Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Wish-I-Were-Fishn

Is a RV a money pit

28 posts in this topic

Was looking at RV's on hsolist. Lots of good deals, but I'm wondering about the overall cost of ownership considering maintenance.

I would think a trailer, or 5th wheel would be less expensive to maintain than a motor home. I was blown away by one guys listing of a nice motor home that listed all of the things both he and the previous owner had replaced, or repaired in it.

Your thoughts please.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

heres my story. i grew up with a cabin in nortern mn. got remarried started to do tent camping. was ok. good friend owns campground, bought a $2500 older camper to try out on a permenent site. loved it. 3 years ago sold it bought a 3 year old 5th wheel. love it even more. did a lot of repairs on old camper but it WAS OLDER. have done a few small repairs on new one,standard maintence stuff mianly. guess my point is if you put a camper on a seasonal lot you shouldnt have as many repairs as one that gets moved every weekend because its not bouncing down the road and eveything is jigglin and vibrating. personally i wouldnt own motorhome but to each his own, and i think there are good deals from private owners. this is my opinion and hope it helped. by the way we still have cabin will give up camper if it gets to that point.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had a motorhome and sold it for a 5th wheel and truck. Way harder to work on a motorhome if you have problems compared to truck, and it is easier to find someone experienced on working on trucks than motorhomes. Biggest issue is wiring, they are kinda merged together and very hard to troubleshoot issues.

I agree with what glen said about maintaining an RV, if you are moving it around especially on bouncy dirt roads expect more maintenance no matter what you buy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought an 01 travel trailer 5 years ago. have not spent more than $100 on maintainance. I wash it in the spring, wax it, treat the rubber roof once a year and wash it in the fall and put it away. And we use the heck out of it!! After this weekend, we'll have spend probably a total more than 30 nights a summer in it. it's not on a seasonal, we take it wherever we go. insurance is cheap as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

what do you do to treat your rubber roof? i just recently caulked the seams but never treated other parts of the roof.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you can get a bottle of rubber roof cleaner/treatment at wal-mart. just mix with water, scrub it on and rinse it off. it will keep the rubber from drying and cracking. i do it once a year

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thanks i will need to do that. i already pressure washed it off. i assume i could get that other places other than wal-mart. i have issues buying at wal-mart.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes, you can also get it at any camping store, like camping world, or you should also be able to get it at gander...etc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biggest issue is wiring, they are kinda merged together and very hard to troubleshoot issues.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What about wall construction?

I know some trailers use aluminum skinned wall panels with studs and others use a foam core. Which is better?

Also, what brands are good in a trailer, motor home, and 5th wheel?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

C'mon fellas. K.I.S.S. Answer his original question.

"Is a RV a money pit"

Yes. The Point cannot be argued. You'd better love RVing, and do it often enough to justify the expense.

RVing is a money pit. Fun, but a money pit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The entire charging systems for both cab and the coach mix together on the same blocks, all the leads come in to the cab/coach in the same bundle, and until you have to troubleshoot an electrical problem, you won't see what I mean. I had a problem that I worked on for a while and wound having a mechanic work on it and even he said that was one of the more miserable things he ever had to work on.

We were camping last spring and a guy from out of state was having engine electrical issues and he had a hard time getting anyone to even work on it. The RV dealers don't work on the engine wiring and the dealers don't like to work with the coach and engine wiring mix. He spend a whole morning trying to find someone North of Duluth to work on his rig.

Quote:
I have seen some of them really falling apart. It could be lack of maintenance or just because they are cheaper models. Either way, I don't see much difference in quality comparing apples to apples on motorhomes vs. 5th wheels. When you go out and actually start looking at them, you will see the difference in quality and if it is used, the difference in how it was taken care of.

I know people that have motorhomes that are in pretty poor shape too. Some are poor quality and some are just cuz people don't fix things as things break. Fact is trailer or motorhome have things that move or get bounced around and things that get moved around or bounced around break. And no matter what you buy, if you buy the real bottom of the line you can't expect it to last as long as a quality rig.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes, the wiring can be a real pain! when they wire the coach

part, they don always use the same color wire as the wiring

diagram says. seems they use whatever color is within reach.

class c motorhomes arent to much different than a standard

van, but when you get into a class a motorhome anything goes!

most of the time, we find bad grounds or bad connections.

randy

rv tech

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What about wall construction?

I know some trailers use aluminum skinned wall panels with studs and others use a foam core. Which is better?

Also, what brands are good in a trailer, motor home, and 5th wheel?

with wood studs you will have aluminum siding,but aluminum

damages easily. the aluminum studs and foam will be pylon [sp]

or gel coat. a lot tougher but has had delamination problems.

more so if you have a small water leak. pylon also is easier

to keep clean, also its a lot heavier.

as far as brands, thats a ford/chevy polaris/honda debate :]

structurally the major brands are built pretty much the same

way.most of the warranty we did was paneling coming loose or

trim not cut right and plumbing leaks.

randy rv tech

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the big ones are fleetwood, forest river,dutchman,r-vision,

winnebago are a few. but for example forest river has a few

different brands under their banner like salem,wild cat among

others as does fleetwood. are you looking at buying new?

randy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, it would be used, if at all. Just exploring the pros and cons right now. Nice to know which ones to look at though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

check out the dealers, they want clear their lots of used stuff.

probaly get a better deal. they got to make room for the 2009s

randy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Go kick some tires. Look for things like fit and finish. When we were looking there were some really poorly taken care of trailers. Seen one where some must have left a chair in the wrong spot when they brought the slide in and pushed out part of the wall.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ouch! That will lessen the resale value!

I think I'm leaning away from a motor home. As far as 5th wheels, or trailers go, how are these brands: Jayco, Palomino, Holiday Rambler, Cherokee, Coachman, Keystone?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to say, the nicest 5th wheels I have seen are Montana's. These seem to be the caddy of caddy's, not the GMC of caddy's if you know what I mean.

Choosing a camper, whether it be a tag trailer, 5th wheel, motorhome, slide in......it always comes down to how much you are willing to spend, and your personal needs. Not all, but most will always choose a trailer of some type because they are less expensive.

Have fun shopping and I hope you are happy with your final decision. You are using it and it's your money. Just don't get anything too big for your tow vehicle, otherwise you are shopping and spending again. smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

one good thing with a trailer, you can unhook and still

have a vehicle to get around with. with a motorhome you

have to tow a vehicle. the wife loved the motorhome, she

could use the bathroom on the road.

randy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Is a RV a money pit"

Yes. The Point cannot be argued. You'd better love RVing, and do it often enough to justify the expense.

RVing is a money pit. Fun, but a money pit.

I completely disagree. when you say "money pit" yes it takes money to own and operate a camper. but the camper itself is not a money pit. Mine is paid for and I spend around $100 a year for insurance and next to nothing for maintainance, other than elbow grease. I don't think the original poster wants to take into consideration, gas, camping fees, firewood, and the many, many other incidentals that go with camping. I believe his post was just wondering about the camping unit itself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yup, just the unit itself. Stuff breaking, or wearing out. Window issues, roof sealing, heater & A/C units going out, water heater, etc.

Can't get away from fuel costs and camping fees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

roof and window sealing is maintenance whether a trailer

or motorhome. cheap to do, just takes time. sure you will

have vent covers that weather and crack, window cranks break

ect. just hope a refer dont puke on you.. big money there.

all in all they are pretty reliable if taken care of.

randy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Either I'm slackin', or the sun is rising earlier than it did last year! Didn't make it to the river until 6, but surprisingly I was still the first to arrive  walked to my normal starting spot, but once there, something told me to go out of the ordinary. So I packed away my black panther martin and put on a crayfish husky jerk. I didn't catch the trophy I desired, but I did catch some nice ones, with the biggest being about 15 inches. I ventured farther downstream than I ever had before, and wanted to keep going, but it appeared that the fishing easement ended, and I may have been on private property. I stayed in the river the entire time, but didn't want to push my luck, so I went back upstream. Caught 19 total, probably lost at least as many. Surprisingly, no brook trout though. 
    • Oh yeah, a lot of the newer 1/2 tons have frame rust issues as well.  If you want a serious off-road machine, you need to go back to the models with the straight front axles, and of course, they're getting harder to find in decent shape too.  Especially in the rust belt.  You can still find solid older trucks if you head west, young man...        
    • Just to be clear- The wrangler wasn't introduced until 87 so at least compare apples to apples and having owned ford,chevy and dodge trucks of the Wrangler era I can testify they all have issues. My 08 Ram had more frame and fender rust than my older Jeep. The Chevy's have plenty of frame issues as well. Yes. It's a concern but if you want something like this,there is no better alternative.   https://www.google.com/search?q=chevy+frame+rust+problems&client=opera&hs=Lrs&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjAnPz1kMrTAhVpw4MKHSs9B1UQ_AUICigB&biw=800&bih=381
    •   Good questions. You have 3 body style configurations to choose from.  The YJ body was made from 87-97 and that had either a 4 cyl or an inline 6. It had leaf springs and a pretty spartan interior IMO. Some serious off roaders liked the leaf springs but they rode pretty rough IMO.   I feel the 4 cyl is anemic especially with bigger tires. The 4.0 inline 6 is bulletproof, has decent torque and power and fits the Jeep about perfectly. In the YJ series the manual transmission seemed like a better option in my experience.   The TJ ran from 98-06. This version replaces leaf springs with coil over shocks. Mine is an 06 and has the dana rear with the 4.0 and auto trans. I have BFG AT KO 32x10s and on gravel they have taken out 2 side mirrors by throwing rocks at them.    I prefer the TJ series. It has better suspension and interior than the YJ while keeping the original drive train. Fuel economy pretty much sucks as you are essentially driving a brick. I probably get about 12 MPG. If they had done a diesel I would think the wrangler could get 30 but...   The JK series replaced the TJ and was a pretty radical redesign. The body is wider, the drivetrain is totally different and the interior was upgraded quite a bit as well. They went to a pentastar V6 instead of the inline 4.0. trans was upgraded as well. They also started to sell the 4 door unlimited which gives more interior space as well. The new ones are much more civilized and refined which is great for taking the top off and driving to the lake or beach. OTOH they are expensive and harder to justify taking off the top and heading into the woods to hunt or find mud. 
    • Yes, you do have to have at least a weak cell signal and battery for the GPS to work. I know that can be challenging at times in the woods.
    •   Not sure about the new V6, but the old inline 6 was bulletproof, and had a lot of low end torque, which is a desirable feature in an off-road vehicle.       Any 1/2 ton pickup truck from the 70's and early 80's in particular, had a much better frame than a Jeep.  Body panels rust in all of them.   Not saying this is a deal-breaker for a Jeep, just something to watch for, since it is a very common problem.    
    • After doing a little looking there are a lot of options to these things. Anyone know how that new V6 compares to the in line 6? Some of the stuff I would like is the bigger tires and because I would consider putting a plow on it a lower rear end gear. The Dana 44 rear axel would be nice and would want a hard and soft top. I'm in no hurry to get one so Ill wait till the right one comes around. There are a lot of them out there that never leave the tar. More options in the later models as far as transmissions to. So it also comes down to how much I want to spend on one and how late of a model to buy. Sure don't want to spend 35K on a new one.
    • Well yeah but can you name a vehicle built for off road including any domestic pickup truck that doesn't have issues with rust. Fenders, rockers, frames etc. If you play in the mud and salt you need to maintain them. UTVs are no different. Ask yourself why Polaris would put the air filter canister intake in the rear wheel well so it is sucking in the air from the dustiest area they could possibly draw it from resulting in a 4k bill when the motor grenades.    Jeeps are fun, used ones can be had at a reasonable price but by their nature you need to be careful when you purchase because if the previous owner drove them the way they were marketed then they may have some issues.   But the aftermarket has an amazing amount of mods,upgrades and accessories to make your Jeep into anything you want and because the generally go 10 years between major design changes there are a large number of parts available if you need them.     
    • Anyfish it's still points and way better than a zero for points! Congrats on the fine eating bird.
  • Our Sponsors