Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Shoot2Kill

Gun and Bow with you in a tree?

14 posts in this topic

Just had a question between some co workers - what if you have an unused bow tag which you can take either a doe or buck with, and have a gun tag that only allows for taking a buck in our zone - can you have both weapons with you in a tree? Basically, if you want to shoot the first deer that presents a shot, can you legally take both weapons with you and shoot a doe with the bow, but yet have the shotgun in case a buck comes in first but doesn't come into bow range? That would be the only deer you could harvest in our zone so you would be done, but then you have both options since without the lottery doe permit for gun season you have to hold out for a buck. It's just a debate, is this legal?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I need ammo for this guy at work....both seasons are open, why can't you have both? Is there a specific reason?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure why the reasoning is.. But the rule is pretty cut and dry. You may not have a firearm while also having a bow. It states it pretty clear in the regs book.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Because you can't be in possession of a firearm while bowhunting for deer. I believe you can for bear but not deer.

Check the regs. to be sure.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Because you can't be in possession of a firearm while bowhunting for deer....

That is it in a nutshell. You can not be in possession of a firearm while hunting deer or small game with archery equipment. It is ok for bear (the hole a bear could eat you argument) but not for deer.

It is clearly writen in the Regs. book. A carry permit holder can not even have his gun with him while bowhunting.

Bottom line and end of argument ITS THE LAW!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: BobT
Because you can't be in possession of a firearm while bowhunting for deer....

That is it in a nutshell. You can not be in possession of a firearm while hunting deer or small game with archery equipment. It is ok for bear (the hole a bear could eat you argument) but not for deer.

It is clearly writen in the Regs. book. A carry permit holder can not even have his gun with him while bowhunting.

Bottom line and end of argument ITS THE LAW!!!

Well alright then. Neither of us have a reg book with us at work and didn't want to wade through them online.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm going to go out on a limb and say something different. If you have both archery and firearms tags and you have the bonus tags, I seen no problem with it. As long as it is in firearms season. You cannot tag a deer with both primary tags, so if you had a buck with your gun and then used your bow to shoot a doe and tagged her with your archery main tag. I think the whole gun with a bow limitation is in the archery season only. You can ask "Lcornice" about that he would know for sure.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is from page 92 in the handbook.

*********************

A person may not take deer by archery while in possession of a

firearm.

*********************

It would seem to be quite clear.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both tags and i plan to leave my bow at the house and if i tag out with the gun, take the gun home and grab the bow, thats legal but no way can you have both with you, not even in a truck together during season is it legal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I am going to disagree with mrklean on this one cause you can have any gun, bow, crossbow, muzzle loader in the vehicle at any time as long as they are legally set up for transport. (case, unstrung, ect.) That is stright from the CO's mouth. I asked this question about four or five years ago.

Froggy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...but no way can you have both with you, not even in a truck together during season is it legal.

Not sure about that part. I may or may not carry... and always or never have a firearm in the vehical. The only hang up I can see as a possibility is if you are transporting a bow killed deer while in possesion of a firearm. Think that part may need further investigation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • You'd think they'd give Stalock a look.  His overall NHL stats are OK and not that bad down in IA either....Kemps has to have a "great" night and have everything in front of him going our way to be good...he's not going to steal games for us like Dubs can IMO...give Stalock a shot in the nets!
    • 1 I'm on board, but not sure how you go about doing that. 2 laughably impossible 3 Sure, but it's not going to make a whole lot of a difference. 4 OK, I assume it would need to be replaced with something else though. 5 is open to a lot of interpretation as to what "make no sense"   None of that really puts the power back to the people though.   Do you still envision a representational government with elected leaders?    
    • The fumbling thing and also the blocking and catching the ball where all things that I thought he should have been able to improve on.  To me the failure to improve in those areas seems to indicate he might lack the right stuff upstairs.  With his physical gifts doing something like blocking shouldn't be that hard.  Its not rocket science, you just need to know your assignment and mostly just be in the right position.  Its almost like he couldn't focus on more than one thing at a time.  If he got the ball he could focus on running but not securing the ball, if he didn't get the ball it seems like he couldn't handle the concept of picking up a rusher if need be and then getting out into his route, maybe it was just too much for him to process at game speed.   Like I said he's probably the best runner most of us have ever seen but the rest of his game was so flawed. The fumbling thing and also the blocking and catching the ball where all things that I thought he should have been able to improve on.  To me the failure to improve in those areas seems to indicate he might lack the right stuff upstairs.  With his physical gifts doing something like blocking shouldn't be that hard.  Its not rocket science, you just need to know your assignment and mostly just be in the right position.  Its almost like he couldn't focus on more than one thing at a time.  If he got the ball he could focus on running but not securing the ball, if he didn't get the ball it seems like he couldn't handle the concept of picking up a rusher if need be and then getting out into his route, maybe it was just too much for him to process at game speed.   Like I said he's probably the best runner most of us have ever seen but the rest of his game was so flawed.
    • And trust me, these things will be much easier to accomplish than some progressive or conservative utopia. That is the real pipe dream.

    • Here are few steps, I'm sure you and Del will team up and say they are impossible.

      1. Remove the two parties from power.
      2. Keep money out of politics.
      3. Dump the electoral college.
      4. Dump our tax system - not worth our time.
      5. Dump old laws that make no sense.

      It might even be fun to elect a government who doesn't need to spy on everyone or bail out billionaires but you get it.
       

    • Bahhh ha ha ha ok there champ. More like you see someone else post up a clever meme and a few days later you claim it as you own, often failing to comprehend its meaning in the first place. Of course you do ok with a few of the easy ones.
    •   I prefer a unicorn utopia, but what can you do?   I take it you got nuthin on how you go about "returning the power to the people"
    • Look at it this way, every time a liberal posts something bad about Trump or the Republicans we are proven right. And every time a conservatives posts bad about Obama or the Democrats we are proven right. Is it really our fault that the entire political system is a hot mess? We are just here to point out the ever growing hypocrisy. I haven't seen anyone say they have all the answers, no one does but no amount of polishing those two turds is going to win anyone over.
  • Our Sponsors