Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
walleyes12

For all you Spinger guys or gals?

17 posts in this topic

I am in search of some advice. I have a 6 mo old pure bred English Springer, I am debating between neutering or not neutering. I have no intent of breeding him as of now. My main concern is him gaining weight, is there any truth to that or not? My second question, will he loose his drive to hunt?

There are no other female dogs around, so I am not concerned about him running off, or should I be? Any advice would be greatly appreciate, I have never seen a dog of this caliber before, and I don't want to mess with it if I don't have too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We had our springer neutered. He didnt seem to be so hyper after. and didnt not seem to gain a ton of weight. I do not regret getting it done. And still hunts birds just fine

I am in search of some advice. I have a 6 mo old pure bred English Springer, I am debating between neutering or not neutering. I have no intent of breeding him as of now. My main concern is him gaining weight, is there any truth to that or not? My second question, will he loose his drive to hunt?

There are no other female dogs around, so I am not concerned about him running off, or should I be? Any advice would be greatly appreciate, I have never seen a dog of this caliber before, and I don't want to mess with it if I don't have too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have 2 English springers, both neutered 1 14years old and 1 2 years. No weight gain on either. One of them was a purebred of good bloodlines and was an incredible hunter. The neutering never effected his drive one bit. I would do it again if I had to do it over.

The second dog came as a free dog from questionable and unknown bloodlines. He's worth about what I paid for him. He's not a hunter, and I don't think he ever will be. I did have him neutered but that was more to satisfy the wife and to curb and roaming problems. I knew he wasn't a born hunter before the neutering so I really can't say that the neutering changed him, only that he certainly didn't gain any hunting drive from it. He's just a very submissive dog. He's good with kids though.

In the end it is up to you, however personally I believe I will continue to neuter my males.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I neutered Maynard early - and he's not fat at all. In fact, we were calling him "Bangladeshi Bhuddo" before I switched diets to Canidae. He has TONS of energy and LOVES to hunt - runs all day if he can.

If you aren't going to breed - do it. No need having him get off the urge to hunt if he smells a female in heat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the input everyone, I really appreciate it! Anyone other opinions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am very involved with training field bred English Springer's at one of the top keenels in the state... Having you dog neutered is the right thing to do if you do not plan on breeding... It will not affect the dogs desire to hunt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I neutered my Britt very early and he is not fat at all. Not really sure if it slowed him down much, if it did I'm not sure I could have handle him even more hyper than he is now. grin I would do it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My springer is gone now... 5 years and I still miss him... Anyways, If I could go back in time, I would have nutered him. Just to keep him home. Man did he run.

I just had my Lab spayed last week. She is not a runner, but hope this helps with the hunting. Now I dont have to worry about every dog in town comming for a visit or taking after her in the field.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

even though i don't have a britt, i have a female yellow lab. i got her spayed last summer and her hunting drive never changed! about 4-5 weeks afer her surgery she was in south dakota with me chasing phesants for 3 days straight. i did notice that she did put on some weight over the winter cause she hasn't been running hard but all i did was cut back on her food a little bit. now she is back to her normal weight. also she is a outside dog full time. hope this helps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would wait until around 18 months to 2 years of age to let the dog fully mature. For a male there are no real health benefits to do it earlier. I have heard that the dog will not fill out with the same muscle mass and may have ligament problems if nuetered before they reach maturity. I have also heard that they may not have the same drive, but it seems that may be more opinion/hear say after reading other replys. I do plan on waiting until my chessie pup is fully mature to get him neutered though. Just figured I would through the other side of it out there.

Blake

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a 9y/o male that was neutered when i got him at a a little over 1. He wasn't a hunter when i got him and i doubt he was prior to his neutering. He is a big dog at 65lbs, but up until the past year he has only been muscle.

I just had my female spade this year. She turns 1 next month and has not lost a step. Hunting skills are still questionable since she is still learning. She seems to have great natural instincts, but more to come after pheasant season.

Have you dog fixed. It will decrease some of the negative attitude and not affect hunting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Blake, I agree with you on waiting until the dog is mature... Studies have shown that this is the right thing to do.. The dogs growth will then not be impacted... My girl is 17 months old and I am waiting until she is at least 2 yrs old to have her spayed... My breeder also recommends this and he has 40+ years of experience and his daughter is also a vet....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Joel I agree with you also. Sophie had told me the same thing. I will be getting Jasmine spayed sometime in the spring at around 1 1/2. How is belle? or bella doing? I can't wait to get Jasmine out on her first hunt next weekend for the duck opener. She is doing very well. I can't believe how far she has come along, since I have gotten her home.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello Jimmy..... great to hear Jasmine is doing well for you.. She is a really nice dog!!! Getting her out on wild brids will bring the best out of her...

Belle is doing great.... Still running her 4 to 5 times a week... Have been really working hard on steadying her up on the fall so that she will be ready for her NAVHDA Utility test next year. Also lots of water work/retrieves...

I like you am getting pretty excited about the upcoming hunting season... I will be guiding in SD with Pine Shadows this fall... Belle will be with me so she should get into lots of pheasants. I also plan on hunting by myself and with my sons in both SD and MN... Should be a good year.

Keep me posted on how she does in the field and water...

Have a great fall!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks again for the input guys, I came to the conclusion to wait till hes mature then get him neutered. I really appreciate the advice guys!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I still have a feeling that it's based on old wives tales - I have a hunch that hormone levels among young neutered and older neutered dogs are the same.

For me - I'm glad my Springer isn't whizzing on everything like all the other male dogs I train with. You had better not leave anything laying around at training - it's going to get sprinkled....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He'll be just fine. If he's around other male/un-neutered dogs, there will be less of a tendency to get into a growling match.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The fumbling thing and also the blocking and catching the ball where all things that I thought he should have been able to improve on.  To me the failure to improve in those areas seems to indicate he might lack the right stuff upstairs.  With his physical gifts doing something like blocking shouldn't be that hard.  Its not rocket science, you just need to know your assignment and mostly just be in the right position.  Its almost like he couldn't focus on more than one thing at a time.  If he got the ball he could focus on running but not securing the ball, if he didn't get the ball it seems like he couldn't handle the concept of picking up a rusher if need be and then getting out into his route, maybe it was just too much for him to process at game speed.   Like I said he's probably the best runner most of us have ever seen but the rest of his game was so flawed. The fumbling thing and also the blocking and catching the ball where all things that I thought he should have been able to improve on.  To me the failure to improve in those areas seems to indicate he might lack the right stuff upstairs.  With his physical gifts doing something like blocking shouldn't be that hard.  Its not rocket science, you just need to know your assignment and mostly just be in the right position.  Its almost like he couldn't focus on more than one thing at a time.  If he got the ball he could focus on running but not securing the ball, if he didn't get the ball it seems like he couldn't handle the concept of picking up a rusher if need be and then getting out into his route, maybe it was just too much for him to process at game speed.   Like I said he's probably the best runner most of us have ever seen but the rest of his game was so flawed.
    • And trust me, these things will be much easier to accomplish than some progressive or conservative utopia. That is the real pipe dream.

    • Here are few steps, I'm sure you and Del will team up and say they are impossible.

      1. Remove the two parties from power.
      2. Keep money out of politics.
      3. Dump the electoral college.
      4. Dump our tax system - not worth our time.
      5. Dump old laws that make no sense.

      It might even be fun to elect a government who doesn't need to spy on everyone or bail out billionaires but you get it.
       

    • Bahhh ha ha ha ok there champ. More like you see someone else post up a clever meme and a few days later you claim it as you own, often failing to comprehend its meaning in the first place. Of course you do ok with a few of the easy ones.
    •   I prefer a unicorn utopia, but what can you do?   I take it you got nuthin on how you go about "returning the power to the people"
    • Look at it this way, every time a liberal posts something bad about Trump or the Republicans we are proven right. And every time a conservatives posts bad about Obama or the Democrats we are proven right. Is it really our fault that the entire political system is a hot mess? We are just here to point out the ever growing hypocrisy. I haven't seen anyone say they have all the answers, no one does but no amount of polishing those two turds is going to win anyone over.
    • So you prefer the status quo bobby? Wars in the middle east to to the tune of Billions or Trillions, corrupt politicians everywhere, corporations buying laws, favors and tax perks that pocket them money. Or do you prefer to save up for another gov bailout and just let it all slide because there is nothing we can do.
  • Our Sponsors