Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
dairyman

minimum bass size

30 posts in this topic

whats the smallest size bass you would keep?? Large mouth or small mouth. Either one

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wouldn't ever keep one...and I'm sure many others will repeat that.

Now hypothetically if I were stuck on a lake that only had bass in it in the middle of nowhere and needed to eat bass to survive I would fry up 12-inchers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't ever keep large mouths - don't find them good eating around here.

I have eaten Smallies when camping in the BWCA - They are very good eating IMO. Not sure what size, but it would have to be a decent fillet, otherwise you might as well target crappies or sunnies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I.M.H.O. The bass around here aren't very good this time of year.....warm water=mushy meat. I'm with everyone else, throw the bass back and keep some crappies or sunnies, now your talking about a good meal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Blah Blah Blah don't eat bass. crazy Keep a size you can get a decent fillet off of 13 inch large and 14 inch smallie. I don't eat bass personally but know a lot of people who do. They say they taste good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm with TOOMUCHFUN I dont see why people dont keep bass if you mixed bass and walleye on a pan sheet and tell people to eat them the average person isn't going to have a clue. I was going to say 12 or 13 inch largy and smallie.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've eaten bass once or twice, and while it isn't walleye, it isn't that bad. I do throw 100% of them back though.

Crappie's really aren't that great in the summer for the same reason.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All fish taken from warm shallow water get mushy, not just bass, but it has more to do with storage and care after harvest than the acctual water temp....10-14" would be the size to keep, but if you want some to eat, look towards spring and fall, or have a cooler with tons of ice, and get them on it right away...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have to disagree with depth making fish mushy comment the suspended crappies in the basin are still mush down about 20 in 40 FOW in the summer. The only way to do crappies in the summer is pickling those bad boys. I always throw my keepers in a cooler full of ice. Sorry for the thread hijack also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Smallest size largemouth I'd keep would be 1 oz. over the current state record. All others go back in the lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with toomuchfun. Crappies in the winter are even a little mushy and they fall apart in the pan. I would suspect bass are the same. They all go back.

Sunnies, perch, and walleyes have nice firm meat. Northerns, also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right, those fishing sitting in a livewell with warm water and floating around belly up is much better for them....

I have never had much of a problem with mushy fish as long as I take the time to care for them properly, no sloshing around in the livewell in warm water and no sitting in a bucket waiting to be cleaned. Maybe it's just me...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wasn't saying handling wasn't important. I should have been more specific the deep fish that I have even thrown in the ice right away like bass and crappie caught in the summer deep or shallow still seem mushy even if properly handled is all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also would only keep a bass if it were of state record contention size. I'd eat a muskie first.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't eat bass but regarding the crappie thing I have found that if you put the fillets in a plastic bag and put them in theh firdge or even on ice in the fridge for a night they firm up and are just fine......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've eaten some great bass in my life. However, I usually will not eat them unless I'm camping up north and can't get any northern's or walleye. If you cook it in with any of the coveted table fish, you can't tell much of a difference. In fact I bet 95% of you couldn't tell much difference between bass, walleye and pike fried over the fire in a pan with in a little butter with some lemon pepper smile

I just like to release them so I can catch them another day!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is from a die hard bass angler...

Bass are not all that bad, smaller fish are better, but it really all depends on the fishery.

We need to keep this in mind however. Bass do a fairly decent job of keeping their numbers in check, the MN DNR spends very little if any on re-stocking programs. MN DNR spends magor bucks to stock walleye, and some on Muskie and Trout...

I have no problem with someone keeping 3 or so 12-13" fish for the table. Often times its even healthy for the fishery. Its when peole keep numbers of spawners, 14-18" fish that can hurt the fishery. can some lakes handle that, sure, but for the most part, no.

If I may suggest, if you plan to eat it, keep it, put it on ice right away and eat it before you freeze it.. Bass can be a mushy fillet to eat, not as firm as a walleye or pike, its often good made into cakes or baked. But please I again urge you to keep the smaller 12 -13 inch fish as they are best and dont hurt the fishery as bad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never keep bass in the summer/open water season. however, I have kept the occational bass ice fishing and have found them to be very good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too am a die hard bass guy, but I also started fishing when I was just a baby down south. I do C&R most of the time, but on occasion I will keep a few, generally they will be in the 12-14" range. My grandma loves bass and a few other people I know love bass. When I keep em it is generally premeditated to invite friends and family over for a fish fry.

The key to keeping any fish in the summer is to fill your livewell with ice before you head to the lake if you are planning to keep em. Toss em on ice right away rather than in warm water. This will help keep em nice and firm as best as possible. Not just bass, but panfish, walleyes, catfish, everything.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've eaten bass and it tastes just fine. I've kept smallies out of the croix and they taste great. Keep the smaller ones and leave the breaders. I don't understand why so many are so protective of bass. They are fun to catch but fry them up with some shore lunch and they make a heck of a sammy!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the trick I use (a cooler I coverted to livewell) is to fill it full of cold tap water before I head out. (Like the ice in the livewell thing) They stay cold and the water kinda filters the fish as they are in it most of the day. my $.02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't mind keeping a few bass. They're easy on the mouth, and it takes less filleting to get a decent meal's worth!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Saw a flash by the window so looked out and saw the hawk. It grabbed a chipmunk. Grabbed the camera and snuck the patio door open to try and get a quick shot before it flew off. Fun ! It was just a couple feet from the end of the deck so the flowers helped. 
    • Saw a flash by the window so looked out and saw the hawk. It grabbed a chipmunk. Grabbed the camera and snuck the patio door open to try and get a quick shot before it flew off. Fun !
    • ONE would think you wouldn't need to quantify your need to go hunting all the time. that she'd be glad your outta her hair!!!!!!!!!!
    • I have used a graph unit before on the ice it definitely has its pros and cons.. But the Helix 5 I just got also has an ice fishing mode and I expect it will be very similar to other flashers? Keep in mind also I have only been using a VX-1 for last several years on the ice so I am expecting the Helix5 will be a nice upgrade especially with the GPS and Navionics+ card. I run and gun just to chase schools of perch and have to be very mobile to stay on top of them. During dusk and into the evening I often fish too shallow to run and gun so once I am setup I keep noise and light at a minimum. I appreciate the feed back, right now leaning towards a homemade setup or the Genzbox would still love to hear what others are using also.
    • I used to be the guy years ago claiming an approach but I don't get too excited on opener anymore either.  Opened the season on the 2nd weekend last year and did real well, hoping to do the same this year. I try to get as many hunts in as possible before deer hunting, and then hit it hard after. I keep telling the wife "it only comes around once a year ".  
    • In our neck of the woods, a lot of the lakes are very clear and the weeds can be seen, sometimes even the weeds that are in 12 - 15 feet of water with the tops being 5 or six feet from surface. On the less clear waters, during the summer months, the weeds that are in 4 - 10 feet of water will often show themselves on the surface as well. For those deeper weeds, or those that simply aren't making it to the surface, I use a lake map and a jig to find the weeds. I do not use electronics of any kind so lake maps are crucial to me, and though they don't pin point weed beds, if the map is a good one, and describes what the bottom consists of in certain areas, then it helps to narrow it down quite a bit. Then once I have found the weeds it's a matter of narrowing down the key spots in, and around, each weed bed and weed line. In this video I fish for crappies and gills on a weed line in Northern Michigan. This particular weed line is very visible so it's easy to find. On this lake, the weeds got so bad that they just weed killed several areas of the lake.   
    • I use lowrance and have the soft case ice packs.  One question- have you used a graph unit in a run and gun situation before? I was just having a conversation with a friend about this the other week. He has always used a vexilar even though he has HB graph units and gets more fish with the vex. He is much more of a run and gunner and can drop in the ducer, turn a knob or so and be locked in.   I, OTOH am more if the sit back and relax type and don't move around as much. When I do, I Fing the graph sonar to be a liability as I need to dial in the sensitivity and color line every time I change structure and depth or it doesn't mark fish as well. We both agree that a round circle noisy spinny wheel thingy is better when you run and gun. Sitting back and relaxing a graph is nice because you can dial it in and have the chart for memory if you look away or if a fish is coming.  
    • I don't care for any shandy.  They all taste bad to me.   Go drink your mike's hard lemonade, or maybe Coors light, and pretend you are in the mountains.
    • I was looking to buy a frame from this guy http://www.fishhouse-frames.com/node but it was out of my price range. He said he can weld on the axle arms after the galvanize. If you have not talked with the galvanizer yet I suggest you do. If your going to use AZZ galvanize out of winstead MN, Dan the sales guy is great to deal with and will explain everything you need to know.
    • Great idea, Purple!!!  I've done the Chili Dogs and Cody Sticks from Curley's.  Both are excellent!
  • Our Sponsors