Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
mnbass2002

PSE X-Force or Bowtech Guardian?

6 posts in this topic

i am going to get one of these i just want so opinions on whats the better bow pros/cons your thoughts please. both bows are 2008.

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shot the X-force and wasn't a big fan. I thought it was loud (my most important criterion for selection of a bow) and had a lot of handshock. However, it was a bare bow and didn't have any dampening gear, particularly an STS on it. I shot one last week that had all the sound and vibration doo-dads on it and it was much better. It's lightening fast!

That being said, I'm a huge fan of the Guardians. I actually shoot a Commander, which is just a longer ATA version of the Guardian. I shoot a heavy arrow at 275 fps, which is plenty fast for me. My bow is about as quiet as I've heard and has virtually no handshock. I know half a dozen guys who have Guardians or Commanders and all but one have been super happy. Warning- if you have a draw length longer than 30 inches, I'd be a little hesitant- my brother, along with a lot of other guys on the Internet, have had problems with Guardians and Commanders with a longer than 30 inch draw length. Under 30 inches, the reports have been like mine- very happy.

Good luck with your decision. Most importantly, shoot both bows and see what you like best. Also, think about what's most important to you- speed, noise, draw cycle, or handshock. Then, make your decision. Good luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with scoot I also shot the Xforce and hated it (NOT VERY SMOOTH) ask yourself this why shoot more pounds if you don't have to and achieve the same speed? I am not a promoter of Bowtech, but I am hooked with the accuracy and overall performance of these bows and I have 3 buddies that now own newer Matthews and shot mine and said "I want a bowtech" and mine is a 2006 Allegiance and it maxes out at 60pds and I am shooting 265FPS with a 400 grain arrow which is moving and I shot my arrow through a chrono at my guys bow shop set at 50 pds and I shot 285FPS what does that tell you.

I have back problems and I have never shot this bow past 57pds because there is no need for it. I read an article a few years ago in BOWHUNTER mag and it was about the draw weight fine line and how not to cross it. For me if I try to shoot 60 pds I can,but I dont have the confidence that my arrow will go where I want it to every time like I do when it is at 57 pds (seems stupid, but just try it and you will see what I mean) sorry for going off on a tangent, I made a heart shot on a doe at 45 yds with a mechanical 2 years ago and my bow was set at 50 pds and it broke both shoulders.

If you need I have a good guy to recommend you to for a Bowtech, he shoots for Bowtech and is a very nice guy with a great business and I can not go there for a whole year and I will walk in there and he says hey Chris how the heck have you been and [PoorWordUsage]. To me thats the guy that gets my business in a heartbeat. Shoot me an email if your interested.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i used to shoot a bowtech and now shoot a mathews. i dont see any bow that is better than mathews in overal performance. but i do say bowtech is a very close second

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have shot both, and like the Guardian better. It is smoother and quieter. I would recommend you shooting both and get what fits you best.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its all about what you want in your bow. I will say that bone stock. the Bowtech will be quieter with less vibration. I just purchased an Xforce this year. It was kinda loud and vib'n as a bare bow. I added the String Tamer to it and its night and day. I haven't added anything else to this bow besides the stabilizer and sight/rest etc.

Its very quiet, no vibration and wicked fast. I also only shoot 60lbs, but that's cause I can get more power from the Xforce at 60lbs than I did from my Darton at 70lbs. My 380gr arrow is shooting 295FPS. I'm thinking of moving to a heavier arrow for more KE, but I like where its at.

I can draw my bow nice and slow with no problems. In fact I drew on the same deer 3 times last night before it offered me a shot.

The best thing to do is shoot them both and decide on the one you like best. If you get them both factory-ready than I'm sure you'll choose the Bowtech. Try to find an equally equipped X-force and you might change your mind. If you're in the metro and you''d like to try mine let me know. I have a 28" draw length. Oh yeah, the Xforce runs about a half inch long, so try to choose one size shorter than you're used to.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0