Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
croixflats

fish eating advisory

16 posts in this topic

I was thinking of having a nice walleye meal but that advisory keeps popping in my head. Oh, they say you should only eat this amount fish out of this lake and that amount of that river. Well, at my age I'm thinking other things are gonna get before the fish will. And as the lead making me dumber I think the way I abused the beer over the years it aint gonna much differance.

Not to say somebodies of do turn me off. And I think we should be carefull of what we give our young. But for me a Walleye dinner cannot be turned down

What are your thoughts on this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Moderation will keep any one thing from doing you in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I think the only way we can prevent toxins from invading our bodies is if we stop breathing. The air we breathe, the water we drink, and the food we eat are full of toxic chemicals. One day we're told eggs cause cancer then we're told red meat is dangerous; we should drink decaffeinated coffee then we're told it's better to drink regular; we drink bottled water because we foolishly believe it is somehow safer than tap water when in most cases (some have flavors added) it is nothing more than ground water. We worry way too much. Sometimes I think we worry ourselves to death about dying.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ya, I agree about worrying too much, but in the case of kids or pregnant women (and recently pregnant men??? that was a weird story), it might not be that bad of an idea to watch the intake from some waters. I do think there is an overboard reaction for most lakes and rivers. After all, if you have to kind of think about the canary in the coal mine aspect. If the water is that foul, the fish would be dead. Given that, I know that pollutants are cumulative, but like you said, is it worse than a lifetime of suds and other stuff? I wouldn't worry too much. I kind of look at it like a rating on a chain or cable-the breaking limit rating is a third of its' actual breaking point. A safety valve, so to speak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Never had problems eating fish. We don't have a lot of meals though, but never saw any effects from it. I agree, in moderation, nothing's gonna hurt you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How often do you eat fish? If its not more than once a month you should be just fine- I guess its just an afterthought to me because I typically only keep enough for a meal a few times each year.

I'd worry if you were huge, old fish every week- but if you do eat fish often-stick to the smaller sizes-there's younger so they have less toxins in them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

definetly keep some fish from some places away from my daughter and women of child bearing age. Personally I cook up fish from most anywhere for myself, parents, grandparents, and friends probably couple times per month. I think I am pretty well screwed where I live... nuclear plant 10 miles, koch refinery 10 miles, ashland oil about 15 miles, 3M 10 miles. Air, ground, and water quality around here is definetly contaminated w/ all sorts of stuff w/ all that [PoorWordUsage] nearby. I think I need to move to Canada, only worry about hydro plant and paper mill.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We all have to die of something. smirk

If it is because we ate to much fish, we should be so lucky....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Whats more unhealthy, catching a limit of walleyes and eating them when you get home. Or bass fishing all day and stopping at mcdonalds on the way home?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with fishinjohn, Moderation!

Same with any type of food pretty much, Things like bacon, fries, sweets, etc. It's good to enjoy them, as long as it's in moderation, some people don't know what moderation is, that's why alot of people these days are obese.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with fishinjohn, Moderation!

Same with any type of food pretty much, Things like bacon, fries, sweets, etc. It's good to enjoy them, as long as it's in moderation, some people don't know what moderation is, that's why alot of people these days are obese.

Toxins can get you in more ways than just accumulation. You really want to limit it whenever possible. The safe level really isn't an absolute, it's just statistically very unlikely to affect you at that level. But accumulating toxins like mercury is going to be far more harmful than years of drinking beer. Plus some of the effects of long term exposure are pretty serious, loss of memory, nervous disorders, delirium, etc are things you don't want to mess with at any age.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with fishinjohn, Moderation!

Same with any type of food pretty much, Things like bacon, fries, sweets, etc. It's good to enjoy them, as long as it's in moderation, some people don't know what moderation is, that's why alot of people these days are obese.

Hey!!! I resemble that remark!!! mad

Givin' ya a hard time, but I do resemble that remark. smirk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: ac777
I agree with fishinjohn, Moderation!

Same with any type of food pretty much, Things like bacon, fries, sweets, etc. It's good to enjoy them, as long as it's in moderation, some people don't know what moderation is, that's why alot of people these days are obese.

Toxins can get you in more ways than just accumulation. You really want to limit it whenever possible. The safe level really isn't an absolute, it's just statistically very unlikely to affect you at that level. But accumulating toxins like mercury is going to be far more harmful than years of drinking beer. Plus some of the effects of long term exposure are pretty serious, loss of memory, nervous disorders, delirium, etc are things you don't want to mess with at any age.

Sounds to me like the same conditions from years of drinking beer. grin

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

An expert once said that you'd have to eat over 1,000 pounds of the affected fish in one sitting to notice any negligible effect. I'd be more concerned that pregnant women and children followed the guidelines.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Whats more unhealthy, catching a limit of walleyes and eating them when you get home. Or bass fishing all day and stopping at mcdonalds on the way home?

Depends on how you cook the fish smile

McDonalds is definitly the better choice if you order a garden salad smile

I sure wish bass sesaon was upon us here in the metro and I could be fishing instead of posting on message boards about the mercury levels in the fish I eat

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does anyone know for sure how they do the testing of fish for all of these toxins? Are they filleting the fish and testing only the meat, or are they grinding up the whole fish and testing that, or what?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Switched up my pick at the last second in bucket A and put Wheeler in there. Great ledge fisherman and sounds like this dude puts in more time on the water then any other angler out there.   A. Wheeler B. Evers C. Tharp D. Herren E. Omori   Sounds like the bite has been super tough. Will be interesting to see how it goes. 
    • They are drumming like crazy now. In fact, I even hear them at night. My wife said when she was a teenager growing up in rural Wisconsin, she always thought that drumming sound was the nearby powerstation.    
    • Lilac blooms are here, just haven't opened. Hearing some reports of good finds in the Houston and Lewiston areas of MN. I checked some new public areas today on the MN side. Could be decent later but too cold and wet right now. Will check some early season spots tomorrow but won't hope for much with the cold weather.
    • Nice!  Must have seemed forever waiting.
    • 6 months later and he is home
    • Three favorites at the moment.  By the time they upload, I may change my mind.
    • A few from Maplewood State Park on April 16th.  Non-professional, but they stood still long enough for me to get 'em.
    • You might be able to figure things out this week.  How big is your sump basket?  Is the  pump kicking in now?  Sit there for 15 minutes and count the number of times it cycles.  That should give you a decent idea on how much water is coming in.  Then figure out about how high the water has to go before it flows by gravity.  The spec for the pump will say something like that it can pump 2,000 gph at 10 feet of lift.  (the gph drops dramatically the higher it has to pump the water).  The answer to your specifics will give you an idea of how big of a pump you need.  If you match the size of the pump as close as possible to the amount of water your will face you can maximize the amount of time the battery backup will last.   Faced with this problem I took a standard boat sump pump and modified it so I could hook up a garden hose.  The I took an old shop extension cord and wired the pump so I could hook it up to a car in the garage.  So just prior to having Noah float by I could hook things up in the garage and be good to go for as long as I had gas in the car to pump up the battery.   Now that I am adult I bought a generator and wired the house to take care of things.
    • Inevitably at least twice each season I will leave the house, drive 45 minutes and walk some of my favorite grouse spots for hours and hours, seeing nothing.  Admitting defeat on that day, I will drive 45 minutes back home, only to find a covey of birds in the driveway...
  • Our Sponsors