Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
wildcatcreek

Who is the Strongest Fish??

126 posts in this topic

Me and a buddy were having a conversation the other day about our experiences catching large, strong fighting fish. After realizing how different our stories were, I started asking other people their experiences. Turns out that it's pretty interesting hearing all the different views. Therefore, I ask you what your experience is. What is the strongest fighting freshwater fish out there? Looking forward to hearing some good ones.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Big Northerns, not those little hammer handles.

Summer or winter they just don't want to quit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Panfish. Their body shape gives them an edge that other fish like predators can't match. They may not be fast in a sprint but they have power. Imagine a 20# crappie!!!

Let me at 'em!

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've never caught one put I'm guessing it's a sturgeon. Just watching them jump for no reason you can tell they are an extremely powerful fish.

Over a short burst though nothing is stronger pound for pound than a northern though. They are the fastest freshwater fish, and physics will tell you that on their runs nothing is generating more force for it's weight. It doesn't have the best overall fight though. It's a shame most pike in MN are kept when they are still children so to speak.

Shape is a natural resistance, it isn't a generated power. If you just didn't reel and let the fish pull shape would have no effect on the force generated.

Plus you can use the shape against a panfish. They skip across the water with almost no resistance....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree, I've heard "get the net!" over a sunny before.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Imagine a 20# crappie!!!

Let me at 'em!

Bob

Sign me up for that!!!

I would say my favorite fish to fight are big cats!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Me and a buddy were having a conversation the other day about our experiences catching large, strong fighting fish.

I would have to say sturgeon and then Flat head cats if we are talking Fish found in MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First of all, I've never had a brook trout (up to 12 inches) give me much of a fight, even on a 3 weight or an UL spinning rod

2nd, almost all northerns I catch just give a huge head shake, then you reel em in. Then when you're about to grab them and they take off like a torpedo. Not a real consistent fighter, and I've caught plenty of big pike, even on UL tackle

I gotta give it to bluegills. Pound for pound they are the most feisty, hard fighters out there. I've had guys call for the net with a 10 inch bluegill on medium spinning tackle before.

Sturgeon would come in 2nd in my opinion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Come on....Northern, Catfish.....I've caught a 20# of each and neither one of them have pulled out 400 feet of 20# mono on a run.....King Salmon rules this roost!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I give my vote to the mighty carp, especially if they have a little current to use. I always like hooking a buddy up on their 1st one, they are always extremely suprised that it can take 5-10 minutes to reel in a 5 lb fish and are usually begging me to take them out again as soon as we're done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not to mention, when fighting a fish in current, you are battlin the current almost as much as the fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have to say out of what I have caught it would have to be carp and buffalo. Those things fight hard. So do some of those big northerns they would have to be 3rd on my list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bushwac....

Imagine sinking a hook into this thing on the Brule.

164843.jpg

88 lber that made it thru the spawn out in California this year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pound for pound sunnies rule!Could you even imagine a 5 lb sunny.Then kings,then river smallies then the mighty red horse.The cats do well also.Dogs are also quite spunky.Ocean gotta go with halibut and flounder.I will let you know after feb how the tarpon do!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think we could categorize this debate.

In the pound for pound category, sunfish dominate that class.

This summer I caught a 16oz bluegill that pulled HARDER than the 3 pound LM bass we were catching.

Also, those 3 pound LM bass were pulling a lot harder that the 3 pound hammerhandles we were catching.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pound for pound sunnies rule!Could you even imagine a 5 lb sunny.Then kings,then river smallies then the mighty red horse.The cats do well also.Dogs are also quite spunky.Ocean gotta go with halibut and flounder.I will let you know after feb how the tarpon do!

lol

I think a five pound sunny would pull a person right out of the boat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The sad part of the whole thing, is if they would have somehow found a way to get one in OT to win Game 5, I think they finally got to Allen a bit. The forward D zone coverage was terrible in the game and for much of the series. Those goals that start out with a player against the boards skating in front of the net are a sign of a forward breakdown. The winning goal was on Zucker. It happens. I know we  were pressing a bit, but that killed us.   Now, for the offseason thread! :-) I would be willing to bet Haula isn't back. Ek, I think is going to be forced into the lineup and play a significant role next season. I would actually like to see Hanzal signed. I was a fan of the trade at the time and still am. I think as a 4th line guy he would be a nice addition. Perhaps Fletch can convince Pominville to waive his no trade clause to free him up for the expansion draft. I certainly don't expect Vegas to take him, and he wouldn't want to go there, but this would allow the team to protect one other player. We would have to eat some salary if we are able to ink a deal with another team, but I think that is doable. Russo actually was saying the same kind of thing in a recent interview.
    • I have a water jet pump and I have only needed to rely on it once when the power went out briefly. As floyd said it uses water to move water but it has its limitations. If you need it when the power goes out during a significant rain event its just going to make things worse.   I have a 1/2hp pump in my sump basin with a float on it. The waterjet also has a float on it set just higher than the main pumps float. in the event that the  1/2hp main pump burns out etc the water would raise high enough to hit the waterjet float and turn it on.   the battery back ups work great also but you need to maintain the batteries to make sure they are good to go when you need them and they are fully charged.   pros and cons to each but if possible I would opt to install both if you can.
    • Ihprop! Welcome to the forum and thanks for posting.  Just to get a better idea. Did you find it in a parking area or in the field? Mite help who ever lost it remember?
    • See I always use the poppin frogs for walking. I usually dont use the regular frog unless I am throwing it in really thick cover. Over the top of submerged weeds, timber, and docks I always use the poppin frog. For Spros, I actually think the poppin frog walks better than the regular one. 
    • I found some hunting gear yesterday and I figured I'd grab it and try to find the rightful owner before someone else claimed it for themselves. If you or anyone you know lost some hunting gear on public land in Waseca County over the past weekend, let me know.  If you can identify it, I will get it back to you.
    • Bummer. Battling a cough/cold here and the snooze alarm won this morning.  Hopefully I'll get out later this week.
    •   I use them and they seem to work fine. I guess with the poppin version I don't really walk them, I just work them in the holes and around other Bassy looking cover. I don't work them real fast. My guess is you would probably want to use the standard style for walking them.   Cret what versions did you test for walking, the standard styles or the poppin versions? 
    • Looked them up.   Personally they seem underpowered but it will depend on how much water you need to remove when you finally need that pump. The water powered pumps performance is based on water pressure. If you have 60+ psi then you can get 500-900 gpm and it looks like you will use 1 gallon of tap water for every 2 you pump out of the pit. For comparison I generally use 3/4 horse pumps at a minimum for the pumps which gives you something north of 3000 gph.   I'm not real sure if code and insurance even allow them so check first. If you have a small house and if the sump doesn't get used much it might be an option.
    • Just returned home last night. Had 3 Jake's come in at 7am on my 1st morning and decided to pass on them. Never saw or heard a Tom the next 5 days. Oh well maybe I learned a lesson. Good luck to all.  
    • Never saw a water driven pump. The ones I use and know if are the battery backup kind. They are sold at all if the big box stores and are around $300 I believe. They run off of an automotive type battery that has a trickle charger attached to it to maintain the charge. You have as much backup power as your battery has capacity and then that pump is dead as well so it's a short term solution.having a generator is very helpful as part of the backup plan.
  • Our Sponsors