Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Zorba

Lake turnover in the metro

17 posts in this topic

Does anyone know when the lakes should start turning over in the metro area? How long does the process usually take and how do you usually change your approach to muskies after the turnover is complete?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The way this weather is, it's a total toss up. The lake I fished this weekend was 54 yesterday and kinda looking turn-over'ish and today it was 62 and pretty clear for this lake. It's gonna be a process this year...looking at the forecast, it might be a week yet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's going to be a long time. Water temperatures and wind have to line up. If it's 62 it's gotta drop twenty degrees yet, and a little wind action always helps.

It's a little harder to find 'skies when you can't work temperatures to your advantage. Post-turnover metro fish where you don't have the benefit of spawning coregonids could mean trying a number of different schemes. The submergent weeds are usually down by this time, so finding a good muskie ambush point is helpful...rocks, bars, points, any nonvegetation structure you can find are good starting points. Emergent weeds become important. Guys talk about fish just flying out of the rushes at baits, late October and November is the time to be hitting those spots.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

42 degrees before turnover? I don't think so. Typo maybe?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All lakes can be a bit different. But turnover typically occurs in the 54 to 58 degree range.

Aaron

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Then you have lakes like Mille Lacs, that are big, shallow and wide open. With the wind blowing the water around so much, it doesn't even have a turnover, as the water is mixing all the time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With the way many of the metro lakes are structured I wouldn't be surprised if well over half of them don't have a distinct turnover. Take Bald eagle for example. Fairly shallow without a big deep main lake basin. You add in a lot of heavy winds which will in fact mix up water columns, so you don't get that distictive thermocline you need for turnover. On lakes where turnover happens, I'm no expert, but I don't think you can throw out a specific degree and apply it to every lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This debate happens ever year. It all depends on how you define turnover. A few people think when the weeds die, which has more to do with lack of light than water temps. If you look on the DNR webite, which I have provided a link to, they relate it to temp and water density.

DNR Turnover question

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did notice dead grassy weeds floating up all the sudden. I found muskies there Thursday and for 6 weeks prior in that spot. Then Friday the weeds floated up and no follows. Across the lake the water temps were up to 58, from 55 in the first spot, with no dead weeds and there were the muskies again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looking at the DNR link posted above, they make it sound as though turnover is a continuous process until the water column is generally around 39 degrees. I probably need a better education on this subject, because like Aaron, I thought this process was completed for most lakes by about 55. Maybe da chise is closer at 42 degrees than I previously thought. Anybody have the definitive answer, and more importantly, how can you tell if turnover is "complete" on your lake, at least as far as muskies are concerned and the disorientation they experience or trouble finding them that we usually have during that time? RK, care to weigh in here? I spoke to Dan Craven a couple years ago about lakes in his neck of the woods, and what we had witnessed in late August/September - the bottom debris being brought up and floating as minner describes above, even though water temps were 60 or above - was part of his definition of turnover.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Turnover is a process, so I should clarify by saying "It's going to be a long time... (until things are turned over completely and you can work post turnover patterns). The process of turnover is already unfolding. It can get jumpy. I had mid-50's early part of last week and by this past weekend on Sunday it had shot up to 60.5. It now needs to get cold (clear cold nights (40 degrees) like tonight help, as does daily winds) and windy to speed up the process. I don't mean to mislead and make you think that it will happen in like two days. But when you get wind and cold temps it moves more quickly.

You'll know things are underway when the water clouds up a little (bottom sediments are temporarily put into suspension) and on some lakes you can get a little sulfury rotten eggs smell.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always thought and was told of turn over to be when the water clears and you begin to see debris floating in the middle of the water column.

I have never really paid much attention to water temps at this time, then again the boat I fished out of didn't have water temp on the depth finder.

Judging from what I seen on Flake over the weekend I would say that it is in process if not complete, clearer water and plenty of mid-column debris.

BUT... I'm an IT guy so what do I know...

RU

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

During turnover the water generally looks muddy as the rising water from the bottom lifts up sediment with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

water is to clear to be turned over, the shallows on waconia were empty but i did get a 40" near suspended bait in that 20 to 30 foot range. look deep for bait. Jonah

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was on flake last weekend, I don't think it has turned yet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i did get a 40" near suspended bait in that 20 to 30 foot range.

Throwing dawgs? Been meaning to get out there soon...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Decided to blow my lineup up at the last minute.   Combs Powroznik Defoe Kennedy Jones Jr.   I am gonna kick myself if the guys I took out do well. I just can't bet against Defoe, the hottest stick going lately.

    • Isn't it all illegal? Our gov used the 4th for toilet paper but I guess had Bush been in charge you might have something to be mad about. Now Obama always gets the free pass because that's your party right? There is no trusting any of these people and worse yet we don't get to the truth until it's far too late, usually decades later. We have two sides spewing half truths full of lies, impossible to figure it all out, worse if you trust one or the other. What I do know is supposedly wikileaks had both DNC and GOP emails, now if you think the right wingers control them whatever but I put more faith in them based on simple history and actions. What actions of the DNC or the GOP or CNN or FOX whatever news source you find worthy do you find credible in this day and age?

       
    • It's a garage listed as a loft build.  2x6 floor beneath the trusses to it will take a good amount of weight and I'm not putting much for weight up there more so just a bunch of bigger boxes spread out.  I will be good as far as weight goes.  Budget would like to be a couple hundred but would go to 5ish if I throw in stairs.  And the fire pole may be the best idea yet! 
    • Before you fill it up, do you know how much additional load the trusses can take and how much weight you plan on adding? Also, what is your budget?

    • So who should I blame then the Independents, Green Party, Libertarians, any other party not worthy of your vote? Oh wait, I should probably blame the Russians or the Alt Right or the Progressive? This is the problem, you still believe in the "system" that has failed us again and again. You can't fix this mess with these parties, or with people who think like them. All you guys do is fight each other over the same ridiculous arguments without end, then the media fans the flames and you double down on your party like they have all the answers. How exactly does a person who doesn't believe in any of it sway the masses who are programed to pick a side for life and stick with it no matter what happens? Sorry but I am no programmed that way and never will be.

      Honestly all we need is some common sense, something 8 out of 10 people will easily agree with when given a choice but we rarely get to choose such things. This stuff isn't rocket science, it is very easy to see the corruption. Go dig back in the Trump thread, I said several times lets get the money out of politics and we fix a lot of a problems all at once. That is something most people with common sense can agree to but you get people defending the status quo. I even got called out several times to put some ideas up, as usual I posted up some ideas that most are scared to put in writing and not one person responded because they are too busy attacking/defending one party or the other. We are a divided country and until we meet in the middle and figure out some very simple problems we will be stuck in this mess. There is no conservative or progressive utopia that will save us, until the right/left extremist settle down and meet in the middle with what I hope is a large but not vocal majority we will go around and around again. It isn't up to the politicians, it is up to us to force the changes we want, they will follow us, trust me they will bow down to us if we just find some middle ground. We already have all the power, we just have to agree to use it in a way that helps everyone, not the guys writing the big checks.
    •   Dry rub is a little too salty for me. I mostly smoke pike, walleye and jumbo perch.
    • Canadian fly in bear hunt?   Catching walleye all day and bear hunting in the evening is pretty spectacular, and it won't hurt the wallet too bad.
    • They had to do this. It was one of those mandates the Evil One.......the former President, insisted on, initiated and produced. Thus, they had no option but to throw it out....the Evil One had done it.
    • Can we put my nephew down one will be hunting a good deal. @Borch
    • Paul Ryan- He mad bro.
  • Our Sponsors