Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
maros91

Weeds growing through rock bedI

13 posts in this topic

I just completed a landscaping project in my front yard complete with edging, plants, 2 trees, river rock, and an old piece of farm equipment. I placed fabric on the ground before placing my rock and now after 3 weeks there is weeds growing everywhere through the fabric. I want to know whats the most lethal stuff to put down to kill the weeds but not kill my plants. I,ve tried the weed and grass killer in the black and green bottle but didn,t work. Whats the most lethal stuff?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did you put the fabric down over weeds and/or grass when creating the bed? If so they will tend to grow thru the fabric the first year unless sprayed. If you put the fabric down over dirt, then there shouldn't see any weed growth...unless you got a screen mesh for fabric.

If you did put the fabric down over weeds and they are growing thru, then a simple round up spray carefully placed on the weed leaves and not pooled should do the trick with out killing the good plants. Get the round up that says rain proof which has a sticker in it to adhere to the leaves so it wont run off into the soil and harm the good plants.

On a side note, it may be that your river rock is not dense enough where sunlight and air can get to the ground yet to promote growth instead of smuthering it out. It is best to have 3" of rock to keep the sunlight out and that help to prevent future growth.

Kill the existing weeds with a round up spray and then use the preen product to prevent future weeds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are they growing through or on top in the rocks. I just had my yard professionaly installed in june and had the same probelm. The weeds were actually on top. I sprayed them all with roundup. Then applied a nice thick layer of preen everywhere. Each year I will be applying preen in she sping and mid summer. Fabric and rock help controlling weeds. but to be weed free it still takes a little work from my experience. Also did you overlap the seams on the fabric.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Preen works okay, but if you look for a product called "Snapshot" it will last all season with one application.

It can be found at the same location I and others have mentioned before.

Also, as Preen, Snapshot only works as a pre-emergent, not a post emergent.

Spray the weeds that have already emererged, and put down your pre-emergent chemical of choice. It's a granular that can go right over the top of most established plants.

If you're concerned about spraying the roundup, grab a pail, or 5 gallon bucket to put over whatever plants you're looking to keep so you don't risk overspray, if you're not confident in your spraying abilities.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The weeds were growing right through the fabric. During my project I used a sod cutter and took out the top layer of grass/weeds and put my fabric down. I did overlap about 3 inches. I only put down enough rock to just cover the fabric, maybe a little deeper in some spots so I am sure sunlight was still getting through. Long story longer I am pulling up the rock and the fabric (cheapest stuff you can buy I might add) and am going to dig the weeds out and spray with round-up. Then I am going to through in some Preen then a layer of the cheap fabric and then a layer of some better fabric and then add more rock (at least 3"). Maybe this will do the trick. I should have did this in the first place but I guess now I know. I will see if I can take some picks and post them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You don't have to do that much work Biff.

Just pull as much as you can / would like right now, and then spray the rest.

Put some Preen over the top and you're going to be good to go.

There's a good chance that you'll still get some growth of weeds from the ones that have already started to germinate from earlier, but just spray / pull those when you see them.

Add some more rock as your budget allows.

There's a fair amount of landscape beds out there that have ZERO fabric, the weeds are just controlled chemically and manually.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Will the Preen go through the rocks and into the soil?

Yes. Preen, Snapshot, Treflan or other products will work by just spreading or shaking the product right over the top.

It works the essentially the same way as a pre-emergent does for crabgrass, in that it prevents weeds from germinating.

When it rains, or if you have irrigation (not drip line) it will push the product down to soil (or rock level) and start to break the pellet down to form the barrier.

One of the discussions on the lawn / landscape websites is do you put it down before the rock / mulch, or go over the top.

I personally like to go over the top, since if you put it down first, you run the risk of moving it (although unlikely) or you run the risk of introducing dirt (sediments) with your rock, or if you put mulch down, there could be some weeds that grow from the mulch.

If you put the product over the top of everything, then you are preventing weeds from these sediments or from the new mulch that was placed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice. Great info!!! I will quit tearing up the project and just kill the weeds I see with Round-up and pull them and sprinkle the Preen in. Good stuff LwnmwnMan2 and everyone else. You saved me many hours of work and cussing and swearing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I showed this post to my wife as we are having some of the same problems. Her questions were can you use this Preen product in a perennial garden and will it have any effect on getting spreading plants to promote new growth of plants?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Usually" once a plant has rooted, it will not affect the plant. If the plant spreads by root structure, you should be fine.

All of these products will have labels on them, and what plants not to use them on, so just to be safe, I would recommend reading the label, as with any chemical product.

Most of these you can google the product name and find a label, read it at home, so you're not standing in the aisle at the store, trying to squint, hold the bottle at a certain angle, get better lighting, etc., to try to read all the fine small print of plants. laugh

For others that are following this thread, and are thinking "HEY!!! what about gardens???!?!" these products are NOT rated for food stuffs.

I'm not entirely sure, but Preen MIGHT have a food rated product, but the others are not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Could be that others cheated also.   I was relying on memory about the BMW connection and hypothesized that Mercedes would also have been a possibility.   I did say "maybe mercedes".     In any case, VW cheated on emissions for many years with the assent of the highest levels of management.     Apparently making a small diesel that runs ok and doesn't make too much pollution at an acceptable cost is really hard.
    • License what technology, this kind?        https://www.google.com/amp/www.cnbc.com/amp/2017/04/27/after-vws-record-fine-mercedes-benz-parent-daimler-could-be-next.html     "In light of the ongoing governmental information requests, inquiries and investigations, and our own internal investigation, it cannot be ruled out that the authorities might reach the conclusion that Mercedes-Benz diesel vehicles have similar functionalities," Daimler said in its newly released quarterly report. The maker first acknowledged in January that authorities had begun probing its handling of diesel emissions. That was the same month that VW agreed to settle a criminal probe by the U.S. Justice Department, a federal judge this past week approving the payment of a $2.8 billion fine. Almost 40 times the legal limit In the VW case, the mainstream German automaker rigged the software controlling two diesel engines to recognize when a vehicle was undergoing emissions tests and then adjust pollution levels. In real-world situations, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency asserted, those powerplants would produce up to 40 times the legal limit for pollutants like smog-causing oxides of nitrogen. Since the scandal broke in September 2015, regulators in the U.S. and the European Union have begun rechecking the emissions claims made by other manufacturers, including Daimler, General Motors, Fiat Chrysler Automobiles and others. In January of this year, the EPA took aim at FCA, alleging that it may have used its own, rigged software on products like the Ram 1500 EcoDiesel which "appeared to cause the vehicles to perform differently when being tested" than when in use in real-world conditions. That same month, Daimler said that what the EPA was concerned about "apparently includ(ed) functionalities that are common in diesel vehicles, as undisclosed Auxiliary Emission Control Devices (AECD)." While the German parent of both the Mercedes-Benz and Smart brands did not confirm it had broken the law, it laid open the possibility that its own diesel emissions strategy could be in trouble. "If these or other inquiries, investigations, legal actions and/or proceedings result in unfavorable findings, an unfavorable outcome or otherwise develop unfavorably, Daimler could be subject to significant monetary penalties, remediation requirements, vehicle recalls, process improvements and mitigation measures," Daimler stated.
    •   Wow, Del I forgot all about that little discussion you started two years ago.  All the fun folks were in on it, even the LIMITOUT. That's what happens when you have short term memory loss and and pictures bring on new thoughts and emotions.  Let's just call this threat the "What a dang waste and shame!" More of an aftermath threat?  K
    • When we had are seasonal campsite I had lots of squirrels. I used all metal feeders. Come Sept them squirrels went in the freezer and cooked up for the wild game feed!
    • If you have been following the story, the reason VW got in this mess is they didn't want to license technology from BMW (or maybe Mercedes) and chose to develop their own.   When it couldn't be made to work properly, they chose to cheat rather than bite the bullet.    Long discussions of what happened as the story broke    
    • I had one of those.  Mine never quite ran right, although I lived with the quirks for years.  I have a pdf of service manual if you want it.   Mine ran rough intermittently at certain rpm.
    • If they make it better because of stupid government mandates it wouldn't bother me at all.   In fact, the Dodge ram diesel that I used to have had something from Daimler Benz that allowed it to meet the standards without DEF. I would not be surprised if they did something similar with those diesels and if they did I applaud them. The best thing anyone can do with the diesel trucks is delete the emissions and unlock the power and economy that are robbed from them.   
    • pellet gun does the job here  
    • I have to many squirrels, need the feeders with the metal holes.
    • build it and they will come. 
  • Our Sponsors