Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
RiverFish

Sturgeon Spearing.

Recommended Posts

It takes a female sturgion 28 years to reach sexual maturity and they live to over 80. A very unjust demise for such a magnificent fish. sick

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What I find to be extremely stupid is how there is no legal angling season on the Winnebago system, but theres open harvest for a day or two with the spearing. Whats up with that? And it seems like lately someones stabbing a giant every year. Sure would be cool to have at least a catch and release period on the Winnebago system. So us angling dudes could have some fun too...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
What I find to be extremely stupid is how there is no legal angling season on the Winnebago system, but theres open harvest for a day or two with the spearing. Whats up with that? And it seems like lately someones stabbing a giant every year. Sure would be cool to have at least a catch and release period on the Winnebago system. So us angling dudes could have some fun too...

I know how you feel. No legal spearing season for most sport fish in MN. It sucks when everybody isn't included.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good to see thar Wisconsin treats sturgeon like trash fish much like Minnesota treats pike like rough fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

God forbid, that people enjoy eating fish! Smoked sturgeon is the best fish I've ever tasted. If you look into this it is highly controlled by the Wisconsin DNR and it's only legal on a handful of lakes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There's just something about seeing a mammoth sturgeon sitting on the ice with a "pitchfork" sticking in it's back. I'd prefer to see spearing (at the very least for the bigger fish) banned. I understand spearing sturgeon through the ice is popular in WI, but just because it's a tradition, that doesn't make it right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There's something special about the ecosystem of Lake Winnebago that favors an extremely healthy population of sturgeon that apparently no other lake in the country has right now. I've never got a straight answer from anyone in the know as to exactly what that is, but I bet it has something to do with their breeding grounds.

I agree with the previous poster that a restricted C&R season on them for anglers would be nice. I know they taste good, and there's a long tradition with the fishery there, but personally I would not like to be the person who hauls up a 100-year + fish onto the ice and watches it die. JMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think sturgeon are very cool fish also. But why is spearing them any different than the harvest season by hook and line on the rainy? Again it is highly regulated and if the population couldn't handle it they wouldn't still be doing it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never speared any species of fish in my life and I don't know that I care too. That being said, I have a problem with people saying it should be "banned" or it is "unjust". Spearing is someone's family tradition, someone's quality time with children/parent/grandparent, someone's connection to the great outdoors. It's legal, highly regulated, and the sturgeon population doesn't seem to be suffering in Winnebago, so why do you want to take away someone's hobby/family time/outdoor time? The more stuff you ban, the less people there are who enjoy the outdoors. The less people there are who enjoy the outdoors, the less support you're gonna have, when some day, someone decides that one of your hobbies is unjust and should be banned. If it's legal, well managed, and populations are sustainable, then mind your business. Not every activity that we don't agree with or don't participate in needs to be banned!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm kind of torn on this one...It's not my tradition, and i respect others traditions. This reminds me terribly of an Antler Point Restriction.

I personally couldn't spear one, or harvest one.

It is concerning knowing how difficult it is to maintain populations. I'd hate to see them disappear, but sustained harvest i'm OK with...They are one of those species that do not reproduce fast, and we need to think 20 years ahead on how to manage them...Since it takes that long or longer to make another breading fish. We can't manage sturgeon like we do walleyes on Mille Lacs. It just takes TOO long to grow a sturgeon population.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The biggest problem with this might be that the majority of people doing this are looking to pop the biggest one they see. Its gotten to be a big competition out there. And even though its "highly regulated" and managed by the dnr, its still probably not so good to be harvesting huge breeding age fish from the best source for Lake Sturgeon in the world. Maybe the Winnebago system is unique. Maybe it can truely handle harvests like this, who knows. Personally, I dont even think the dnr can accurately predict long term benefits or consequences on such a long lived species.

Being an avid Lake Sturgeon fisherman, I would never harvest one, hook and line or spear. Thats just me. I'm sure they would be a delicious meal, but I feel their way too fragile of a species to even go there. Any fish that survived since the dinosaurs were around is pretty special. I'd like to see 'em stick around so our kids and our kids kids can enjoy them too.

And I would believe that if there were no spearing season there would be an angling season. Its strange, where else in the world is fishing banned but spearing is allowed? Strange stuff going on out there in WI...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think to date they've harvested around 260 out of lake Winnebago, and double that for the River system. Lake Winnebago is about the size of Upper Red Lake. You get one tag if you want to try it...And if you want to try the hook and line in WIsconsin, you're more than welcome to do so on Lake Wisconsin, Menominee River, The Chippewa River, or Yellow Lake. Spearing is an old tradition there, and sturgeon fishing is as analogous to hunting as it is to fishing...The only real difference is the gills...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep and you used to be able to trade a cow to get a wife and had the tradition of polluting our waters so industry could prosper. You know times do change heck I used to have the tradition of using a scatter gun from a sink box shooting lead shot at ducks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep and you used to be able to trade a cow to get a wife and had the tradition of polluting our waters so industry could prosper. You know times do change heck I used to have the tradition of using a scatter gun from a sink box shooting lead shot at ducks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And some day.... (if we sportsmen don't come together and support each other)

By "we" do you mean you and Hackbarth and the MDAA? Because your 1% seems to be playing for a different team than the rest of us.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, we should ban muskie fishing too. Everybody is always trying to catch that monster fish. I've seen 4 dead muskies floating on white bear and bald eagle that were caught and released last summer. Just because the holyer-than-thou cpr crowd throws their fish back, doesn't mean they're not killing fish. I would bet my paycheck that the cpr crowd kills 99 percent more fish than the 1 percent of spearers, due to participation numbers. Let's ban deer hunting with rifles too. It's not very sporting to pop a deer at 200 yds with a 30-06 and people are always harvesting those breeder aged does. If it's legal and sustainable, let people do their thing. Yooper is right, times do change. These days, people are always trying to tell everyone what they can and can't do. Oh btw, you can still shoot ducks, right?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

.... Hackbarth ..... seems to be playing for a different team than the rest of us.

Hackbarth... a concealed carrying Minnesota State Representative....

Personally I think the legislature needs a few more concealed carrying legislators.

.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yeah, we should ban muskie fishing too. Everybody is always trying to catch that monster fish. I've seen 4 dead muskies floating on white bear and bald eagle that were caught and released last summer. Just because the holyer-than-thou cpr crowd throws their fish back, doesn't mean they're not killing fish. I would bet my paycheck that the cpr crowd kills 99 percent more fish than the 1 percent of spearers, due to participation numbers. Let's ban deer hunting with rifles too. It's not very sporting to pop a deer at 200 yds with a 30-06 and people are always harvesting those breeder aged does. If it's legal and sustainable, let people do their thing. Yooper is right, times do change. These days, people are always trying to tell everyone what they can aned can't do. Oh btw, you can still shoot ducks, right?
yep but I can't shoot my muskys when I land them. Just have a problem with old growth fish that spawn once every three years being selectively harvested, and I really could care less what the method. I bet the commercial netters that almost wiped out the sturgion in the first place used the same arguements.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Careful, man.  Any such suggestions get criticized pretty heavily.  I came here around this time last year and posted something similar, and I hadn't been on this forum for quite some time.  My question was met by one of the mods with mock & ridicule.  But he thought that was okay as long as he put a smiley face or an lol after every sentence.  Funny, funny guy.  No wonder it's a ghost town around here.  Too bad, this was a must-read destination back in the day.
    • Here are a couple pictures from our WI season. We were able to take 5 birds. Two of us had two tags and one buddy just had one tag. Really think the predators in the area have these birds learning to be silent. They do not gobble much and if they do it’s mainly morning before fly down 2 or 3 times at the most. Over that last 5 years it’s been like this the first 10 years gobbling was heard through the day but now you don’t hear that gobbling in the distance or to calls very often. Still come to calls but almost ways silent now which is fine they still come in.   Finally all done and food plots are almost finished love the spring time.
    • Congrats on the bird
    • Congrats on the bird.
    • Assume you were in a blind since you are bow hunting.  That is a long time ...  active bird or no bird.   Very Nice.
    • Way to go!  That's persistence!
    • Way to go Britt!
    • So our bear friend came back today and she brought somebody with her. It might be time to quit feeding the birds sunflower seeds until next fall.  
    • I picked up that double bag deal about a month ago at Home Depot here in Sioux Falls. Ironically it was the same weekend we had the big April snow storm.
    • I see Home Depot advertising for Memorial day but no Kingsford double bag on sale. Has anyone seen any on sale anywhere? I am down to my last bag and need to stock up, Memorial weekend is usually the time to do it.