Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
tmvikigns

Best Broad head Poll

12 posts in this topic

What is the best broad head and why? I have only been bow hunting the last 4 or so years and have killed deer using Montec g5, slick trick, also the Grimm Reaper, and Ram Cat. I really like the Ram Cat, but they are hard to find unless you go online. Only broad head I won't use again is the Grimm Reaper since I had one that did not deploy.    

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Slick trick fan here. I had a complete pass through, stuck into the ground, and its still sharp enough to shave my fingernail. Not to mention they fly exactly like my field tips. 

Edited by eyedr

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The last 5 deer I killed were with Thunderheads. I do not have to worry about them opening up, because they are a fixed blade. I have not lost a deer yet with these.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was a muzzy phantoms guys, but this year I switch to NAP Killzones and so far I like them! shot a doe ran 50 yards!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've killed deer with fixed and expandable and have had success with both.

When I was shooting a lower pound bow (55lbs).With fixed heads it seem to have a higher percentage of pass through.  Alot less drag and better penetration compared to the Rage I used earlier in my career. I've still put plenty of deer down with Rage but few pass through creating smaller blood trails.

I have a new hoyt now and I'm shooting 70lbs. Since last year I have stuck with rage Hypodermic 2". Its been an absolute killer with a 2" diameter cut. The last 3 deer I shot where hit in lungs and heart. The heart shot was nearly cut in half and the exit wound provide a waterfall of blood. The down side of the expandable: replacing blades(you really cant sharpen them like fixed broadheads), replacing shock collars, If you are stalking with an arrow knocked they might release from flight position( 90% of mn bowhunters are in tree stands) and they are kinda expensive. 

If you have had success with one type of broadhead I would stick with it. You know exactly how they fly and handle in the field. There really arent any broadheads you really need to stick away from besides (walmart)

Edited by Ohboytimmy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What is the best broad head and why? I have only been bow hunting the last 4 or so years and have killed deer using Montec g5, slick trick, also the Grimm Reaper, and Ram Cat. I really like the Ram Cat, but they are hard to find unless you go online. Only broad head I won't use again is the Grimm Reaper since I had one that did not deploy.    

I don't think it would be too much of a stretch to say that no topic has eaten up more space on hunting themed message boards than this one.  "Best" is a very subjective word to use, and I think most people would agree that there isn't a "best" broadhead for all situations.

I've shot a few different types and brands, including fixed and mechanicals.  Slick Tricks and Rage (3 blade and Hypodermic) are the only two that have flown exactly like field points for me.  Ram Cats are pretty good, but not exactly like a field point.  VPA unvented have given me the most trouble, but I really want to make them work.  I just ordered a VPA vented "custom shop", and I'll have those today for testing.  

Next year for elk I'll be using either 125g Slick Trick, or VPA's.  I won't use a mechanical on a big animal like an elk.  The smaller cutting diameter leads to better penetration and hopefully a full passthrough.  For deer I'll continue to use Rage Hypodermic.       

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used Bear Super Razorheads for years with great success.  In 2008 I switched to Rocket Steelheads and they are a dynamite, conservative cut mechanical that flies like a field point.  They are extremely durable and penetrate awesome.  I've shot over a dozen deer with them since I started using them and all but one was a complete pass through.  Good short blood trails.  Problem with them is they don't make them anymore.  I especially liked the 125 grain head.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I shot rocket steelheads for a decade and had great success with them.  I really liked them.  However, they started making them overseas and their quality control went to pot and I quit using them.  I now shoot G5 Strikers for fixed heads on big animals like elk, moose, etc. and I shoot Spitfire Maxx's for deer.  I really like the Maxx heads and Spitfire makes a rock solid mechanical.  I've watched a bunch of deer drop since I started using the Maxx's. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most heads will work just fine , if they fly true and you take the right shots . I've used wasp , sidewinders , slicktrick , swackers , and afew others to. The one that stands out the most is the T3 ! Those POS broke twice on deer ! 

I have about 10 packs of swackers so I will be using them for along time on deer 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a fan of original Muzzy 3-blades.  I've used bargain bin fixed heads, rocket mechanicals, and rage mechanicals.  They all killed deer just fine, but I settled on Muzzy's since they do the job, are cheaper than most heads, and fly just fine out of a tuned bow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •     The assumption here being that since he didn't know, nobody knew.    Because obviously, nobody is smarter than him.
    •   Thanks for the reply. I was looking at the IQ pro hunter. It is a three pin, two fixed and one that is adjustable. The other would be the 5 pin micro.   i have thought about an HHA single pin but the sight makes me nervous to have in the rut. if ever I need to take a quick shot in an area I didn't expect a deer to come from
    •     Or possibly just one, since the two parties are getting more alike all the time.   Probably not a constitutional convention in the normal sense, but as we turn more and more into a police state, there is a definite possibility of a military coup.  There was a survey done in 2015, and 43 percent of Republicans surveyed said they could envision a military coup in the U.S.   http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/2015/09/10/Military-Coup-US-Surprising-Number-Americans-Might-Support-One     Republicans (43 percent) were more likely to say they can envision a scenario in which they could support a military coup than Democrats (20 percent). Perhaps that difference is related to having a Democratic president who some critics on the right see as overstepping his power.     (What's laughable is those same critics have no problem at all with a Republican president overstepping his power.)
    • Don't have to worry, there won't be a constitutional convention.    And we will have two parties or what passes for parties for a long time.
    • This Health biatchin reminds me of a dog that keeps barking and chasing a car down a street daily--then one day the car stops and the dog doesn't know what to do so it just pizza on one tire or walks away.
    • Juneau4 and Swiveldigger  each picked up a win- 200 whoopin pts. (That has to be an all time low for winning) and they didn't have the same drivers.   We had a couple contestants that had 0 pts and that may be because they just didn't get entered in time, so I'm thinking I can put it in where you can have a Mulligan for each segment. (Your low score for 1 week is thrown out each segment-Spring, summer, and playoff.  I'll try to have a winner each segment and a overall champion.   What do you guys think? I'm just thinking if more wish to join now it would possibly make it more interesting through out the year.
    • https://xkcd.com/1732/
  • Our Sponsors