Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
NAMASafetyDirector

Water Heater

12 posts in this topic

I am looking at replacing my electric water heater in my 1500 sq. ft. home and would appreciate some advice on what some of my options are as far as the most efficient and money saving route to go. Thanks in advace!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go with and on demand hot water heater, they are alittle more up front but they pay for themselves in no time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know which is better, but I have an offpeak water heater and I get a deduction on my electric bill for it.

The on demand ones like already mentioned seem to be the cat's meow right now, but not sure if you come out ahead or not money wise. I have never priced them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Roofer, how many people in your household, and do you ever run out of hot water, like if you have guests? I will have to decide on 100 gallon off peak, or 50 gallon regular. We won't have many people using it, as usually just two of us, so the off peak might be good choice. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The tank-less are not a little more they are ALOT more and it would take you a long time to make it pay for itself. your size home just replace with the same you have-every thing is there. Tank less you need high pressure,enuff BTU capacity from your meter to supply all gas appliances,furnace,fireplaces if you have them and the 198000 the tank-less needs. Alittle re-water piping,getting a 3 in vent out the side of your house and all the gas work that "could be needed" i think you can see just the labor charge would be up there besides the unit costing way more than a tank style. Way more hipe than they are worth.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had looked into putting a tankless in a place I am working on right now. The tankless is not a bad option for a new application, however retrofiting can be costly. The reason I say this is you will need larger gas lines, venting out the side of the house (if possible), and the space to do this. The cost of the unit will be about double, and then the install costs push it outside of most peoples range.

I decided to go with a new power vent gas fired unit. It has a fast refresh with the power vent, and gas is normally faster reheat. The power vent will cost more then a similar replacement of the electric unit you have.

The cheapest option will be to replace what you have and not worry about it.

You may want to look into rebates, tax and city, for going with a more energy efficient unit. They may help offset costs with a on demand unit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Off peak electric is by far the most effecient. 100 or 120 gal with a mixing valve and you should never run run out under normal conditions.

I would not recomend a power vent gas water heater to anyone, (well, maybe to someone I did'nt like :)) The maintenance problems with them are unbeliveable.

On demand heaters are a joke. Payback is waaaay down the road, and i'm sure there will be maintenance issues as well.

Overall, go electric, no question.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine is 1995 model Marathon 100 gallon. Never ran out of hot water except once when a heating coil went out. That I figured is from the well water here. The replacement was cheap, but yes it did break down on me once. There are only two of us living here, but the guy who lived here before me had a family of four. He had it installed because he had one in his previous house and they really liked it.

Electric is our cheapest source of heat right now. Getting a discount every month for off peak is nice also. It does have it's own meter though. I'm not sure what the costs are for hookup of the system, but it is rather simple being it is electric.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i hear tsnkless do not work in Mn ground water is too cold to get up to temp. check the web sited they have a map that shows where they work

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The on demands are becoming common in Fargo ND. The gas one are expensive to put in and not simple to maintain. But ultimately cost effective.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have 2 80 gallon water heaters on off peak since 1990. It's never cost more than $6.00 per month. 4 people and a whirlpool bath and we've never run out of hot water. Back then the Electric company gave us the heaters for free, but we had to pay $50.00 for the extra meter.Check and see what kind of deal your electric company has now. Off peak has been good to us. DrJ.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another problem with tankless heaters is that you realy can't install a recirculating line and have the tankless heater not run all the time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • That is amazing!! I especially like the dovetails!! And the hand made flasher holder!! That has me seriously thinking... just what i need, another project before winter gets here.  Seriously, that's awesome!
    • Who said anything about victim? We have terrible representation, I am taking responsibility by trying to change it. Sure beats picking some party your parents voted for and blindly sticking with them your whole life. That isn't a poke at you Del, just the way things are.
    • I like them in Spring when the water is still cold. An original in white works well for me, usually fished on 15lb mono. This year I mostly used a Strike King blade minnow as a trailer.
    • Just ask her..... It's because you want more of the Obama policies and more.  It's because she is a woman and you want to show you are not a bigot. It's because Trump will destroy the country and probably the planet.   /sarcasm for the reading impaired...
    • You don't deserve better because they got nominated by voters who chose them instead of one of the other possibilities.  What did you do to get one of the others chosen?   If you just watched TV and went to work and were not involved in the process, then you got what you deserved, as did the rest of the country.   You are not a victim.  No mysterious cabal did this to you.   We are all responsible and that includes you.    Is that so hard to accept? 
    • Sorry if this has been discussed before, I wasn't able to find anything through a quick search.  I'm looking to start a new fish house build and wondering what everyone's thoughts were on Tebben frames.  I like the idea of how they raise the tongue of the trailer keeping the hitch level.  My current trailer binds up on the ball when it's lowered making it difficult to disconnect from my truck. My main concerns are if I can get it galvanized and if there were any added charges for that.  Also, do these come with trailer brakes built in, or would I have to add those myself?  From what I've seen online, correct me if I'm wrong, trailer brakes are required on trailers with a gross weight of 3000# or more in Iowa and Minnesota.  With a frame weight of 1780#, I'm assuming I'll go over 3000# pretty quickly. I'm planning to build a 20' house with steel 1x1" square tubing for the studs.  My first build was a 6-1/2x10' plus a 3'v.  It still works great, I just enjoy the project almost as much as I enjoy fishing out of it and I'm ready for an upgrade!
    • Lets not project your low self esteem onto me, it's hard for me to imagine anyone in this country not deserving better than Clinton or Trump but yet here we are. I guess sometimes you have to hit rock bottom before you see how bad our choices are. Just wait until the economy crashes hard again, tends to happen around these elections you know. That should get some people riled up.
    • So I should vote for Hillary why?
    • I wonder Joe's focus some also, always looks focused but when after the first 9 games of the year you have a 0% chance at the post-season if that's a factor at all ? Hasn't been for Dozier. Will this happen when he gets in that final contract year will he have a good year ? I think he slides off into the sunset but that will depend on his wife, kids and family. .261 as of today still 11/49. How many years away are we from seeing playoff baseball again ? Hopefully sooner then later. Now you read up and we don't have a good defensive catcher etc. in Sunday's star and trib. I'd ask him to go back there, this saving him for what ? Wilson Ramos for Matt Capps was it ? Front office has been a weakness also for a while now.   
    • Are we comparing Teddy to Carr ? Is Carr good ? OK, simmering down fine keep Theodore for a backup because in 3 years when he's finally ready maybe again, Bradford might be down. People are assuming Ted can come back from this he nearly needed an amputation from what the training staff did saved his leg or was that report false ? I think the next Louisville guy might be a franchise QB. Ted needs to fill out in a hurry, maybe this down time will put some weight on him. I look at it this way in most sports. Is Teddy making the guys around him better or is it the other way. Either way we're 3-0 and I've forgotten Teddy just like everyone else has, no one is shedding a tear that Ted is sidelined, beat Rodgers and Newton back to back, feeling blessed Teddy wasn't out there tossing a flailed left handed pass to nobody.  
  • Our Sponsors