Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
brittman

SoDak 2009 Pheasants Down 26%

22 posts in this topic

SoDak 2009 Pheasants Down 26%

Down 35% - 45% across the area neighboring much of MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you mean only 70 get up from the cornfield instead of 100, thats still pretty good odds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm with you fishroger.....It's probably a good thing...the few times I have had the chance to go to So Dak there has been what I think, is too many birds...I know that sounds crazy but when waves of a hundred birds are getting up at a time.....It's too much....plus my setter was on point the whole time...Had to release her from point every thirty seconds "literally" in this one field we hunted...Crazy!!!..I know alot of you will call call me crazy so I should probably just keep my mouth shut and stay in the grouse woods! Have a great season!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Much depends upon if you are

hunting core areas or fringe population areas

hunting private land vs public land

hunting private land where operators constantly replenish birds shot with pen raised birds (secretly). More (pen raised) pheasants hatched in MN are sold to SD operators than anywhere else. blush

I am more concerned that the trend seen in Brookings and Watertown will spill over into western MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brittman is absolutely correct. All the birds in South Dakota are planted. Minnesota folks ought to just stay home and go to the game preserves instead. The thousand or so birds I put up out of a half section of pig weed last December were definitely planted by the 70 year old farmer who let me hunt for free. That old coot must be really busy at night! The hundreds of birds I put up in the walk in areas each year are probably planted by the game department. What I'm trying to figure out his how they can afford it. I've raised pheasants and you'd be hard pressed to hatch and feed them for $7 a bird. The license costs around $110 and I've shot 15 a trip twice a year for the last 5 years. That means it's costing them about $100 a year just for me to come there. SDGF must be bunch of nice guys.

All kidding aside I'm sure some places plant birds, but if you aren't paying $150 a gun a day or staying at some ritzy lodge, I doubt your hunting planted birds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went and checked the 2009 survey. It looks like the areas hardest hit are the ones that are the most commercialized. So in reality that wont affect the hunting much at all. Not for the guys who have to work for wild birds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if the numbers are down from last year its only because last year was a record high year. this year although lower than last year will still be a well above average year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am more concerned that the trend seen in Brookings and Watertown will spill over into western MN.

Britt: What trend are you speaking of? Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brittman is absolutely correct. All the birds in South Dakota are planted. Minnesota folks ought to just stay home and go to the game preserves instead. The thousand or so birds I put up out of a half section of pig weed last December were definitely planted by the 70 year old farmer who let me hunt for free. That old coot must be really busy at night! The hundreds of birds I put up in the walk in areas each year are probably planted by the game department. What I'm trying to figure out his how they can afford it. I've raised pheasants and you'd be hard pressed to hatch and feed them for $7 a bird. The license costs around $110 and I've shot 15 a trip twice a year for the last 5 years. That means it's costing them about $100 a year just for me to come there. SDGF must be bunch of nice guys.

All kidding aside I'm sure some places plant birds, but if you aren't paying $150 a gun a day or staying at some ritzy lodge, I doubt your hunting planted birds.

First off that is NOT WHAT IS SAID.

Yah but some of the guys paying $350 to $600 per day are hunting tame released birds. If you are hunting high $ private land and see roosters outnumber hens then maybe??? If they do not say WILD Birds only then ...

Buyer Beware.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: brittman

I am more concerned that the trend seen in Brookings and Watertown will spill over into western MN.

Britt: What trend are you speaking of? Thanks

Pheasant count down 35 - 45% in western MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...Buyer Beware....

When it come's to hunting in SoDak, this is the best advice you can give. Public lands = Wild Birds. Private lands, guided hunts = Wild Birds confusedwinkwhistle mabe, sort of, well at least some of them right.

I think if your motives are pure, you are going out there to have a good time, and shoot some birds, you get out of it what you put into it. Phesants are BIG buisness down there. The big $money$ outfitters have to "replenish" the birds once in a while so there are a lot of birds out there to be had. Otherwise why would you book after the first couple weeks of the season? If you spend that kind of cash on a "you should have been here last week" type hunt, you are likely not going to come back and spend the money the next year.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pheasant count down 35 - 45% in western MN.

Where did you get the MN numbers from?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Britt is refering to the SD numbers. Britt, any idea as to what is causing this trend in SD? Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like to know the source citing these numbers for SD? The Argusleader in Sioux Falls had a story in the paper yesterday with a chart that showed the numbers for this year are going to be above average?

Here is a link: (source was from the Argus Leader) No links allowed thank you!

6.32 birds per mile sounds pretty nice to me. Yes that is a state wide average, but I run my dogs almost everyday of the week and I have no problem seeing birds along the roads where ever I go, even just outside of town here in Sioux Falls which is far from the prime areas.

I travel through Brookings and drive Hwy 14 both east and west often and always see birds. Nothing to be concerned about in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
Originally Posted By: brittman

Pheasant count down 35 - 45% in western MN.

Where did you get the MN numbers from?

Someone asked what my concern was ... that was my answer.

That is not the count ... sorry for the confusion.

MN pheasant count is usually held tightly to the DNR's chest until mid to late September.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Britt is refering to the SD numbers. Britt, any idea as to what is causing this trend in SD? Thanks

Winter had an impact, cooler - wetter? spring must have hurt too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: brittman
...Buyer Beware....

The big $money$ outfitters have to "replenish" the birds once in a while so there are a lot of birds out there to be had. Otherwise why would you book after the first couple weeks of the season? If you spend that kind of cash on a "you should have been here last week" type hunt, you are likely not going to come back and spend the money the next year.

No way ... if you spend that king of money it better be wild birds ... otherwise pay $17/bird and visit a MN preserve.

For more "discussion" Please google search Doug Smith Star Tribune December 24th SD pheasant article....

I shoot the majority of my roosters on the second half of the season. In part because that is when I spend more time hunting. The birds are not exhausted after the 1st two weeks of hunting ... gosh you don't even see the majority of them "lost" in the sea of corn.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You guys can keep your numbers. Even if they are down 99% I will still be out there with my dogs chasing the last couple birds. The numbers mean nothing to me or the dogs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Following up on the links provided by rundrave and 311hemi, here is part of the SD GFP news release:

PIERRE, S.D. – The S.D. Game, Fish and Parks Department counted an average of 6.32 pheasants per mile in 2009 as part of its annual pheasant brood survey, the fourth highest statewide count in the past 45 years.

Although this year’s statewide index has decreased from last year, the 2009 statewide pheasant per mile count is 13 percent higher than the 10-year average.

In 2007 GFP reported the highest brood route survey count in over 40 years. The count went even higher in 2008. Even though pheasant numbers remain strong, the 2009 survey reveals a 26 percent decrease from 2008.

“The pheasant brood route survey is the standard for gauging how the pheasant population is doing,” GFP Secretary Jeff Vonk said. “Our data represents a very good reflection of pheasant numbers in the areas we survey. While our pheasant population is down from 2008 record, the good news is there are still a lot of pheasants out there heading into the hunting season.”

“In the past 45 years only 2005, 2007 and 2008 have a higher pheasant per mile count than we found this year,” Vonk said

GFP surveys 110 routes of 30 miles each over a three week period from late July to mid August. Survey data is used to calculate a pheasants per mile index for these routes. GFP can then compare the number of pheasants within each local area on a year-to-year basis, and also against a 10-year average.

“Considering the tremendous pheasant populations we’ve had the past couple of years, I believe even with this decline South Dakota will continue to offer the premier pheasant hunting opportunity in the nation,” Vonk said. “For a historical perspective, we had a pheasant per mile count of 2.69 birds in 2002, yet hunters still harvested over 1.2 million roosters that year.”

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I've had it on a few different lakes and still the same result. I'm a tungsten jig type of person, thought those showed up better on the vex?? Bigger profile jigs show up better than small. Any type of jig is a in-out flicker. Been on some finiky fish lately,  used some very small jigs and they barely show up. I'll try the battery next! Thanks guys
    • https://news.google.com/#pcid=ncl-dI28YSQEZfeNHXMQgNq8v7tc9GlTM&pt=FRONTPAGE  
    • If your ex can get prostate cancer......
    • It was doing bad under pawlenty?
    • I know I would  That bacon really looked good!!!
    • Word of caution !! Lake Superior will generate a east wind for days and the fish bite great. I think it has something to do with the air sinking out in the center and it pushes in all directions and in Duluth we get the wind out of the east.
    • This weekend I got a chance to use the 6" Nils with my Dewalt. That was crazy fast and had both of my brothers asking more questions about the whole setup. I believe the 6" cuts faster then my 8" Nils with the Tanaka motor and I thought that was fast.
    • Some possibilities in the St. Paul / SE metro area.   Joe's sporting goods in St. Paul Blue Ribbon Bait in Oakdale Ace Hardware in IGH   There is another bait shop off of HWY 10 in Newport, but I'm not sure if it's still there and google can't seem to find it.  I also seem to remember a gas station on Concord, south of the St. Paul Airport somewhere that has bait, but I just randomly ran into it one afternoon and I might be confused.  
    • Ya, me too.....they're extremely rare animals nowadays.. I searched (online) every hardware store, box store, Home Improvement, office supply store....zip. Only place that has them...Walmart. I suggest ya hit the used a bit and goodwill stores, they always seem to have a few. I'll keep my peepers open for ya for a good one if ya want, otherwise, get someone to order for ya off of Amazon Prime.
    • Hey everyone, had the opportunity to get out with my new jiffy 4lite propane, an Ion, and the Clam Drill plate kit (drill plate/gear box/auger with 18v Dewalt).  I was with 25 guys and I was the only one with augers. So it was the perfect time to try out all three and see what was preferred. In the end the ratings would be:   Jiffy 5/5 Ion 4/5 Clam 4/5   The propane was faster and cut the lake like a hot knife on butter. The Ion and Clam were not as fast, but were still able to cut plenty of holes without any issues. The batteries on the clam did not last as long, but if I were to buy higher amp batteries that could be solved. The Ion was slower than the other two but was consistent and did cut a lot of holes.
  • Our Sponsors