Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Jameson

Late doe season anyone?

24 posts in this topic

How would you feel about a late doe only season where needed? Kinda like our early doe season only after regular firearms season.

Describe your own season if you want one. Mine would be the last 9 days of muzzleloader season opened up to all hunters with a regular firearms license. All unused tags from earlier seasons would be good for anterless deer only. Archer/Muzzleloader hunters would still be able to either/or hunt during this time, following all regulations for their season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My perfect season would begin on the 2nd weekend in November, it would be a 5 day buck only where no spikes, forks, or yearling bucks could get shot. No APR, no EAB, you just have to shoot a mature buck over 1.5 years old. The Deer season would close for two days, and then a 9 day management season would run the week of Thanksgiving. Then 5 days closed, and ML season starts and goes until January 1st. BTW, this is just my wishful thinking and I know that it is not at all a reality, its just what I would like to see in my perfect hunting world. Also, youth under 16 could shoot whatever they wanted the first season, buck or doe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

not much interest huh? I guess that's why we don't have a late anterless season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I could see one in SE MN, 346 and 349. I would like to see it like Iowa does in the southern teer of the state, rifle season for does, I believe it is one weekend only. I would be all for a January doe season in SE MN with rifles, it would give a chance to rifle hunt where I slug hunt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

were i hunt by the end of muzzy season the bigger bucks are droping their antlers. could be alot of nice bucks shot as does. not a good idea atleast were i hunt

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the area to have a late season is overpopulated with deer does it really matter if it is a buck or a doe? Sure it would be better if it was a doe, but a 200-300 pound buck still eats and effects it's surroundings. I don't think anyone is suggesting a late season state wide, but rather only in areas with overpopulated deer. These hunts would not be conducted to get the buck to doe ratio back in check, these hunts would not be conducted as trophy hunts, these hunts would be conducted to lower the deer population. A dead doe or a dead buck still lowers the population, just a doe is more significant in the long run.

Perhaps if a late anterless season isn't popular a late earn-a-buck season might be. Anyone with a remaining buck tag would need to shoot a anterless before filling their buck tag during the late season hunt. Just an idea.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so you are saying lets take out a high quality buck from the gene pool and leave a small less quality one that still may have horns. i think it does matter if it is a doe or buck. shooting does will lower a population shooting a buck that late is just one less eating winter food and that same doe will be around to have two more fawns that next year. what have you really accomplished except taking the chance of a trophy from someone. is it not the goal of most to get higher quality of deer in the state. just my .02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jabug, do you have a proposal for any kind of late season anterless hunt?

You mention that the bucks are dropping by you by the end of muzzleloader season. Do you then think that bow season should close at the end of muzzleloader season? How about we move the muzzleloader season up some how and replace it with a anterless season?

C'mon jabug, don't just sit back and be a critic, let's hear some constructive ideas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i don't want to see a late season hunt. bow hunting takes so few deer that late it is not an issue. i think the muzzy season should have been left alone with either sex not this doe permit stuff. if there is an area that is that populated let the intensive harvest rules go and mother nature will take care of the rest. sorry that you seem so irritated that i didn't jump on the late season bandwagon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If guys aren't dropping does during earlier seasons, why would they be out there shooting does when first ice fishing is firing up, holiday parties are going on, the deer are spookier than all get out, and it is just plain cold. I would be out there, but not many will. It is not going to be very effective as a population control tool.

lakevet

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

jabug, Sorry if I came off as being irritated, but it is frustrating to put forth an idea, ask others for ideas, and then have people be critical of anothers idea without offering up their own idea to fix a problem. Thanks for your responses. I see now that either you don't think their is a problem, or are unwilling to do anything to fix the problem.

lakevet, I see your point. During the regular season the whole state is open for hunting and hunters spread out. If a late season hunt was implemented only in certain areas it would force the hunters to only hunt certain areas. Like you said, you would be out there, I may be out there, and some others would be out there. If their are not enough willing hunters if it was a anterless only season than perhaps change it to an Earn a buck season. That might entice a few more participants. Or maybe if a person tags a doe during the late season they are allowed to apply for some rare hunt in a State Park that takes place before the next regular season. Or for each doe they harvest it counts as a point for the hunter for the Lottery areas. Just some ideas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

state wide earn a buck would be a good idea. then along with that put a points restriction on. i for one hate to see all them forks and sixes shot up and then the same people complain there are no nice bucks. try it for a year or two and i think you would see some nice racks out there

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you think the whole state needs to be EAB you need to educate yourself on some of the areas other than where you hunt. Parts of the state easily could be, much of it's now doe lottery & should be, there's a chunk where the populations now about right. This state is definitely not a one size fits all state.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we were to move the season back a week or two, what would this accomplish? This is a pretty loaded question, so answer with care? Ideal season would leave it where it is, educate hunters on what the ramifications are from taking the 1.5 year olds. The early anterless season already increases the doe harvest significantly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is there a problem with taking 1.5 year old does? I think they are mighty tasty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...try it for a year or two and i think you would see some nice racks out there

I currently see some nice racks out there. No need to try anything like that statewide.

sick Maybe if you aren't seeing big racks it might be from degraded habitat caused by overpopulated deer and a late doe season might help in your area????? blushgrin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

in the area i hunt we have some real nice racks. i personally have four on the wall over 140. that is a result of leaveing the smaller bucks go. it all boils down to if you want to manage for big bucks or numbers. where i hunt there is a very good population of deer that have a good buck to doe ratio. i understand that not all areas of the state are the same. going back to the original post i do not favor a late hunt atleast not in the areas i hunt for the reason i stated earlier, i have seen to many nice bucks shot even during the early part of muzzy season that have dropped their horns. i would hate to see how many would go down if it was a all out rifle hunt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...atleast not in the areas i hunt ...

So..............In an area overpopulated with deer; An area ripe for disease outbreak (TB, CWD, etc.) In an area with very evident browse lines; In an area with high car-deer collisions; you could maybe be for a late season hunt, even if it meant some bucks got shot with out their antlers? Or are you so protective of those antlers that you would rather risk that same buck die a winter-kill, or a car-deer statistic, or of disease?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you really seem mad that i do not favor a late season. to throw another bone out there for you i don't like the early hunt either. if an area has that high of a population it should be intensive harvest already so go shoot your five deer and be happy. with bow,rifle,and muzzy season you have 3 1/2 months to do that. if you can't get them in that time a few more days won't help. when all else fails the dnr will come in and kill off what they feel is neccesary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is already a late season in the TB zone. Or should I say there has been the last 2 years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow jabug we agree on something. I don't like the EA season either. IMO it has the potential to screw up opening day of firearms.

jerkbait, whoops your right! I guess I looked into hunting that and wrote it off for various reasons so long ago that I just overlook it. Thanks for pointing that out!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
if an area has that high of a population it should be intensive harvest already so go shoot your five deer and be happy. with bow,rifle,and muzzy season you have 3 1/2 months to do that. if you can't get them in that time a few more days won't help. when all else fails the dnr will come in and kill off what they feel is neccesary.

The DNR won't come in and kill them off unless there is a disease threat. They will use us as to reduce the population, that could come in the form of EAB if we can't do it without it. Wisconsing needed to do it. I would hope though, that they would learn from Wisconsin's mistakes and only do it for one year, and then reevaluate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Keep an eye on those trees. They tend to jump in the way when your not looking.    won't be the same without ya. 
    • Truth be told it was the outstate money that originally built the metro into what it is. Without that funding St Paul would be nothing more than St Peter is today. 
    • Can't argue with the last part
    • I wonder if a person gets an extended warranty if that will help?  I have a 2011 with 5.3 silverado and all is good today so I'm thinking og looking into that.
    • My last kayak adventure was less than stellar wound up in the drink. And it was a cold drink at that. A very memorable paddle up to that point. It was the first time I had ever been on the water with snow on everything. It was awesome.    Alas, my 'yaks are all put up for the season now. Waiting for next years adventures to begin. 
    • I am toying with the idea of doing a little calling this weekend. The moon is nice and dark, so the first and last few minutes  of daylight might make something happen. It all depends on what I stumble into for sign. The majority of the deer hunters have been done for a while, so the free meals are going to be getting harder to come by. 
    • The fans I was talking about are 12 volt and only 1" deep. Putting them under the heater might not do the job because the heat from heater rises. If you have room in the lower cabinet on your heater you could mount one fan inside and blow the heat out the grill on the front of the heater.
    • I thought last night's game was surprisingly entertaining considering how low scoring it was for most of it. Not sure if people outside of MN and TX would agree. Rudolph dropping that ball in the end zone was devastating - IMO it was a bigger play than the final one. As much as I hate to see us continue to lose, I honestly have never seen a team lose so many starters at key positions and still be competitive. Says a lot about our coaching, depth, and players buying in.   Will be interesting to see what we can do with our OL without having a 1st rd pick this off season. As others have said, it wouldn't be a bad strategy to use every draft pick we have on the linemen.      
    • Yes. Unlike you I have a job and a life.   I'll just say that whatever it's about you are right because that's the only thing I could ever say that you would possibly agree with me on. I won't get in the way of your libertarian fantasies.
  • Our Sponsors