Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Duffman

Is the canoe becoming an endangered species??

7 posts in this topic

It just seems that everywhere I go lately, be it in the sporting goods stores or on the lakes, kayaks are outnumbering canoes by a large margin. MN is the heart of canoe country, but even up in the Boundary Waters I'm seeing more kayak trekkers. Not that that's a bad thing, just an interesting observation. I picked up an issue of Kayak Angler and was amazed at all the different kayak models out there, the coastal areas of the US looks like they are leading the way in kayak use, and I think it's only a matter of time before the Midwest catches up.

What do you guys and gals think is the biggest factor or factors for this recent kayak popularity???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kayaks are one person operational. Not that canoes cannot be, but you need a solo canoe or go through some hassle to make a tandem canoe work for you.

Personally I will always be a canoe person. I plan on buying a solo in the next couple years to add to the two I already have.

I prefer the load capacity and openness of a canoe which usually are opposite compromises in a kayak. I will probably own a kayak too, someday, but I prefer the canoe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me I like how they sit closer to the water, although at some point in the next year or so I will probably buy a solo canoe for fishing. I also think there is a mistaken idea that canoes are heavier or less maneuverable, which is actually something I discovered wasn't true after the yaks were bought.

As far as trends on the coast go, the sit-on tops let you go places you just can't go in a canoe due to the waves/surf, which is why the guys on the coast fish them. Why you don't see more SOT yaks here is beyond me. There is nothing like paddling through 4 foot surf in a sit-on-top. And of course, midwesterners like me feel the need to be as trendy as the clowns on the coast so we buy kayaks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

there will always be a nice canoe around here. It gets used about as often as the boat and motor. I would like a nice yak but may never get one. gotta love small water... amazing what can be found.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The canoe will be around for ages. They are easy to use, hold a ton of gear, and are so incredibly lightweight.

Kayaks are making tremendous inroads for many of the reasons you mentioned. SOT kayaks can be rigged really nice for fishing, have internal storage, and paddle and fish great.

I think what you are seeing is a resurgence in the popularity of non motorized craft for fishing. I know a lot of people who sold their boat for a non motorized kayak or canoe. It does most of what they need the big boat to do, but allows them to get some exercise and to save a ton of money.

The kayaks you see aren't to replace canoes, but to take advantage of the popularity of motorless fishing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the Olympics and now days the advertising make them popular,the price also.

40 yrs ago my first yak was homemade,If I even found one for sale back then it was priced 10 times the cost of canoes.I could'nt afford a canoe back then but the 40 bucks for a plan and materials was OK.I think the plan was out of sports afield? or outdoor life.

It worked but my craftsmanship was poor I was unexperienced,but I did build a nonleaking,bad tracking,lightweight yak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I doubt they'll ever replace the canoe in the BWCA. Not easy enough to store gear in packs, which makes portaging a pain. The plus side of them are they don't ship water in big waves as easily as a canoe, unless you have a spray skirt on your canoe. I do like the paddles and use them in my canoes. A guy can make some better time with a kayak paddle than with a canoe paddle.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •   That's basically what Ryan tried to do with the last bill...authored behind closed doors.   That all worked out well....
    • Just make them pass it before they see it
    •   Democrats have wanted a single payer system from the start, but they don't have the power to pull it off.   The elderly, the healthcare providers and the medical profession are the drivers of the legislation, and they don't want single payer either, since they have already seen what has happened to Medicare coverage.                      
    • https://www.google.com/amp/www.newsweek.com/bernie-sanders-sponsor-single-payer-healthcare-bill-574403%3Famp%3D1?espv=1   http://www.attn.com/stories/15946/democrats-supporting-health-care-plan   http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/446104/republican-health-care-bill-collapses-democrats-go-single-payer-universal-program
    • Same here. And look how well twetter is working for da prez!!
    • Facebook is where it's at...no thanks...
    • All forums have a certain shelf life. There is only so long that the debate over Ford/ Chevy, Vex/Marcin. Eskimo/ Strike master, Ice Castle / Yeti can keep your attention. After a while most just slip away. New people are using social apps more that the old forum formats and that is that. The only thing saving silly town is that politics is the gift that keeps on giving. 
    • Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham is among GOP leaders saying Republicans and Democrats now need to work together on a fix. Over the weekend, Rep. Betty McCollum and Sen. Al Franken – both Democrats — said they agreed with Graham. “That is what we need to do,” Franken said on WCCO Sunday Morning. “Speaker Ryan said at the end of this process that the Affordable Care Act is the the law of the land. We need to address what’s wrong with the Affordable Care act, what isn’t working.” Immediately after pulling the bill, Trump said he would be willing to work with Democrats on health care.     Too big to fail.....deja vu
    • Catzman wins again for the 3rd time with a score of 365   2--fishingstar  359 3--Juneau4  346 4--Musky999  336 5--Swiveldigger  333 6--gregg52   308 7--jar jar    301 8--BlackLundProV  280 9--huckfin  276 10-mnwildman  260 ________________________ Standings overall 1--Catzman  1314 2--Juneau4  1243 3--Musky999  1223 4--fishingstar  1212 5--gregg52  1208 6--mnwildman  1205 7--jar jar  1195 8--Swiveldigger  1139 9--huckfin  1120 10-BlackLundProV  1112 
    •     I saw a couple of statements in the media yesterday from Dem leadership to the effect that they would be interested in working with Ryan on this.  One from our very own Al Franken.  So that tells me they most likely already are.      
  • Our Sponsors