Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Muskiefool

Motivation

64 posts in this topic

Ive seen a few things that often make me wonder,, say someone catches a fish on a certain body of water or in a specific bay; why would anyone want to name that body of water?? from my experience all it does is add pressure to the lake, the reality of the state of Muskies in MN is that 55+ fish is in every lake in the range with the exception of a very few.

What do you gain from asking what lake I caught it on the first thing out of your mouth? how's about a congrats then the q&a, I decided a few years ago that I would never give exact size or location of any fish caught because of it irrelevancy to anything but myself; you know what; you really notice a few things about people after that, I'll even say different lakes in the same sentence just to see if your paying attention to the places that I didn't catch the fish.

Whats the motivation, not enough company and competition for spots? I don't get it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess nobody has to ask what bait anymore, they just assume it was caught on a cowgirl. smile

I caught myself doing that just this morning. The guy at the cabin next door showed me a photo of a big fish this morning that he had caught a week or so ago. I simply said,

"Did you catch it here on Vermilion"? To which he simply replied. "No, I caught it in the Leech lake area". So that narrowed it down to about 35 lakes.

"Ace"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree MF. Never kiss and tell. If you do, expect more pressure to said lake. We only have a handful of big bodies of water. Even the big lakes are effected by pressure as a lot of the fish stack up in small areas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess I can see both sides to it, but honestly feel differently.

Think to yourself a moment and pretend you are given the location to a secret lake. A lake in which all your fishing dreams came true. Now the kicker to this information is that you can NEVER EVER share it with anyone....not the location.....not the details.....not even the sights and sounds you see or hear on this lake.

Truly think about not being able to share that with anyone. Not your family, not your friends, nobody.

What fun would that be?

These are fish we are talking about. Fish

Life is WAY to short to worry how many people know about fish X or spot Y or lake Z.

I guess it's the difference between half/full and half/empty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nothing wrong with sharing some general info. with a pic if one decides to. Those are the best reports. Like MF said, what's the point of naming the lake? There isn't one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing is there are no secrets if there are Muskies there are people fishing them, the way it works is if say a fish that's large is caught everyone thinks they are bubbling out of the water so the Muskie world descends on whats usually a small lake with 10-15 spots.

Even Big V is getting small by most I know that are fishing there..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

John,

Good post.

I was burned years ago very bad!! I learned to block out even the background if I choose not to let the world know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hate to say it, but I study the background of fish pictures all of the time. Especially if a general area is given or a certain poster is known to fish a certain area, I almost can always tell what lake. Obvious landmarks are always a give away. Right Jerry, JK. grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I love sharing photos, but I block out backgrounds because I enjoy having these spots to myself when I can. More people look at this site than post on it, I saw a guy out tonight that told me he saw pictures of fish I caught online, obviously on this site, but he doesn't post. It's a small world- share what you want to, and have fun with it. No need to make it so serious, like dtro said they're just FISH, and it's just FISHING.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I always chop shop the pics on our site, Ive added a low spots and a few docks(the fish and fishermen are always untouched); on a recent one it was altered greatly, Ive told people 10 diff lakes and they all know the spot it was caught on that lake.

I think they have a better chance of getting a big fish from the theoretical confidence they have on a lake I may have never fished than if I GPS'ed them the spot to fish.

BTW its 99% luck and thanks to the hard work of a few good people over the years and the DNR she is everywhere, so we all have the chance for the fish of a life.

I would encourage people to think before they boast, those of us who appreciate your fish for what she is will do so without specific details on location.

Whats more important for you to share are the small things like the wind, the moon position, if the humidity kicked up, if the clouds rolled in and how she was related to structure or specific forage; was she the first fish you saw, was she active and rolling etc.

If you give me those keys it helps allot more than the lake or spot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

See now if you fished in Wisconsin you'd know that you can fish a musky lake all day like I did today and not see anyone throwing big baits, and Saturday I only saw one other musky fisherman. This is actually pretty typical as long as you aren't fishing Deer, Bone, Holcombe, or Wissota. But there's probably 10,000 acres of good water near lakes with very few fisherman on them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
Deer, Bone, Holcombe, or Wissota.

I like my fish to be over 37" j/k... Sorry couldn't resist!

It's up to the fisherman whether they want to give out their spots or not. It sounds like some people have really deep issues on this subject. I don't get so worked up about it but I am very easy going when it comes to Muskie fishing.

I personally think that you need to rephrase your comment and keep going after the DNR to add more lakes and fast. The sooner we have more lakes to fish the lighter the pressure will be on your spots.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When it comes to muskies I dont mind saying the lake I caught a fish from. For the most part they are big lakes and already recieve plenty of traffic. I probably wont give out the spot to someone I dont fish with. When it comes to my bass lakes though my lips are sealed smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MF, you must hate guides who make their living off taking people out to lakes and showing them fish and spots.

I dont like a crowd on the water, but i have gotten used to it. You siad it is 99% luck anyway. So who cares. Post pics at your own risk, i guess. I post one every once in a while. I dont post many, because no matter what you do, someone on this site will complain about something. Holding fish wrong, not deleting the backround, giving lake name, too many pics, taking pics when water temps are up, etc.

Why try to grow the sport, if you are just gonna get mad when see the people on the water. I guess i should start telling people that i hate musky fishing, to keep them from trying.

I think educating the novice fisherman would help the sport more than everyone lying and being extra secretive.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh and Dhanson, guess what lake my profile pic fish is from.

email me, [pleasebecomeasponsor]@yahoo.com. I think it would be hard to tell, but who knows, could be fun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ya, I boated this real nice 48. The fish that was in my avitar for a while. When I brought the pic into the lodge the only thing they where looking at was the backround/shoreline.. the docks. Then they had a guessing game on what spot it was on the lake before anything else was said.

Kind of an erker... but... what else do you expect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with most statements but with some locations that can be over fished or pressured easily because of proximity of people an easy background picture could have serious effects to the fishery. I know for exact were Bronzeback fishes and with respect to him and his hard work I will never share or ask were he's fishing but if he showed any kind of landmarks it could cause allot of problems. Nice fish to bronzeback and everyone that shares there pictures on line and thank you for not exposing the locations to sensitive bays or lakes.

Generally if you do state a lake like Leech or Mille Lacs that can be enough information and will not have any ramification to the resource unless you take it one step further and point out the location which most people don't do anyways.

that's just my .02

mr

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[pleasebecomeasponsor] I sent you an e-mail. Pretty sure I got that one right. grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK, Dhanson had a good point. He guessed my fish, first guess, about 5 mins after posting.

I hope not everyone is that good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Seems to me a lot of you could send more time fishing than worrying about this garbage. At least wait till we're not at season peak with fish jumping in the boat! How about when there's ice out there...

I don't like seeing places named any more than anyone else and it's something you should really think about before mentioning.

But oh well, what are ya gonna do. Back to the lake!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea, I now get very nasty emails from a few certain forum lurkers... and haven't mentioned a specific lake in awhile. No more photos or muskie reports from me...at least of decent fish. I don't know if it is the economy or what, but folks this year can be downright nasty. However, it pales in comparison to the flack I get for interrupting CSI for a tornado warning and messing with a few hundred thousand folks at once! The theme this year seems to be "let em die, it's not my town..." Sad where we have gone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good point JRedig about waiting. I bet people are less likely to flock when they find out the fish was caught a month ago.

But when it comes to any type of fishing, I really try hard not to let this issue bother me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
Deer, Bone, Holcombe, or Wissota.

I like my fish to be over 37" j/k... Sorry couldn't resist!

It's up to the fisherman whether they want to give out their spots or not. It sounds like some people have really deep issues on this subject. I don't get so worked up about it but I am very easy going when it comes to Muskie fishing.

I personally think that you need to rephrase your comment and keep going after the DNR to add more lakes and fast. The sooner we have more lakes to fish the lighter the pressure will be on your spots.

Well that's sort of implied. Another thing is the lakes Minnesota stocks tend to be large lakes that already have a ton of pressure for other species. Rather than stocking all large lakes it might more sense to stock systems of lakes (appendix B of the long range plan). Stock say a river headwater lake and let them trickle down through the system. After all nearly all native muskies in the world relate to a river system, not standalone lakes.

I'll use Polk County, Wi as an example (where my cabin is so I know it well).

Code:
Lake Name         	Acres 	Class
Apple River Flowage*  	639 	B
Bear Trap Lake  	241 	C
Big Blake Lake 	        302 	C
Big Round Lake 	        1015 	C
Black Brook Flowage*	98 	C
Bone Lake*	        1781 	A2
Bridget Lake (Mud) 	95 	C
Deer Lake*              807 	A2
Indianhead Flowage  	776 	C
Wapogasset Lake  	1186 	C
White Ash Lake	        153 	C

I starred the waters that were stocked when this list was made (Wapogasset and Bear Trap were added to stocking since). Of the 11 only 4 were stocked, the other 7 have migrant fish through the Apple River system. Big Round even holds a line class record for a muskie (a 50lber) having never been stocked for muskie (and muskie are not native anywhere in the county).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Well Molly doesn't have any snow on her.   You been drinkin?  
    • 70 pages dealing with Donald Trump and I can't find much that says anything on the positive side, of course in the past year and a half he hasn't said much that's been positive either.
    • @Neighbor_guy    Oh, I think the dismount was memorable too. 
    • I have fished for trout in my home waters for fifty-five years. The places I call home are the waters of the Wisconsin driftless area. Trout are my favorite species to chase. The trout of my waters have fluctuated over my more than a half century of fishing. Trout are instinctual creatures.  The big wily brown trout are my quarry.  They are portrayed as superior entities when in fact they have a brain the size of a pea. Do you want the keys to the castle?   I have seen many trends and fads come and go in the trout world.  This fancy rod and that special fly have cycled through a dozen times in my lifetime. Anglers come and go and so do the latest new fangled trends.  The constants in the trout world are the seasons and good old Mother Nature.  If you want a real leg up on those trout you should pay attention to the seasons and the changes they cause in the trout’s environment.     The weather in Wisconsin can be a harsh mistress.  The extremes are the norm here.  We could have twenty inches of snow on the ground and below zero temperatures and what seems like a blink of the eye in Wisconsin it changes.  The snow could melt and the next time you go fishing it could be radically different.  You need to roll with the seasonal changes and modify the way you fish and where you fish.

        This frigid morning in January was shaping up to be a “skunk” outing.  My friend was cold and told me he had enough and wanted to head back to the vehicle.  I talked him out of heading back.  We had taken the stream temperatures earlier and we hadn’t found a one reading over thirty-six degrees.

      The outdoor temperature was twenty-six degrees and not looking like it was going to warm up.  I had scouted this area prior and our fishing was going to get better I told him.
        Do you see the log laying on the right side of the stream?  Just on the other side of the log is a tiny trickle feeding in.  This trickle is a tiny spring.  Springs run year round here at about forty-two degrees constant.  Where that spring fed in caused a six degree temperature swing just downstream.  That little trickle made the stream bearable for the trout.    I have found many trickles during the early season when the grass is down that I cannot see even a month later due to weed growth.  It was like the Bahamas in that halo of the spring.  We caught seven trout in that tiny spot. Many feeders are not easily found during the summer.  They are covered up by weeds.  You can only discover them when the weeds are down in winter or early spring. I emphasize the word trickle here because they may be tiny and you will miss them if you are not looking for them.   My friend Andy and I fished this exact hole in September.  We both caught four trout each in this bend in September.  We couldn’t buy a bite in March.  What was different now?  First off the water temperatures were in the sixties in September and in the middle thirties in March. Trout lay in different areas during cold and warm conditions.     In Wisconsin winters the trout are in survival mode.  They need to find good lays where they don’t have to expend too much energy to hold in place and wait for food. The calories required to hold in place in this cold fast water is a negative formula for calories gained. This shallow fast current hole is great when the water temperatures are in the sixties and the trout can hide in the broken fast water.  In thirty degree water this holding place has no one home.  I would look for the deepest water either direction for two hundred yards.  This is where the trout would winter.
      One picture says a thousand words.  It was twenty degrees below out this day. The water temperature at this spring head tells the tale. It measured at forty degrees.  I like to call these Bahamas causing the water temperatures to fluctuate. A thermometer is a must to get a leg up on these instinctual creatures. This spring is a glaring thermal. 

       Many anglers discount some thermals because they are not so obvious.  A swamp is nothing more than a spring spreading out and they have the same properties as a small stream emptying into a larger waterway.  There does not need to be an obvious entry point to these swamps causing thermals.  They can leech through the surrounding banks and make their way into your stream.
        I am going to stay on thermals but switch seasons.  The temperature fluctuations you found to indicate where to find the wily trout in winter holds true in the dog days of summer.  I went with a Natural Resources crew to do a shocking.     The stretch we were to shock was a non-designated area way below typical trout water.  Even on a typical summer’s day in Wisconsin this waterway was almost too warm to fish in it.  Many anglers considered this “frog water” and dismissed it.  What a giant mistake they were making. 

       When water temperatures are near seventy degrees, it is recommended not to fish for trout.  It plain and simply puts too much stress on the fish and raises the mortality rates to an unacceptable risk for the trout.  Streams that are warmer have less dissolved oxygen in them.  Trout caught in water near seventy degrees have a hard time recovering from a battle due to the lack of oxygen.     I was in charge of the thermometer and Garmin on this trek into frog water with the fisheries folks.  Every thirty yards I was asked to take the temperature and write it down with the GPS coordinates. I was asked to submerge the thermometer at least halfway to the bottom to take the readings. I needed to hold the thermometer in place for ten seconds. I also was advised to make sure there was no secondary warming from my hands holding it.  The lead worker said the trout actually live in the lower half of water columns. The water temperatures hovered around seventy degrees at first.  We did not shock up trout in these areas.   We started to shock up some trout.  They were smaller fish.  I took the temperature and there was a slight change.  I looked around for a spring or a feeder creek.  There were none to be found. The fisheries staff told me to take more frequent measurements and log them. They were trying to prove a theory they had. I measured every ten yards on this stretch.  The temperatures continued to go down. The water temperatures were in the low sixties now and we were shocking numerous trout to the surface.  It was quite amazing how the numbers and sizes of the trout increased as the water got colder on this stretch.   We shocked up some true monsters from this waterway and then they just vanished.  The alpha or large predator trout had the lays in the coolest hides.  I could not see anything feeding in.  It was a true mystery to me.  There was a swamp about thirty yards from the stream.  It had no obvious entry points.  I followed my thermometer to its access point.  The swamp leeched into the stream and the only tell tale evidence was found with my thermometer.  

       The only visual evidence was softer banks that extended a couple of feet toward the swamps near the coldest points and these were my thermals.  I would not have discovered them without my thermometer. You can guess where the biggest brown were shock up correct?  Their noses were stuck right in the area where the trickles fed in.   I fish with many folks and they must grow weary of waiting for me to quit messing with my thermometer. Some stretches I fish regularly I leave my thermometer in my vest because of my historical data. My friend Dan Braun and I took a break during the midday of fishing due to water temperatures being too high and dangerous for the trout.  The outside temperature this day was eighty-eight degrees.  Dan took a temperature check at this spring head and it measured forty degrees. It is amazing to see a light bulb go on when another angler finally figures out why I am fiddling with my thermometer.
        The next time you fire up your computer check out the thermometers for sale.  There are many new and trendy versions.  There are many kinds.  I believe a keep it simple purchase is in order.  A bungee cord to hook them to your vest is a must purchase. A durable thermometer with easy to read numbers is what I carry. 

       I have been drawn to marginal frog water for over half a century now in Wisconsin’s driftless area.  My photos of big browns don’t lie.


       
    • Moose is staying home with no ice
    • Those "extended warranties" are mainly a cheap scam. The small print will ruin your day. And buying one AFTER  you have have the vehicle for a while compounds the mess.  Don't do it.
    • Til the end of my days, I will never understand why the northern states don't just stay open til January. What's it gonna hurt?
  • Our Sponsors