Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Dbl

Attn: Canon 40D users

10 posts in this topic

I would love to get some feedback from those of you using the 40D, specifically when using the camera in AI Servo focus mode. Your impressions on how well it tracks and how fast it moves if it moves off track. Shooting horizontal or vertical, what lens, how many focus points selected? What type of subject were you shooting and conditions.

Rob Galbraith has commented on the occasional erratic AI Servo performance on this camera. I'm interested in hearing from real-world users and their experiences. Thanks so much for any feedback in advance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan, Rob Galbraith, who I just quoted in the 5D Mk2 thread, mentions the same thing in that quote. I wonder if Ken has used his 40D Al servo much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've used my 40D for almost a year now, and must say I've been very happy with it. I have two 1D II bodies, and Al Servo is a tad slower than those, to be expected. Can't say that I've missed many shots because of camera problem - plenty because of operator error! grin Most of my shooting has been with either the 100-400L or the 17-40L. Actually, I haven't had any of my 2.8 glass on it because they're usually sitting on the 1D bodies. Might have to try them out.

Sorry, I usually use center focus only.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shot a fair amount of BIF this spring, mostly ducks. Took me awhile to get the swing down, but got a lot of good shots once I got into the rhythm.

Haven't used it for sports. Should really do that and give some rest to my 1D's.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Ken and Steve you are correct, it is Rob Galbraith who mentions that, not Canon. I've heard the comments from some sports shooters as well about this issue, taking it all with a grain of salt. I've also heard it is very good in AI Servo! crazy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan,

In my experience it has depended highly on the background. I've done a lot of waterfowl shooting in AI servo. I used to shoot with the Rebel XT then I upgraded to the 40D. In shooting against a blue sky background the 40 locks much more quickly and quite accurately. My "keeper" rate, so to speak, increased dramatically with the 40D. I have made it a habit of shooting waterfowl with the center autofocus point selected. Lately, I've been attempting a lot more habitat shots of waterfowl in flight. I've noticed the autofocus has a difficult time distinguishing between the bird and the background. This may be true for almost any body, but I can't really speak to it as I've never used a 1 series body. I should also qualify that the habitat shots I've been attempting have been with the birds at distance which really minimizes their contrast/separation in regards to the background. For the few shots where I have had birds in a little tighter, the AI servo did a better job of locking on target. All of my shooting has been with the 100-400, so I can't speak to the difference with an f/2.8 lens. I would love to get a 400 f/2.8 on the body to see what it can do, but alas I'm a little short on the six to seven thousand dollars one of those fetches. Hope this helps, I wish had a wider array of shooting situations and lens combos to comment on - but this is the best I can do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dbl,

I have only had the 40d for about 6 months,also have the 20d.

It seems faster than the 20d by quite a bit.

I have it on AI Servo most of the time and for BIF shots with 100-400L I have had it go out of focus sometimes and I have to focus on some trees or something to get it back good enough to follow the bird again,this is usually against a blue sky and I think it may be me loosing tracking of the bird, more than the camera.

Like mcary says if the bird is out a ways and crosses in font of trees, I have had it seeem to jump to the trees.

For the times it goes way out of focus, there is a setting (function III-1 I think)that will stop it before it goes too far, but I have not tried it yet.

Thanks

Dan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mike and Dan thanks for you experiences. Sounds to me like you guys are experiencing typical operation. The circumstances you both mention are difficult for any camera and tough on the operator to keep on target, especially if a bird is at even a slight distance.

I'm used to my Mark IIN but have at least 75,000 sports images through a 20D and a 30D so I've got a wide range of experience on both good and and not quite as good. I'm just looking at a 40D as a third backup camera at this time next to a 50D and the Mark II. I'm just curious what other 40D users have found using AI Servo and tracking.

I am only shooting 2.8 lenses so the performance of the focus system should be a bit better than say the 100-400. Anyone notice any difference in tracking when shooting vertical or horizontal?

Again thanks to all for their experiences.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dan, I can't speak for the 40D, but a significant amount of my 30D shooting this last two years (and the 20D before that) has been with f2.8 lenses. I can say that in Al servo with the center focus point selected the camera/lens is noticeably faster and more accurate with focusing. I've used the 70-200 f2.8 and 400 f2.8 on this body. While my 400 f5.6L acquires focus a bit faster than my 100-400 did (just enough difference to be noticeable), there's a very clear difference with the f2.8 glass. I have to assume you'd find the 40D/50D comparably faster/more accurate with f2.8 or faster glass than the slower glass.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I had the 100-400 for a summer on the 20D and switched to the 70-200/2.8 it did make a difference. I am guessing not much different than the 40D will be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The Warriors have an incredible situation. Incredibly talented players without the ego that typically comes with it. Most guys want to make the most money or be "The Man", these guys don't seem to care, they just want to win.

      I saw a quote from I think it was Klay Thompson, someone asked if he thought about ever leaving leaving to be "The Man" on another team.  He said something to the effect that it would be cool to be "The Man" and for it to be his team but winning is just too much fun.  
    • 70 HP Johnson motor.  Older model, but low hours on it.  Starts up fine, but when I go to give it gas the engine bogs down and won't come anywhere near running as fast as it should.  Anyone have any thoughts on the cause?  Wondering if maybe the carbs need to be cleaned.  If so, anyone know how much of a job that is?   Thank you in advance for any feedback.
    • The Warriors won't lose anyone that wants to stay with them since Durant is basically sitting back and saying pay my boys and then we will take care of business.  Hard to lure a free agent from them if their studs take such paycuts...
    • Score!! Nice find.
    • I still don't like the Hanzal/White trade.  I can see a team that is on the edge or coming into the playoffs as a 6,7,8 seed, but at the time, the Wild was 1st in the West and everything was going great.  I really didn't see a reason why they needed to change or bring in other players.  If it ain't broke, don't fix it.  They could have brought guys up from Iowa down the stretch to spell the vets and give them some motivation.   I'd like to know what Baby Boudreau wants to change or what he would like to see on the team. It would be nice to have somebody that really knows and wants to work the front of the net.  Parise is the closest thing we have to that and that isn't good for his longevity.  Be nice if Coyle embraced a role like that and used his size out front.  
    • Probably because most people wouldn't sell one of these for that much. I'm not sure why they did and well I didn't ask. Maybe they didn't like it as even being a older grill it had hardly been used and looks like new. I already had a Holland Companion grill that works great but this is even better. 
    • Skol!  I'm excited to see how Cooks pans out.  He seems legit so far!  What was the deal with KFAN ditching the rubechat forums?  I know the political page could get a little overheated at times but the others seemed pretty tame.  Too bad! 
    • Wow!! Now THAT's a deal!!!!!!! Why can't I find stuff like that?! 
    • Well not exactly new. Found this at a yard sale for $40.     
  • Our Sponsors