Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
llee873

Using Suckers in the summer for Muskies?

11 posts in this topic

I was just wondering if anybody has tried using suckers in the warmer summer months for muskies and had any success? Thanks for your responses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Absolutely. Make sure you use a single hook and when your bobber goes down let them run with it. When they stop, wait about 30 seconds and then SLAM the rod home. Good luck.......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are going to do it I wouldn't use a single hook and wait 30 seconds. Pick up some quick strike rigs, and set the hook instantly once you see your bobber go down or feel a strike. If you do choose to run a single hook look into getting some large circle hooks same as catfisherman use( the bigger the better as you have less chance of gut hooking a fish) and don't let them take it for any amount of time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yeah. if you let them sit and eat it. even if you cut the line and the fish swims off fine a lot of the fish have a delayed mortality. there was an article in an old musky hunter about a test they did on captive muskies . not a bioligist by any means just sharing what i read.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

joey, you must be from wisconsin smile

here's a tidbit from the WI DNR

Effects of a Single-hook Live Bait Angling Technique on Muskellunge Survival

Terry L. Margenau

Use of live bait is a popular method to fish muskellunge during fall months. However, muskellunge anglers have expressed concern that certain live bait techniques may cause muskellunge mortality to be unacceptably high. This study monitored the survival of adult muskellunge (31.5 to 42.3 in) for a period up to one year after being angled using a single-hook live bait rig where muskellunge were allowed to swallow the bait prior to hook set. Over a two-year period a total of 40 muskellunge (20 fish/year) were field transferred into a 1-acre lined hatchery pond in early September. After allowing muskellunge several weeks to acclimate to the hatchery pond, angling was initiated using live suckers (approximately 12 in) with a 10/0 single hook attached to the suckers snout and suspended from a bobber. A total of 22 muskellunge were hooked with the single-hook rig. Hooked fish were landed as quickly as possible, inspected for hooking location and injury, and released after cutting the leader. Average time from a strike until hook set averaged 17 minutes. Play-time (hook set to landing) averaged less than one minute, and handling time averaged approximately 5 minutes. Immediate mortality (first 24 h after hooking) of muskellunge was zero. Short-term delayed mortality (24 h until ice formation; approximately 45 d) was 22%. Cumulative mortality (hooking until one year) was 83%. Results from this study have several implications for management agencies and anglers. First, all fish hooked appeared healthy after being caught and released, thus leading an angler to believe that the release was successful. Second, delayed and long-term mortality appeared related to the extent of internal damage suffered from the hook. Finally, while mortality to one year is unacceptable for fisheries that rely upon successful release, not all fish perished. Those fish surviving to one year maintained good relative weight values and appeared externally healthy.

__________________________________________________

you'll notice time from strike to hookset avgs 17 minutes. it stands to reason that using smaller suckers, as you would buy in MN, would cause a fish to swallow it much quicker, thus producing the same result.

i'm not holier than thou, i just like big muskies. not sure about the rest of you guys but it's the predatory thing that gets me with them, why fish for them if you can't watch them come in and eat at your feet?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yeah, good luck keeping the suckers alive. That is if you are using the bigguns'

Put ice in the live well... wink

Please please please please please read above and use a quick strike, NOT a single hook!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Joe's sporting goods has some bucher quick strikes as well that are pretty good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quick Strike Rigs are definetly the way to go.

I noticed you live in Apple Valley, Fleet Farm in Lakeville has Muskie sized QS rigs. Or Infisherman's HSOforum has an article about making your own, they also have articles about using them. Search "quick strike rig" on their HSOforum.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm definitely going to use QS rigs. That's a given! The water temps at the cabin in northern WI have barely hit 70 so I was thinking maybe the sucker idea might work. I will be taking a friend who has never caught a musky yet and just wanted to see what other musky anglers think about using suckers in the summer. Thank you guys for your responses.

Just another quick question. Should I use BIG suckers or maybe medium size? They will be used on a smaller 150+ acre lake or maybe even the Chippewa Flowage. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm trying to figure out where this idea that suckers don't work in the summer comes from, it's not the first time i've heard it...Are there not suckers in the lakes during the rest of the year, is someone stocking them in the fall and they all get eaten until the next year?

winkgrinlaugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hard to find the really big suckers right now and they are harder to keep alive right now. You will be messing around with pike with suckers you can buy from the bait store. I hate live bait, but that's just me. Artificial works better IMO. I'd rather fool them than feed them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Check out the 2017 Obsession Hurcan 366fps and 3.9 lbs!
    •   When someone gets to the personal aspect, whether it's me or someone else, I will challenge them and if they can justify what they have said about an individual --OK -- otherwise show me why, and if it is just their opinion say so. I'll accept that if it's their opinion.   There is nothing generic about an insult, an insult is an insult. What do you consider as a douchebag?
    • Not sure why people get so worked up about being called dummies, poopyheads and sons of bees.  Whatever, its generic insults and this is the internet.   But yeah, there's a line somewhere in the there that separates the real douchebags* from the rest of us.  You know it when you see it.   *Sorry if any douchebags felt personally attacked by being called douchebags.
    • I was addressing it to JigSawJimmy Peatmoss  response : That's an opinion, not anything more , so I let it go.
    • Created/Saved all these jobs, cut gajillions off AF1 costs, etc.  Ok, so how did the that work?  Usually these sort of dealings aren't totally one sided.  At least the carrier deal had a bunch of Pence fingerprints on tax incentives Trump took credit for.   I have doubts that King Cheeto just shows up and blows a bunch of smoke up assses and corporate executives are just like, "Yay!"   Is Trump's Twitter bully pulpit that powerful?  He randomly yells at Boeing and they just fold over for him?  I thought we realized Trump on Twitter is only for the LOLs.
    • Well hope the Trump supporters are having fun, seems those days are numbered. Turns out you can't just yell fake news at real news and make it go away. The Feds are closing in, and at best it seems Trump thinks throwing Manafort to the wolves might get them off his tail. Anywho, lots of news today.   The FBI has information that indicates associates of President Donald Trump communicated with suspected Russian operatives to possibly coordinate the release of information damaging to Hillary Clinton's campaign   McCain: Congress doesn't have 'credibility' to handle Russia probes    Because this happened - House Intelligence chair discloses classified intel in clumsy effort to validate Trump   Also this earlier in the day -  Former campaign manager Paul Manafort secretly worked for a Russian billionaire with a plan to "greatly benefit the Putin Government."     And in completely unrelated news - remember those Carrier jobs you bragged about Trump saving? Yeah, those jobs are gone. Carrier pocketed the tax breaks then screwed the workers anyway. Great negotiation there. http://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/job-cuts-endure-at-indiana-factories-despite-trump-pressure-416511193.html
    •   Who are you addressing this to? I did not make the statement only re-posted it. I also don't find PEATMOSS's comment very humorous as well.   PEATMOSS said: This is still, by far, the funniest thing I have ever read on these threads in a decade.
    •   Anything you post on here from now on has no merit or credibility as far as I'm  concerned.  I wasn't even going to respond to this, but feel what you posted needed to be. If you wish to call my mother a dam, you will, the same as you called another persons mother that. I don't give a rats butt what your political views are, however when you start getting into personal attacks you had better look in a mirror. You don't probably don't know anyone on here personally, yet you attack someone on a personal bases, call there mother a dam and ridicule them because they had a lower portion of a leg amputated due to something they can control, but had no control whether they have the illness and sometime that illness makes you pay a price. BD2 has that illness he can control to a certain extent where he can lead a normal life, however there will be complications and from what I know of him he will accept that. I don't know DB2 personally, I've never met him, I've debated against some thing on this where he and I have had different views, I respect his opinions even though I disagree on many, BUT I SURE AS H--- DON"T ATTACK HIS ANCESTORY OR  ANY TYPE OF DISABILLITY
    • Yea yea all ya auld pharts would  pass out the minute she popped the first button!!
    • Would he get a free hoodie for his efforts?
  • Our Sponsors