Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Carp-fisher

So I cooked up a gar...

8 posts in this topic

Yeah don't do it.

I caught a 3 lb shortnose this morning and decided what the heck I'll try anything once. First off, trying to clean one of those is like trying to cut through a hardened leather belt. I'd say its impossible with a normal fillet knife. I managed to get a fillet with my electric knife and sawing as hard as I could. The meat looked really good...firm and white. I threw it on the grill with some channel cat. Once the gar meat cooked, it hardened to the consistency of one of those solid rubber balls. I couldn't chew it. Maybe I did something wrong, but just the difficulty of cleaning makes the whole process seem like a waste of energy.

Anyone else here weird enough to try gar?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah don't do it.

I caught a 3 lb shortnose this morning and decided what the heck I'll try anything once. First off, trying to clean one of those is like trying to cut through a hardened leather belt. I'd say its impossible with a normal fillet knife. I managed to get a fillet with my electric knife and sawing as hard as I could. The meat looked really good...firm and white. I threw it on the grill with some channel cat. Once the gar meat cooked, it hardened to the consistency of one of those solid rubber balls. I couldn't chew it. Maybe I did something wrong, but just the difficulty of cleaning makes the whole process seem like a waste of energy.

Anyone else here weird enough to try gar?

you did something wrong. lol.

there is a HSOforum showing how to easily clean gar. and it involves using a saw and tin snips. lol

here is a recipe that was also on the site

"Simple Gar Recipe: Another great gar recipe is to slice your gar meat up into nuggets. Purchase some Louisiana crab boil from your local grocery store. Boil some water with the crab boil spices. Once the water has came to a rolling boil put in your gar meat. Let it boil for just a few minutes (depends on the amount) and then turn off the stove and let the gar meat soak in the crab boil for about 5 minutes. Melt a stick of butter. Take your gar nuggets and dip them in the butter. This will actually have a lobster taste to it. Delicious!!!"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ufdah. I don't think I could go through the process of filleting one as I'd probably saw a finger off before getting a fillet from the deal. I'd definitely give it a taste though. Cheers on the effort.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I heard of one person eating a gar before this, and they said it was "not to bad"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I could see trying the crab boil technique. Like I said before, the meat looked really good. Maybe I overcooked it or something. Those gar are some unique and viscous fish...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One a side note, I also grilled up a couple of 4lb channel cats (bigger than I usually keep--I go for the 1 and 2 lbers)---put them on tinfoil with some butter, lime juice, and taco seasoning. Then made some fish tacos. I'd put those tacos up against any restaurant fish tacos in the cities here. Delicious!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Think im gonna try good old grass clippings since they seem to replenish themselves very rapidly
    • My good buddy from back in SD does fantasy and we have another group we are apart of and he ended up tied for 5th overall last tourney. After day 3 he was in 3rd with the possibility to win it. So close to getting that $2500 basspro card
    • After the cold snap, temps on Trout were back down in the high 40s. Back around 53 now, and should keep warming if the forecast holds. Fish have already moved shallow, bedmaking and piscine lovemaking will follow soon for the brown ones. I am hitting Leech tomorrow...will be interesting to see what water temps are in the protected parts of the bays.
    • Here's some useful information: go shallow, and chuck a swim jig with a paddle tail trailer and set the hook til your arms fall off. Better?
    •   If you like to tinker with guns, you can get a surplus Saiga for a couple hundred bucks.  All sorts of accessories available for these, and they can also be converted to 12 gauge if that's your preference.          
    • I was out last night on a local lake and was surprised to see the water temp down to 57.  Caught a couple cookie cutter fish, but not the big ones I was looking for. Fished a lot of weeds in the 6-9ft range, but not a lot going on there. The biggest one was still shallow in some reeds, so not sure if we are still in the spawn/post spawn stage.     Whats everyone else seeing out there for a bite and fishing conditions. Big weekend coming up, Good luck!! 
    • Maxine_Partain, Welcome to the forum.  There seem to be a lot of folks from Canada joining up in the last half a year which is nice. The sad thing is they all seem to make about 3 posts on the same day they joined and then they never come back which is sad. Hopefully you will keep posting.
    •   Hazel Hain, Welcome to the forum.  There seem to be a lot of folks from Canada joining up in the last half a year which is nice. The sad thing is they all seem to make about 3 posts on the same day they joined and then they never come back which is sad. Hopefully you will keep posting.
    • hi and welcome to HSO. I think you mean double hung not double pane. if you have moisture between the panes you have a seal failure. depending on the brand you might be able to just replace the glass. If you have lots of rot you may need to do a complete replacement. Best to have a window person pop by and check out the situation. 
  • Our Sponsors