think you are heating the shack too warm (unless you fish in shorts and a t-shirt wink I tend to only keep it warm enough to be comfortable with just my bibs+sweatshirt and no gloves. Nice thing about the buddy is it has a couple different heat settings, and the fan you can turn off/on to adjust for the conditions.

One key drawback to the Buddy heaters is that they don't work well out doors. Basically only useful for inside shack. Any sort of breeze and you will have trouble lighting/keeping lit the pilot light. They are also much bulkier/heavier then the cooker/sunflower models. I have both buddies (smaller one for the one man shack), I am considering picking up a cooker as a back up to the big buddy for when I go on longer trips when it is cold out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mines always in a puddle.

There where plenty of people that saw mine lit/working in a breeze at the Medicine lake metro get together.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use to have a Buddy heater but sold it for the Cooker and don't regret it. It is nice to be able to cook those delicious hot dogs out on the ice. The remedy I cam up with for not burning the tarp/floor with a Cooker is to make a L mounting plate out of plywood pieces and mount it to it with some nails so you can take the Cooker off and flip it for cooking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both, I always keep the cooker in the sled just in case I need extra heat or the buddy doesnt work.

I really like the big buddy heater in my opinion it puts off more than enough heat and its nice not to have the windows open for oxygen. It will go out if there is a breeze though, they dont work well out doors.

They cooker is a fail safe unit, I have seen some pritty rusty and banged up units before and they always light up, that why I never leave with out it. I always know you will have a source of heat then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Riverfish, I run my cooker on 1-pound propane tanks. I put a propane foot on the bottom of the propane tank of course, and then put the tank/foot/cooker all inside of a 5-gallon bucket. The top of the cooker still sits inside of the bucket, so it isn't so exposed. What's nice is that you can then put the bucket a lot closer to the canvas and not worry about burning it with the direct flames of the cooker. And yes, I will also transport it that way to allow it to cool down, too. But it doesn't take long with the cookers though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll have to look at mine again, because I'm confused.

The only way I can get it to fit at all in a 5 gallon bucket is to take the 1lb tank off and force the heater in sideways.

So you are burning it inside the bucket facing up and out?

Sorry my thought bubble is cloudy today smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both, and I use my buddy heater 99% of the time. I bought the cooker style first, but it malfunctioned and now it's more of a flame thrower than a heater. I don't know what's wrong with it, but when they work, they are great. What I like about my buddy though is that it is adjustable. I have also had my buddy heater make the pool of water, and no ill effects have come to it. It kind of has like round tubes that keep the main body of the heater up and out of the water and snow. I love it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Darren, my thought bubble is cloudy every day!

I just have it burning facing up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my grandpa is a manufactures rep for a bunch of companies one of which is mr. heater so we have both heaters and they both have drawbacks and advantages, in our opinion the original buddy is a piece of garbage, hard to light, once lit it doesn't stay lit long and it doesn't heat up a voyager enough to even take ur coat off but it was very convient and easy to pack in the sled.

the cooker is a great dependaple heater, puts out lots of heat, lights easy and puts up with abuse but the thing is crazy hot all over, you have to shut it off 5-10 minutes before you leave so it is cool enough to put away. and i have found that if you run a hose from a 20lb tank to the heater the hoses are usually so stiff that you can't put the heater were you want it cause the hose won't bend.

i personly run a standard sunflower on the top of a 20lb tank, you don't run out of gas and you can put it anywere with out having to worry about that stiff hose for the cooker but it is very bulky and you have to wait awhile for it to cool, next time my grandpa gets a big buddy demo heater i will have to give it a try.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I run the sun flower style Mr. Heater on a 5lb.

My mind bubble is pretty cloudy at the end of the night, but I am still running on all 8 cylinders grin

IMO that is the only way to fly during ice time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My cooker would melt a bucket LOL I made a few adjustments to mine and eliminated the cheesy 3 position temp settings to an infinate valve I can adjust to taking the edge off to roasting in -20 temps in my 3 man Eskimo. Rough guess I can adjust from 1500-20,000, tweak the regulator a little I might get a little more. Been running like this for 20 years on that cooker and replaced the screens 4 years ago and a thermocouple once.

To reduce ponding I either turn the cooker to heat up or raise the front a little by placing the metal scoop under the front of the frame. I also run a ceiling fan to help circulate the heat and reduce condensation and frosting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so haad,

I am with dtro, how do you fit your cooker/heater with 1pound tank in a 5 gallon bucket. Are we talking about the same heater.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the mr. heater I have would also not fit in a gal bucket?? I like the buddys alot because they are easy to use and have good heat adjustments for most occasions. The cookers are great but unless its cold out they can throw out way more heat than I ever need. The cooker also burns through the gs much faster

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry for the confusion guys. My bad. I've had my "cooker" for about 15 years, so I forgot the name. This is the style of cooker that I was talking about.

GNS-48249.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have that style cooker as well. I usually drill into the ice and set it in the whole. That way I don't have to worry about it tipping over.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have that style as well. but i use it to cook my brats. use the big buddy to heat. nice not worrying about burning everything that gets too close.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Those sure are pretty snowflakes..........
    • Misguided by love as pure as the driven snow.  
    •   Yep, am with ya......and most of us thank you. Should not be a difficult concept to understand.....except for a select Jv few.
    • So was I.  When I say "my equipment" won't be freezing up when I am hole hopping with the aid of my toasty warm Otter cottage, part of my equipment that won't be freezing up would be the ez ducer...   
    • Reinhardt was sincere, and I don't believe he was trying to sell anything,  He had a lot of knowledge about meat, and simply wanted to share it.   I didn't fault him for his politics, either.  He was simply misguided on that....        
    • I took Mickey in 2008. Bubbles 4 years later. Not too worried about winning as some on here .....as winning in  those years wasn't really winning, and so far, neither is picking the winner in 16, other than saying you picked the winner and "get it".
    • Had an opportunity to tag along with LeeKen to Bluestem Nature Conservancy and sit in a blind Saturday morning.  Thought it was unusual to see a deer with antlers late March.
    •     I was thinking more like Goofy=Pres. Trump
    • Murphy’s Law   I went out this afternoon trout fishing.  I questioned the wisdom of fishing on a robin’s egg blue sky day.  Trout shun sunlight.  I went outside to check the weather. The warmth of the afternoon coaxed me out of the house.     I fished a stretch I have done well on in the past.  I knew because of the bright sun I would more than likely not do well on big trout this outing.  Trout do not have eye lids and shun bright sun. When I got to the stream the outdoor temperature was 58 degrees.  I took the water temperature and it was almost 50 degrees.  That is well within a good temperature range to score some trout.     I hit the water at 2:45pm.  The sun was high in the sky and not a single cloud was in the sky.  I knew from experience that days like these I typically fished the shaded side of the stream.  There was no shaded side of the stream.      The fishing was tough.  I had lots of follows and flashes at my lure.  None seemed to want to commit.   I decided to look for cover for the trout.  I decided anything to throw a little shade on the trout would make them feel comfortable.     The trout had lock jaw.  I decided to target broken water so the trout would feel secure and come out in the bright light.  They still were bashful.  I decided another trick was in order. I was going to throw in the biggest snarly messes and let the lure drop to the bottom and give it a tweak to start the blade going.  Bang bang and I was in business.  This only worked in deep runs and i lost a few lures throwing into the mess.     I ended the outing with 24 brown trout to hand. The biggest was about 16 inches.  It was 5:30pm.  I usually get out at a bridge and today was nothing different.  I stood on the bridge looking upstream.  There was a sweet log jam just upstream of the bridge and it was in shadows.     I decided i was going to go just upstream in the shadows and cast a few more times. I was still on the bridge looking upstream. I looked at my reel and there was a loop on the spool.  This loop needed to be cast out if I was going to continue fishing.  I decided the bridge afforded the best angle and no trees in the way to cast out the loop in my spool.     I cast off the bridge.  The loop caught and dropped my cast about 15 yards upstream.  It nearly didn't land in the water.  It hit tight to the bank and I had a big snarl in my reel.  I looked down and saw my panther martin was barely in the water.  I decided to pull off some line and get this snarl out.  I made even a bigger mess.     I sat down on the bridge rail and started to mess with my giant snarl.  I again looked at my lure and it was barely in the water.  I was worried about losing the lure because of the snarl.  It was safe and barely dangling in the water.     I  really made a mess with the reel.  I was cussing it and trying to untangle it.  I lost focus on my lure in the water. I was peering over my glasses and really putting all my attention on this mess and I heard a splash sound.  I looked upstream and saw nothing.  I looked back at the reel.  I heard a louder splash and looked over the bridge at my lure suspended in the water.     My mouth dropped open wide and I stared in disbelief.  Me messing with the line caused the lure to jig up and down in the water.  This attracted a predator.  Not 2 inches from my lure was a giant trout suspended and staring at the size 9 gold panther martin deluxe waiting for it to move again.     My reel was still messed up so there was no battling this huge female trout on my reel if it decided to quit dancing with my panther martin and eat it. The bridge was at least 15 feet off the water and the idea of battling a monster trout from above was not appealing.  I worked frantically on the snarl.  It got even more messed up.     My fighting with this reel and keeping one eye on the giant female was nerve racking.  She still was very interested in my lure.  She circled it like a shark.  It was more than I could stand.  I decided if I hooked up with her with this less than optimal circumstances I would lose her and maybe kill her because of the bridge nonsense.     I decided to try to catch her another day.  The reel was non functional and i grabbed the line and lifted the lure out of the water.  What happened next is going to be relived in my dreams for the rest of my life.  The monstrous female brown bum rushed the lure as I lifted it out of the water.  It launched itself out of the water snapping at the spinner.  It was a swing and a miss. I got my wits back together and thought about cutting out the snarl and trying for her. I decided a return trip was on the agenda.  As I write this recollection I smile and cuss my circumstances.
  • Our Sponsors