Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
mrmillelacs

if they only made a good heater for a portable

10 posts in this topic

ive tried most of them. my problem is that i love to fish hard water but dont like to be cold. my current heater is a coleman double head sunflower type heater which puts out a lot of heat but is noisy and you have to keep a flap open for air quality purposes. A couple people i know have tried the "indoor safe" type small portable heaters but they dont put out anywhere near enough heat. The company that makes these would make a killing if they jacked these up to about 3 times as much heat, say 30000 btus. But they dont. In my permanent house on mille lacs i have a direct vent heater, but i found out that you need a lot more btus in a direct vent heater than in a vent free heater for the same comfort level. Ive searched the internet to no avail. Is there an indoor safe heater available anywhere that could be hooked up to a 20 pound tank and still crank out 20000 btus or more? Ive been thinking about buying a 20000 btu wall mount heater and fashioning a stand and handle for it and lug that around. ideas? thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you have got to be kidding me........those indoor safe heaters are absolute junk. biggest waste of eighty dollars ever. if you want a good portable heater get the mr.heater heater/cooker combo the one that sits on the floor and runs of a one pound bottle, but get an adapter cord for a twenty pounder. ive been on the lake all day in very cold temps and wind and not been cold......the problem with the sunflower heaters that mount to the top of a tank is that they only heat the top half of your house, no heat down low.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree wit josh Ive had the mr heater/combo for 4 years 3000 to 9000 btu's keeps my shack warm most of the time ive got it set between low and off plus you can point it turn it flip it where ever you want and itmakes soup/coffee ,i still have the big black cat heater for a backup but it has to get rrreally cold before i get um both goin

------------------
Icedog1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've used vented propane heaters in 8' x 10' custom portables, with all the holes on one side, so a double decked cot can be set up on the other side. The propane tank stays outside, and the heavy burner is wedged and screwed to the floor so it can't be bumped around.

I've always used 4" stovepipes, with a metal stovepipe support bolted onto the roof canvas directly above the screwed down burner unit. You also should have a 24" wide piece of insulation that runs from the wood floor right up to the stovepipe support in the roof. You can position this piece of insulation so it is between the stovepipe and the nearest tent wall.

I've use this setup on LOTW and further north in Canada, and it works fine if you're portable is really sturdy, so the walls don't flap too much in a gale wind.

I always shut off the propane heater, if I'm going to sleep in the unit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In my Guide, a HeatBuddy usually does the job. If not, I set a Black Cat in the sled behind me, and I'm good.

To many guys want to shed their cloths. "If you ain't movin', you ain't fishin'". I don't have time to take off the coat, kick back, open a beer, deal cards, etc.
If I do, I rent a sleeper on LOW.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use a Fish Trap II (older version of irvingdog's Guide), and an 8,000 btu Dynaglo (like the Mr. Heater Buddy but $15 less on sale).

It keeps the Trap II plenty warm even when it's below zero. Often, I have to set it on the low setting to even stay in the Trap, and I can get by without a coat a lot of the time.

I used to use a Black Cat from Coleman, but the 4,000 btus weren't enough when it got below 10 degrees.

------------------
"Worry less, fish more."
Steve Foss
stfcatfish@yahoo.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

mrmillacs, I agree with you. i use a Mr Heater. It works great in my guide, but have to worry about bumping it and burning a whole in my clothes. Plus you need venting. I've probably burned a few brain cells running that thing over the years. If someone made a buddy type heater with even a couple thousand more BTU's I bet it would go over big.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've used the Mr.heater-cooker for about 8 years now. It's great heater,puts out a lot of heat,but I know someone that bought one of the newer ones and the valve that you turn on and off the heater melted and started on fire.He took it back and got another one and the same thing happened again.He said he never buy another one. The one I got has a metal valve and I've never had a problem with mine. I also got a heater buddy and though it doesn't put out as much heat, It works well in a small portable or camper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mr Mille lacs, are you looking for a portable heater, or a wall mount? Strikemaster makes a vented heater, I use one in my deer stand. I'm happy with it. It's on their HSOforum.

I use an omni 105 kerosene heater in my fishouse. Only smells like kerosene when you light it and turn it off, both of which I do outside. Once it's burning good, it's whisper quiet and odorless. It's the vertical cylinder style with the tank on the bottom. hsolist, 80 bucks. 24,000btu

I get headaches from unvented propane heat. It's noisy and creates too much condensation inside.

[This message has been edited by Crappie Killer (edited 11-30-2003).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We use Mr Heater single burner sunflower style heaters with 20# tanks put in a milk crate so they dont tip over. I leave mine in my otter sled. During prime time when im stationary i always leave the door partially open for fresh air. But during the day im gunning around and i never shut it down all day, I like to stay warm so i leave it on high, I like not having to fire it up every time i relocate, and its more than enough heat for my lodge. When im gunning around looking for midday perch and walleyes i dont bother with putting up the poles in the house and the flaps do stay loose on the ice, so venting is not necessary. They work great for us.

Remember to: "CROSS THEIR EYES"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • tip to a couple good friends   Len,
      Thank you for the stream recommendation, Len! I love the layout of this stream. Fished it from 3pm until 6:30pm.  My brother threw panther 9s and I threw 6s. We scored a brookie/brown/bow trifecta.    
    • Nelson has been down in recent years in terms of Walleye fishing. Depends on what kind of water you like to fish. The flowage and Moose Lake are good if you like fishing really dark water. Grindstone and Lac Courte Oreilles, maybe even Round are also good walleye lakes, but those lakes have very clear water and will fish completely different than the dark water river impoundments in the area.
    • I think it would be an offensive and experience(post season) up grade. I all reality, we dont have the means to make the trade.  We are nearly out of money(cap space) and only have 11 players.  We need food cheap role players right now.   Only way would be to package Wiggins with future draft picks.  If the analysts are actually correct on how improved we will be, those draft pick wont carry a ton of value.
    •   Well not as many as up by the Emily-Outing area but a few.
    • Still on the fence between going with the cabin or lodge, my dad has a normal lodge and it has tons of room which is great but it also is somewhat heavy for 1 guy to load and pull it seems. I mostly fish with just 1 other person and maby 25% of the time by myself so that was why I was leaning to the cabin which also seemed to have plenty of room for 2 it seemed to me. Also from what I understand the cabin will fit in chevy crew cab box and the lodge won't? I have a 04 crew cab short box so one more incentive for the cabin if thats true.
    • Sounds perfect, thinking your guys reviews will seal the deal for me once I can see one in person again, a hyfax kit will also be on my list as I plan on pulling it behind my sportsman 570. Thanks for the review also AAmerican, it's early to be thinking ice fishing but I'm sure there's people out there like us that are a little anxious!
    • The Chippewa flowage would be a great place to start. I will be honest. Walleye are not what I have ever chosen to Target when I fish up there but the flowage is a great fishery.    Nelson lake would be another choice.
    • I have had 3 of the otter pro xt's, a cabin, lodge and resort. I still have the resort and recently purchased the cabin. I have not had many different brand portables but have fished in other brands buddies have. They are the nicest portables I have personally owned and until I try something I like more I wouldn't change from them at all. The resort is heavy and not something I like dragging far by hand especially loaded with gear and much snow on the lakes. But it has tons of room and I have fished 4 people in it before, a little tight but doable. The cabin I purchased for more hand pulling and an extra for if I have people along. They are very warm and I have fished in them down to -30 deg F. A regular buddy heater keeps them plenty warm, if it isn't to cold or the house is banked well its easily t-shirt weather inside. The resort needs a big buddy heater for colder days sometimes due to the larger size but isn't terrible with a regular. Overall very happy with them all and have been very durable. Also no dripping of water from the ceiling. Highly recommend a set of hyfax for the bottom. I had over 1000 miles pulling my old lodge and they hyfax held up great but I always pulled on snow and not across asphalt much at all.   Changes I have made to them: - added a battery box and inside LEDs  - used stainless screws on the band that hods the fabric to the tub only because I don't like the look of the rusted screws.     If you think you'll be purchasing one I would recommend stopping at a Gander Mountain if you have one near by and getting a set of hyfax since they are going out of business there is a good amount of ice gear. I found hyfax recently there for $15 a set.
    • We are on Lake Edward at WildWoods RV resort just north of Merrifield, MN. It is nice just driving up, unlocking it, playing for the weekend and locker her back up and leaving the frig on.  They let Atheists and Jesus freaks all in!
  • Our Sponsors