Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
fishinmajishin

Bait for carp

6 posts in this topic

Figured I'd ask the experts in the carp dept. I was walleye fishing out on Clearwater lake(Wright Co) Sunday morning and hooked into something really huge. I have seen many carp in the 30lb + class over many years of fishing there. I was pulling a 3-4" sucker minnow on a lindy rig outside the weed edge. I figured at the moment I hooked it my minnow was in about 18-20' at the bottom of the break. I had it on for maybe 4-5 minutes, and the hook came out. Had my drag right and my line/knots were good. It didn't really run much, just some head-shaking. Wasn't snagged on weeds either. Well anyway, my question is will carp take a 3-4" sucker minnow?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, carp will take meat...i was surprised about that myself till one day, my friends were hitting walleyes every 5 minutes on 3" fatheads and I some how get a gut hooked carp. But whats suprising that it didn't run. I' haven't caught any carp that didn't run. But then again I've never caught anything over 10lb. Sounds more like an eye to me...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I highly doubt that it was a carp. The reason being is that they have very small mouths. Like stated above carp also make long runs, even smaller ones.

You could have snagged a carp on its fin, underside, etc. I've snagged small carp(4-5lbs)that fought like they were a lot bigger. Maybe it was a catfish?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I doubt they'd take a minnow that size,too. I caught a 30 lber on lake Reno on a crawler 5 years ago. Enormous! I truly believe that there is a 30 lb pike in Clearwater Lake. The old timers spearing out there claim they've seen them, but they wont come into the hole. The fish I hooked took it like a walleye, and the head shakin it was doing tells me it wasn't snagged. I know what a 20 lb northern and a 10 lb walleye feel like on the line, and this one was WAY bigger. No comparison. Oh, and no catfish in Clearwater that I've ever heard about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Doubt it was a Carp. They are omnivores, but that is limited to mostly nightcrawlers/other worms, small crustaceans, and insects. I don't think a Carp could fit that big of a sucker minnow in it's mouth.

It could have been a very large Northern, or a smaller sized fish that was tangled in the weeds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've seen the carp in the tank at Cabela's chase down some pretty big sucker minnows. I wouldn't believe it if I hadn't seen it. I still doubt it was a carp, though, unless you snagged it, which is a very real possibility.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Does anyone have any good ideas, memories, experiences with any hunting trips that they would like to share?  My dad is turning 60 in a year and a half and I would really like to plan a once in a life trip that I can buy him.  That being said, I can not spend 20 grand on a 2 man moose hunt in Alaska and that is being generous on the cost of that one, more like 30 plus.   Looking for a moose, caribou like trip.  He has shot a big muley in the past and an elk, so that may not be top on his list anymore.   Just looking for ideas.  Thanks much.
    • Just for fun I created a group for HSO on http://www.pickemhockey.com/bracket/index.php Group Name: HSOHockey2017
      Password: HOCKEY2017
    • Have not been around here much but always enjoy the "Turkey Talk" Count me in. Hunting Minnesota and Wisconsin. Archery for both.  
    • I put my feeders out 1st of May usually. Such a neat bird. We usually only have a few so they are territorial here. Fun to watch one guard a feeder and then zip down when another one comes. Maybe they get along in bigger numbers?   Up north at daughters inlaws on a lake the neighbors have 4 feeders under a big pine and usually a bunch of hummers. Saw about 15 one time and they got along fine. Pretty neat. 
    •   So that's the evidence you have about illegal wiretaps that apparently nobody else has besides Trump?  That Obama's a bad (or sick) guy?   Try harder.   
    • Yup, everytime i call you or del out to put up the truth about your own bodies, you dodge. Wouldn't that be the ultimate proof that your way of addressing personal health and wellness is more effective in preventing and healing?  I think you guys have an idea from what you've been told and not what you bring yourself to learn and you never put anything to use so, who are you really to share your opinion? A couple of blowhards, thats who.
    • What crankbaits do you like for the 7-9ft range?   Looking for something that casts/have action like a DT-10, but doesn't run quite as deep. I have some SK series 4, but they have the wider wobble which sometimes I don't want. The SK series 3's just don't cast that far, especially in a wind. Same with some others, they always seem to be smaller in this range.   Thanks. 
    •     Ok, I think I need to clarify my statement. My belief is they would be better off in letting ObamaCare collapse on it's own than passing "Obamacare part 2." My first choice would be to just repeal it. Then I suppose a debate can happen  
    •   Ryan's bill is a direct taxpayer subsidy to the healthcare industry, via the insurance companies.  I think we have enough experience with subsidies to know that the outcome generally isn't good with that.   Probably the best thing to do is just repeal the ACA, and hand it back to the healthcare industry.  But that isn't likely to happen because there is just too much money involved.   Like any other slippery slope, the sledding is pretty good going downhill - not so easy going back up...
  • Our Sponsors