Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
duck2

Size of the Spearing Hole

23 posts in this topic

Hello, I am building my first spearing shack and will be going with a simple 4' x '8 size design. I am looking for feedback on the minimum size that I could use for the hole. Would 32" width x 16 height" be adequete? How about even going narrower, with a 12" height?

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All depends who is going to be using it, I have seen the 4x8 that have a 3x4 hole in the center you have to jump over to get to the other side, if you are taking kids with you might want to have a smaller one, I have never had a spear hole to big, I take that back one time in the portable went alittle big since the ice was thin and easy cutting?!!? my permiant 4x4 has on the is 18x28. good luck with the new project?!?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

about a 2 by 3 hole in the corner of the house opposite the door. hole bigger if you like. location is important.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the quick replies. I was actually trying to build a dual purpose shack that would have the spearing rectangle cutout on one end and two ice fishing holes on the other. That is why I am trying to get by with the minimum (yet effective )spearing hole.

More ofetn than not, i will use the spearing hole as an enlartge angling hole to give me a visual thrill in seeing the fish approach my lure.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a 4 X 6 house with a 36"~38" wide hole across the back of the shelter. It is ~20 inches from front to back

I would think for the width make it as wide as you can and still maintain the strength of the floor and walls.

For a 4X6 house the 20 inches from front to back is very nice since it gives you some room behind you for all the "stuff" that you may drag out there. I would not want it any less than 20 inches from front to back though.

If I had a 4X8 I would increase the front to back to about 24 inches I think. The only thing that would be a pain is; if the front to back dimension was too big and you had to lean over the hole to spear in the back of the hole.

The other thing that you have to remember is:

What ever size the hole is you have to remove all that ice too. lol

In general for the Norwegian TV go with the widescreen!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my 4x6 spear shack has a 24"x40" hole at one end of the shack and my 4x5 has a 24"x38" hole one the end. one of the first houses I speared out of was a 4x8 and it had two spear holes in it the door was in the center of the 8ft wall and the holes were on the same side I'm guessing that they were 18x34 .

another thing you could do is make a template out of cardboard and make it the biggest possble hole you could have then paint it black then move it around the house to find the best location trim it down to get the best fit. hope this helps

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had not thought about the possibility of doing the two spear holes along one side. Doesn't that type of hole placement present some strutural challenges to floor strength? You would have to space the joists out at least 30" apart over those two holes. It seems like that would be a too little support for bearing the weight of an angler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure how it was framed but thats how it was.This house sat tight to the ice and there wasnt any skids on it. you could also go oppisite corners with the two holes. just a thought

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great post guys.

mine is a bit different then others, and most of you have seen at the spearing outtings that we have had.

When i got my Canvas Craft, i cut one hole on other end of the house so it is away from the door. The house is big enough where i will be able to sit 3 people comfortable.

The size of the hole is awesome IMO. If you are cutting it with a 10 inch auger, it would be 5 down and 7 across. The thing i like about it is that if i set my decoy int he middle of the hole. 75% of the time, the fish will not always come into the hole close to the decoy, they will hang outside on the end where its tought ot get a goot throw at the fish with the spear. With the hole being this big, you are goind to get a clear shot becuase the hole is that size. Its going to look like there under the ice, but there in clear shot! Just something to think about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have had a spear house for 50 plus years,after being broken into a number of times I decided to buy a otter small cabin 2 years ago. all my other houses had a 20 by 26 in hole set square in the floor directly in front of my chair. I decided to use a carpet to cover the ice in front of the sled and cut a hole in the carpet. Now where to cut the hole? I took a piece of cardboard and laid it in various places on the carpet, the best place I found was to lay it kitty cornered in front of the sleds chair. I cut several different sizes of cardboard to simulate the hole. The size I settled on was 18 by 26 ins. One corner of the hole points directly at the chair on the otter sled. I can place one foot on 18 in. side and the other foot on the 26 in. side. Looking straight down and leaning ahead you can see back under the sled, lean back you can see quit a way forward, lean left or right you can see side ways for quite a area. I don;t know why it took me 50 plus years to figger this out, but I sure like this hole placement. When cutting the carpet for your holes leave one side HSO, the carpet rolls up much better. I used outdoor in a nutural color.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Duck2 was that you I met out on W.B. last year late Dec.? I had a green and white trimed spear house and I believe your fishouse was just north of the beach.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mr Greenheads... If you are referring to Mahtomedi Beach on WBL, that could be me. If you are the person with the Metallic Green sided shack. I was out cross country skiing in the lake and stopped by a green metal sided spearing shack to chat and examine the interior.

I have never speared before, but have an elderly friend up north who wants to get me into it and help me build a shack. Most of the time it will be used for hook and line angling, but I will occassionally host my old friend and we will do some spearing.

I love a reference I have seen on this site to the illuminated spearing shack hole as a "Norweigan TV"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had not thought about the possibility of doing the two spear holes along one side. Doesn't that type of hole placement present some strutural challenges to floor strength? You would have to space the joists out at least 30" apart over those two holes. It seems like that would be a too little support for bearing the weight of an angler.

I have seen some people make a 18 inch X 6 foot to 8 foot long spear hole all the way along one side of their house. That is allot of work to move all that ice but it is something to think about. Your runners on the bottom of the house (if you chose to use runners) would run in parallel to the hole and there would be plenty of strength to hold a person up.

It looks something like this.

2802363137_5d3c416edb.jpg

Cut all the ice out from the hole when spearing or drill 4 holes in a line when angling and you would both be facing the same wall.

I would recommend a door in each end if you do so you won't have to step over the other guy when nature calls.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Doesn't that type of hole placement present some strutural challenges to floor strength?

If you have runners or supports on the bottom of your house the hole(s) should be framed from underneath.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

duckman2 that was me, It was nice meeting you. We had to shut the spear hole down on account of too many of my young kids around. I recomend a 2x4 ft. hole on the far side of a 6x8 shack with two holes in the opposite sides corners. goodluck and see you around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where did you get that 9 tine spear? I made over a 100 spears that look something like this one. they were 5,6,7,8 and 9 tine spears, what ever someone wanted. That one looks like a Argalas spear that used to be made in Kilkenny Mn. 40 years ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ya No fish in the hole... sorry.

The pic was taken by a guy I know.

He was showing me how his house was laid out.

I am really not sure what kind of spear that is.

I didn't make that one.

I had a batch of spears that I laid out the money for, and made (with a whole lotta help from my friends) just to raise enough money to get into spearing. They turned out to be very good working spears.

At the end of the day I would rather be on the ice than in the shop making spears. My hat is off to the guys who make spears for a living and consistently deliver high quality artesian quality spears. There is allot of work in just one of those spears!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

your a worker, thats all i can say.

man I think thats an understatment he does it all and hes good at it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •     I believe you said it was "libertarian" drivel, actually, so you dismissed it out of hand...          
    •   You posted about neither.     But if you would read the article, my commentary and TJ's commentary you would know that's not really what the article is about.     You have to be kidding, right? Just about everyone who has an opinion on politics at all is this sort of person. Do you look at social media at all?
    •     Ok, now getting back to whether Trump will win the War on Drugs, do you think he will take any steps at all to decriminalize drugs, such as reclassifying marijuana, and recognizing state laws and programs designed to move towards the decriminalization of drugs?   Or do you think he will take steps to protect vested interests, such as prisons and the pharmaceutical. industry?   Just going off his rhetoric and his choice for a drug czar, I'm guessing he much prefers the latter, and will end up spending a bunch of taxpayer's money, and actually lose ground by continuing on with the brute force/criminalization approach.        
    • Because at the time, I don't have anything better to do.   I posted about the article, and you wanted to talk about the topic.  I posted about the topic and you want to discuss the article.    Which is it?     I support a particular candidate because their positions, taken as a whole, are preferable to me as compared to the other candidate(s).   In a few years I get to do it over.     I don't think there are really that many ardent "rah rah for my party" type folks out there, in spite of what we see on TV, or the occasional people we meet.     So the article is basically drivel, as I said before, based on a false premise.   
    • Borch I just signed up Ryan, Morgan, and me but I only see my name listed in the summary. Do my kids not show up because they don't have hso usernames?  Or did I not enter it right?     Please let me know how to fix it and I'll do so.  Thanks!
    •   Because I think self reflection is good for all of us from time to time.   If you don't wan't to discuss this article, why do you persist in posting here?           No one is disputing that at all. The premise of the author's article is in regards to the hypocrisy of then justifying everything your chosen candidate or party does blindly while vilifying the other candidates or party. It's the "all in" sports like mentality that is being discussed here.  
    • There is a really excellent book called "The Righteous Mind" that approaches this tribalist mindset from an evolutionary psychology standpoint. The author, Jonathan Haidt, does a remarkable job of unpacking why people persist in truly irrational defense of the indefensible - when it's their team doing the stupid stuff. I highly highly highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in lessening the hyperpartisan idiocy we have today.

      The trouble is that the closed-off mindset that lends itself to reflexive support for Obama/Hillary/Trump/whomever also tends to preclude any serious engagement in self-examination that the book is designed to provoke. Really good read, though.
    •   I get what your saying here but I think what Dave is talking about is the willingness of some to blindly follow, without question, their party or candidate. I saw this first hand during the primary with some of my own relatives, for example. I had a SIL who was a huge Bernie backer. The things she said about Hillary were worse than anything said here. As far as she was concerned, Hillary should be tarred and feathered and ran out on a rail. Then Bernie loses the nomination. She then became Hillary's biggest defender. Everything she said about her during the primary was instantly washed away. Even her own husband called her out. She wasn't simply voting for her because she found Trump worse. That's understandable. She defended or at least tried to deflect the issues with Hillary when just a few months prior, she said things that would make even Cooter or Bill say, "man you're harsh on her."   I don't think this is a new phenomenon. I also don't think it's widespread. Like everything else, access to more and diverse information just makes it possible to hear more about it than before. I think human nature causes people to internalize candidates and/.or elected officials. It's a "if you're critical of my candidate, you're critical of me," kind of thinking.   I don't fault anyone for voting for a candidate that one feels best represents their line of thinking. Or even defending their candidate from detractors. I don't think that is what Dave is talking about here. It's also the flipping of political opinions just because the candidate you voted for or support is supporting certain positions. For example, many conservatives opposed BHO's stimulus, including myself. It didn't work  as promised and we just added more on to the debt. So on the campaign trail, Trump also spoke of a stimulus plan that was even more expensive than BHO's and  those same people not only supported it but are justifying it. In summary, one can vote for a candidate without defending everything that person does        
    •  Come on.   The world, life is a bit more complicated then that.          Quit passing the blame. Your whole thesis is on choice and owning it.   Let me guess, you hate big banking also since they made it easy to refinance and purchase.   It just proves that general society is incapable of making the right decisions as a whole.   Sorry, you go down with the ship.    
  • Our Sponsors