Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Chode2235

How do you handle pike/musky/toothy fish from your canoe or kayak

20 posts in this topic

I was out this past weekend walleye fishing with a friend of mine in his boat. We were fishing on a lake that I frequently fish out of my kayak. Long story short, I tied into a 40" musky. We scooped it up in his huge net, and released it.

Now I have been thinking, what would I have done had I hooked into that guy in my kayak? A net like that is too big to use, especially by myself. I have never used a gripper or anything like that, are they the best option?

What do you all do when dealing with big toothy fish in your little boats?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was fortunate to tangle with a big pike a few years back. Fortunate that I didn't hook it anyway! I was fishing for bass and crappies, and tied into what I was sure was a 5-6 lb largemouth. I felt the tap, set the hook, and then it ran and steered to deeper water. It actually pulled me along, like I was a big bobber! I worked it for a few minutes, till it was right below me. I looked over the side and saw that I'd hooked a 12 inch largemouth...that was gripped sideways by a huge pike. Only about an inch or two of the tale and head were sticking out each side of its mouth. She'd run a bit and dive deeper, and I could feel her chopping at the bass. I thought if she swallows it, I could land it! Then I remembered where I was...in a kayak! What could I possible do to land that monster? We played tug-o-war for a few minutes more and she let go. I reeled in the mangled bass, let my heart rate return to normal, and slipped the largemouth back as an offering to a great experience.

I don't know if I could have landed that fish without capsizing. I imagine you could play the fish, using your 'yak like a big bobber (think Jaws...'two barrels in her now!'..cpt. Quint). But you'd be stressing the fish near to death before landing it. I've thought perhaps keeping a side cutters handy would be good. Get her along side and then cut the hook or the line.

Anyone have other ideas? Great question!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've caught a few pike and a small muskie from the yak. I use a lip gripper, keep most of the fish in the water, grap it with the gripper , unhook it and let it go. I get alot of my stuff online through - Hook 1 kayak fishing gear -

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The largest fish i have ever caught was a pike from a canoe. I threw up on a cliff face in Quetico Provincial Park in Canada. The wind started to blew up out from the face so I let the bait drag out over deeper water. Then thump, thump, boom and it was on. 15 minutes later it surfaces quickly, shower my brother in the back of the canoe before he could get a look. 10 more minutes of fighting produced what at first looked like a giant green log. It turned out to be a pike we roughly measured at 41".

I was faced with your same issue. So I grabbed it by the tail with one hand, then set my rod down to get my other hand under its head. Then I lifted it into the canoe and popped the hooks free.

(We were both in sandals and as soon as I set the fish in the bottom of the canoe to catch my breath, my brother saw the huge teeth hanging from its face. He start screaming "get that poorwordusage thing out of the boat." I guess it got too close to my brothers toes.)

Tail grab them and lift them over. This works in the canoe but may not work in smaller yaks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It gets dangerous when you have someone else in the boat, they over react and before you know it the fish is back in the lake... along with you and all of your stuff. smile

I actually feel pretty 'lucky' that I haven't had to tangle with a big pike or musky from my kayak or canoe yet. But fishing where I do it is practically inevitable if I spend enough time out there.

I just want to be prepared.

I posted this question on another board too, and the response that I got was to carry a small towel or rag, wet it and cover the fish's eyes while at the boat. That keeps them from thrashing around. But I think I will need to invest in a bigger set of pliers, and a lip gripper at a minimum.

Any of you use a lip gripper, or net?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My main rule is never use treble hooked pike or musky baits in my kayak/floattube. I was glad I was practising that last year as I hooked a tiger musky on a single hooked buzzbait last year in my kayak and I had it alongide and was getting my camera ready, it leaped AND LANDED RIGHT ON MY LAP! Its business end was you know where! if it had a big jerkbait or something on him I could have been hosed big time!

Well it didn't work last year, but my musky from the yak plan is get the fish up close and snap a few pics, then use a long pliers and get the hook out with the fish still in the water.

If you were wanting to keep one, I think you should have a gaff and a club handy, you don't want a live ski or big pike in your yak!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use a lip gripper pretty often. It's a much safer way to get a handle on fish of good size and with sharp teeth!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does anyone remember the part off Grumpier Old Men where the two are fishing right before the wedding to catch the monster fish and the fish is pulling the boat across the water? I am just imagining that with a large enough musky and a guy in a canoe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The_Lee

no your not - crazy I-'ve been pulled 20 - 30 yards by a few bass at only 17 inches or so. My muskie wasn't much over 20 inches and surprisently didn't run or pull as much as the bass. But its always fun and interesting to be towed around laugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being towed is the easy part, getting them unhooked and back into the deep alive and well, with me still having 10 fingers is important too.

I will probably go the route and outlaw trebles in my boats, as they could get to be a big mess. Cyberfish, are you putting single hooks on your crankbaits, etc? How does that work?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being towed is the easy part, getting them unhooked and back into the deep alive and well, with me still having 10 fingers is important too.

I will probably go the route and outlaw trebles in my boats, as they could get to be a big mess. Cyberfish, are you putting single hooks on your crankbaits, etc? How does that work?

Nope, I just don't use crankbaits, too dangerous! I might use a small rapala for walleyes, but for pike I just stick to spinnerbaits, buzzbaits, and plastics.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cyberfish...

I always wondered if you chased the toothy critters in the float tube, I figured if ya did ya must be somewhat crazy, a pike with a mouth full of trebles darting around your legs is just askin for trouble. Single hooks?, maybe ya ain't so crazy after all. smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Has Blue Kayak tied into a hog flat in his 'yak yet? We were razzin him about that possibility at last years KOTC gathering....

Jerry? what's the verdict? laugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cats from a kayak, thats a great idea...

I think....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cyberfish...

I always wondered if you chased the toothy critters in the float tube, I figured if ya did ya must be somewhat crazy, a pike with a mouth full of trebles darting around your legs is just askin for trouble. Single hooks?, maybe ya ain't so crazy after all. smile

i'm kinda crazy, but i don't like PAIN! eekeek

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No trebles, play the fish, use a fish handling glove (provides some protection for the fish, and for your fingers), and leave them in the water when unhooking. I've caught a few big pike from my heritage redfish yak, and it is the best experience.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i am a novice muskie angler but my that is the only fish my grandfather fishes for, he makes regular trips up to lake of the woods for weeks at a time targeting the monsters and they do not use nets. when they get them next to the boat they just rub the belly of the fish, he says it only takes a few seconds and they become almost comatose, if i caught one in a canoe this would be my plan of action, rub the belly untill they are so relaxed they are alomost paralyzed then unhook and release.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rub the belly? I have never heard that one before.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I fish the Mississipi with a Crow Wing SOT, I use fireline on my reels so I do carry a sissors that can cut superlines. Why is that? Last year I got pulled around for a while then managed to get it to the surface. It came up about a foot from me hissing, a snapping turtle had gotten my tube bait caught in his mouth. He was about a 20 incher and really mad. All I could do was cut the line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You grab the pike by the back of the head. So your hand is over the gill plate. If you put the death grip on him it will be no problemo. Just make sure you grab the tail when you get her out of the water. In one day I caught a 39, 40 3/4, 41 1/2, and a 43" pike. Only the 43" I went to shore to land him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I have a little can of lock deicer taped to the gas tank under my tank cover. I haven't had to use it for the lock, but did use it the other weekend when the latch froze up.
    • Because they didn't need to. President Obama was totally open to the press corps and never threatened to "throw them out of the White House". President Obama never refused to take a question from a legitimate and credentialed reporter and told the reporter he represents "fake news". And of course President Obama would never think of ridiculing a reporter who suffered a serious physical problem. We are moving from an erudite, articulate and thoughtful man,  sensitive to others, to an inarticulate baboon who cannot put more than 140 words together at one time. The Donald is going to destroy the Republican Party.   Remember I said this and on this date. I won't need to say it again.
    • we dont remember asking you!!!!!!!!
    • Have to admit, I was expecting a different conversation based on the subject line of this thread!   Would it work to have a hole in 3 corners, with the guys grouped toward the center  with their backs to each other? Assuming your hub has 2 doors, that would allow people to get in/out without too much hassle.   I'm also assuming if you're currently fitting three people in a three person hub, you're keeping things rather scaled down. I have a three-man, but once I get chairs, a heater, minnow bucket, etc. in there it's really a 2-man.  
    • Well Walleyehooker, you may be in luck, because after 5 days of this warm weather it may take a week or two of cold and snow to just get back to point zero on the trails anyway! So you maybe back by then.
    • A 26 incher from a couple weeks ago.  Fattie too.
    • Great pics!  Thanks for the update!  I'm headed up this weekend and hope to get on 'em.  I'll report back next week with my findings.
    • Oh c'mon you guys they all say 60 Db, ya right! You'd have to be nuts to spend double just cause it says Honda or Yamaha on it.
    • Taking fish from our non-sustainable lakes to consume???!?!?!?!!!  *GASP* O MY GOD....  
    • This has worked best for me. I can have better access to the door for all and a good spot for the heater.
  • Our Sponsors