Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Hoytmystic

Shotgun Setup Benelli Vs. Remington

9 posts in this topic

This is my deal. I am going to southern Iowa on a slug gun hunt. I am going to put a gun together for the hunt. I have a Remington 870 express that I was going to buy a cantilever barrel for. I was thinking about putting a cantilever barrel on my Benelli SBE II. Just wondering if anyone has any experience with either. How much do the barrels cost.

Thanks for any help.

Hoytmystic

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have the Hastings heavy barrel for my 870 from my deer hunting days. Pretty sure I was using the 2 3/4" BRI sabots to get a 3" grouping at 100 yards. Very heavy for drives or stalking but made an awesome stand gun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shoot an 870 with a fully rifled slug barrel from Mossberg on it. Topped with a Nikon scope. Its a darn fine deer gun.

The slug barrels for Benelli's are OBSCENELY expensive and you don't need an auto for slug hunting and at about $12-15 for a box of slugs now days, you really don't want to be shooting too many. One good shot from the 870 is all you'll need.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the 870 you can find a fully rifled cantelever barrel for $175 on up. For the SBE II you won't find a cantelever barrel since the reciever is allready tapped and drilled for a scope mount. Fully rifled barrels for a benelli are $ 500 on up.

You could buy a nice shotgun scope and mounts and install a rifled choke tube in the Benelli for about what you would pay just for the Remington Barrel. I have seen some pretty good groups with sabot slugs fired from barrels with a rifled choke tube. You would just need to try a couple of different loads and see what your gun likes. I use a padded, raised cheek piece for better eye alignment with a scope on a shotgun. It also helps get a good cheek weld to the stock which helps make the recoil more tolerable.

I have some aquaintences who have hunted southern Iowa, You could see some real nice bucks if you get on the right grounds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For a Benelli setup you'll also need a new forearm. $90 or so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A little off topic, but what you pay for a cantilever barrel for either gun you can buy a H&R ultra sluger. The H&Rs are heavy, but they are short. I have a 870 cantilever and a H&R 12ga and both shoot good, but I love hunting with the H&R. I shot 3 out of 3 beer cans at 135 yards last season off the hood of the truck. For me I can shoot off hand better with the heavyer gun. In my opinion buy a H&R ultra sluger and put a nikon or leopold on it and your will have one of the most accurate slug guns for the price.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shoot an 870 with the cantilever riffled barell and a red dot scope. I have a 3" group at 100 yds. Plus the red dot is nice on drives because you can pull up quickly and get on the animal easily. You should be able to buy one for 130 dollars or less. Look on hsolist or try a scheels outfitter store.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go with the 870, you can get after market barrels for them (Hastings), and not spend as much to get the Remington barrel. The only barrels you can get for a SBE II would be Benelli barrels. These will cost you a pretty penny, I would say at least 350.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Last year I looked at the Remington 23" heavy contour barrel for my 870. It was about $220. I ended up getting the whole gun for $350. (deer model) I picked up one of those "squishy" recoil pads and am currently getting some trigger work done to make that a little lighter and more crisp. Nice shooting rig. I think the Bennelli barrels are more like $500-600. I have shot a Hastings barrel in the past and was not impressed. Thank you Cabela's for a good return policy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • better late than never!!  so far it's not to late any way!
    • I'm curious about the GenieJar.  Looks like there is a 30oz and a 17oz version.  I wonder how it works in fairly cold weather.  The nice thing about styrofoam is that it insulates against the entire water mass freezing into a minnow-sicle.  I wonder if they recommend throwing it inside your jacket or something. 
    • Agreed. I am getting nervous about the state of out financial situation now, well, I guess getting MORE nervous. Toward the back end of the contract Parise's deal isn't so bad since it was front loaded, but the term is so long. IMO we cannot afford any more buyouts. Pominville is such a buzzkill. Koivu has really played great the last 1 plus this year. No, he isn't going to win many races for the puck, but as long as he isn't on the top line I am OK with that. Staal is doing a little better than I had hoped I guess. I was hoping just for solid play, but there have been a few games where he and Coyle we so strong on the puck the opposition couldn't get control of it.
    • Hey Star, I wouldn't leave the fan there. It's going to get really HOT and will melt ! Move it to the bottom of the cabinet just left of the gas valve and have it blowing up so it pushes the heat out the vents on the top half of the heater.
    • I agree with the backing for the fly line.  Never had any problems and the stuff seems to get better with age.
    • Best thing I've found is backing for fly line.  It has no memory and virtually no knots.  It's better situated for rattle wheels because of the physical size of the backing but I've not had any problems yet with my Frabil tip-ups.  Deepest water we fish in is only 30' with normal depth of around 12'.  Our local Runnings sells 50 yard segments for like $3 each in any color. 
    • The next year my Mom and Dad cooked the turkey in one of those white roasters and it was awesome.  So I told her that too.  Big time.  It was nice and juicy too.
    • i believe it is their first year, one of the guys used to work for Ice Castle at the Pine River plant.  They have videos on you tube.  I have seen them on Facebook and you tube, the house looks nice, but it is not something I would buy. 
  • Our Sponsors