Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
hoggs222

HD Antenna? Do I need one?

13 posts in this topic

I'm looking to get my wheelhouse ready for this winter. I've got an HDTV and I'm wondering come February, Am I going to need an HD antenna on the house?

I currently have a retractable antenna on the roof. Otherwise, do they make any of the plug-in HD antennas that are 12 volt?

Also, does anyone know of a site that lists the state of MN and the HD channels that you get in a certain area?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No you will not. The change in February is the switch from analog OTA (over the air) signals to a digital signal. This doesn't mandate people to get HD televisions or HD service. All cable and satellite systems will not be affected by this change and only older televisions without a built in digital tuner will need a converter box to pick up the digital signal now being broadcasted. The broadcast range is also going to be cut down to 50-70 miles of the broadcast tower. The smaller market (sister stations) are not mandated to make the switch right now, but some will. So if you aren't sure, check to see if the station will be switching and it is also a good idea to get a digital converter with the analog passthrough. Your TV should be just fine as it more than likely has a built in digital tuner.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cool, that's what I was thinking, but wasn't 100% sure.

I fish Mille Lacs the most and we never got good reception out there. Do you think that the digital signal will be stronger?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no such thing as an HD or digital antenna, although it's a common misconception.

What you will need is a standard UHF/VHF antenna to receive the digital signals. One thing to remember with the digital transition is that line of sight to the broadcasting antenna is crucial, and as LakeDocktor mentioned the distance is going to be quite a bit shorter than it has with the analog system we've used for decades.

What is going to be tough is that when ice fishing you are at the lowest elevation (lake level) so getting a good line of sight won't be as easy as if you were just putting an antenna on the roof of your residence in town. If you're lucky you'll be fishing very close to a broadcast tower and it'll be easy to aim the antenna and pick up the signal.

So while the pop-up antenna may work, it still may not have the height to get a good line of sight with the tower unless it is fairly close. I've never had luck with those pop-up antennas for analog TV, so a better UHF/VHF antenna on a short mast may be a better idea for you. It'll all depend on where you are in relation to the nearest tower.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BTW, what area of ML do you fish? Just general area such as north, south, west, or east sides.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting.....thanks for the input! I always thought the HD antenna's would pick up a better signal. What do you think about the antennas with a booster? Would that make any difference out on the lake? Of course, depending where you are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's the digital station data for Garrison, MN. As you can see at the top of the chart a few channels are within a reasonable distance. It appears they get further away in a hurry so there aren't too many digital channels available near Garrison.

Radar-Digital2-1.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My house is roughly 60 miles from the broadcast tower in Shoreview. The antenna is on the peak of the house (two-story) and mounted on a 6' mast and I need a powered booster to receive the various channels, so yes, a booster can be helpful. It is one more thing to draw battery power in the ice house though.

If my situation is any indication, I have my antenna mounted that high and still need a booster at 60 miles out. The elevation of a fish house antenna is going to be much lower and that 60 mile distance will get reduced in a hurry being that low to the ground, therefore you will have to be closer than 60 miles to get a signal.

It looks like there are a handful of analog channels you can pull in after the digital transition. Channels 16, 35, 48, 54, 33, 39, and 14. So you'll definitely need a UHF antenna for those.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From my experience, picking up digital HD broadcast at Millelacs will be marginal at best, and then only from local stations. I have my home set up for broadcast digital reception in Buffalo, and my antenna is pointed at the Shoreview towers. The old VHF/UHF yagi antenna would not reliably keep the signal to my receivers and I added a UHF specific antenna on a 10' mast in parallel with the old antenna which has made reception much better but still not perfect. I am on the fringe for reception at this distance even with the better antenna. I suggest that you invest in a UHF specific antenna at least if you want to receive signal on Millelacs and be sure you know what direction to point it. All antennas that use a bar with reflector plates will be directional. Check out a manufacturer called Winegard for the antenna, they have a good HSOforum that will help. Also check Antennaweb for recommendations on how to receive signal at your location.

After what I have seen trying to get decent signal at 40 miles from the Shoreview broadcast point, the new digital broadcast is going to be a nightmare for rural homes that do not have satellite or cable access. Their old VHF/UHF antenas will just be rooftop decoration.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm surprised you are having problems at 40 miles out. As I mentioned, I'm near 60 miles and get all of the channels. I'm using a Winegard UHF-only with a powered booster from Radio Shack. Without the booster, nada. I have some height on the antenna though, so that helps too.

Be careful about the UHF only antenna though. KARE11 and FOX9 are moving back to the VHF band and it may be pretty tough to get those channels with a UHF only antenna. If I would have known three years ago they were moving back to the VHF band I would have purchased a different antenna.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can get all of the channels and I do not have a booster on the antenna. My VHF antenna is stll up on the mast as well. I think it will be interesting when the switch happens and people suddenly find out that they no longer have reception due to distance and antenna problems. There is going to be quite a fuss.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My house is roughly 60 miles from the broadcast tower in Shoreview. The antenna is on the peak of the house (two-story) and mounted on a 6' mast and I need a powered booster to receive the various channels, so yes, a booster can be helpful.

I am 5.1 miles from this same tower, live on the 3rd floor of an apartment and needed to buy a booster. Needless to say I am not a big fan of the forced change over..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The name of the lake is long. It's between hawick and new London off hwy 23. East of Willmar. It's pretty clear water so your best bet  with eyes is early or late. Actually catch more eyes by accident fishin panfish.
    •   Not sure how the wife will like it, but it's kind of fun roughing it.  I know the area is pretty good for Bear's and Wolves!  And we do get a few Deer once in a while. The nice thing about being so far in, is the bait piles you can make! 
    •   With the 40 acres? Both hopefully. We still grouse hunt and deer hunt up there occasionally. There is a small cabin there but there is not a well or electricity. It is very primitive, but that's kind of what I like about it.
    • There are some pretty gnarly long roads and trails up in that area. I use to do some of them alone on 4 wheeler but not anymore. It's always nice to have a buddy with a wince along!  What are you guys thinking on doing with it hunting-camping?
    • Looks interesting. They have those nets that you put down a hole that do the same thing, but I can see where some people would prefer this more solid version.
    •   The land in question is a 40 acre parcel up near Remer. My FIL's uncle has owned it since my FIL was a small child and he has been spending time up there ever since. It's a cool parcel of land with lake frontage but it is hard to get to. The last mile or so is basically an ATV trail. When it is dry enough we can get in with trucks but the last time I was up there there were a lot of trees across the trail that would need to be cleared.    I would love to be able to own that land but ultimately it has to be an immediate family member. My FIL says he was supposed to inherit it because his dad used to be half owner as well. It is looking less and less likely that will happen because the current owner's wife is in a nursing home and the money has run out. We think there may be a lien on the property already but don't know for sure.    My FIL needs to talk to his uncle about the situation before it's too late but I think he is holding out hoping to inherit it. I hope that happens but I'm pretty sure it won't.
    • This is a good way to keep them crisp
    •   I was just wondering where it was since you said you needed a 4 wheeler to get into it. I know the woods up in that area pretty well after years of hunting, snowmobiling and Dual Sport riding all over. Not thinking of buying but just wondering where it was?
    • I'm not fighting with anyone.   Many ways to make antennas, and for receivers in cars wavelengths aren't all that important.   Class up your vehicle with a wire nut or a fox tail or whatever you like.  
    •   Still a possibility but due to family dynamics it would have to be a joint venture with my FIL. He is the one that would have to technically make the purchase and we would go halves with him but he isn't doing anything about it right now.    It may still be a possibility but I'm not holding my breath.
  • Our Sponsors