Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • Announcements

    • Rick

      How to create an @mention - Click Here   07/16/2015

      You can use the @mention aspect whenever you want someone to be notified about a post or let them know you are talking about them. Type the @ symbol type in a couple "lowercase" letters pause then once the names pop-up either select or keep typing in letters to narrow down the list until you get the @mention name you are looking for. You can play a game so members can see how it works. If you want to practice or If your name has been @mentioned below you should see it in your notifications (upper right) and you then have to @mention one or two members who haven't been mentioned inthe comments section below. Let's see how long we can keep this going. Anyone who duplicates a name that has already been @mentioned loses. This is the first group to be @mentioned to get the ball rolling: @Borch @Scott K @Corey Bechtold @Matt Johnson @mrklean @eyeguy 54 @Finns @IceHawk @MarkB @Cliff Wagenbach @Wayne Ek
Sign in to follow this  
HugoBox

How much do pike relate to muskies

Recommended Posts

If I had a nickle time someone, on a slow day, says, "I can't believe we don't at least catch a pike or a bass" I'd have enough nickels to buy another musky lure.

That said, I'd also have a lot of nickles for the days when it can be frustrating because the pike get going pretty good as you're trying to crack the ski code.

There has been plenty written about both the similarities and differences between pike and musky I'm wondering what keys to their behavior may help you find muskies when all you're seeing are pike.

For example, you see a big musky or get a lazy follow but clearly the fish isn't eating right now. You move to a different later in the morning and all of the sudden start popping pike (or bass for that matter) - could that indicate that a feeding window may be opening and you should head back to the big ski? Or does it mean that reading too mauch into observations made on the water will only slow down my already tired brain??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

make that enough for 2 lures. Like you said with the similarities you would think you would hook into an occassional pike. Like I say on any slow day, if I had the answer we'd be going catching instead of fishing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
could that indicate that a feeding window may be opening and you should head back to the big ski? Or does it mean that reading too mauch into observations made on the water will only slow down my already tired brain??

lol, i love it. i'd say your going in the right direction, just driving the wrong car. muskie and northern and bass eat. they all relate to forage of some type when they feel hungry. and feeding window, feeding shmindow, IMO. i think it's a crock the way it's portrayed smile. a muskie (any fish) will eat the next time according to how big it's last meal was, it's as simple as that. where it eats is according to a book full of factors. sustenance drives it's brain and it will eat when it's hungry and, on occasion, answer when opportunity knocks. could be said of other fish too. except maybe bass and pike. they see? they eat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hammer handles are a harbinger for a Muskie free location no matter how good it looks or was last week, another reason Muskie anglers need to care about the health of our Pike fishery....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to an episode of Joe Bucher, once the pike start feeding, the muskies aren't far behind. That might only be true for Wisconsin though, haha and I suppose the truth of that statement really depends on whether or not you trust Joe Bucher.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hammer handles are a harbinger for a Muskie free location no matter how good it looks or was last week, another reason Muskie anglers need to care about the health of our Pike fishery....

That only makes sense.

If I were a hammer handle and a 50 inch muskie (or a 40 inch northern for that matter) was in the area I wouldn't be.

Much like spearing. When you see the little fish hanging around you don't have to concentrate too much on the hole.

When the little sunnies and perch disappear in a quick hurry... there is something coming.

I think it has less to do with the health of the pike fishery and more to do with the hamerhandles not wanting to be eaten.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

According to an episode of Joe Bucher, once the pike start feeding, the muskies aren't far behind. That might only be true for Wisconsin though, haha and I suppose the truth of that statement really depends on whether or not you trust Joe Bucher.

I'd actually say that this is very true in Wisconsin, but only in certain circumstances. If you are catching hammerhandles that seem to be holding tight to thick weeds chances are there's a bigger fish in the area. However if pike are active over sparse cover or are coming out a long ways from structure you probably won't catch anything bigger.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
could that indicate that a feeding window may be opening and you should head back to the big ski? Or does it mean that reading too mauch into observations made on the water will only slow down my already tired brain??

I'd don't know if you'd call it big, but a couple years ago on tonka I caught a mid 20" pike and a 40" musky on back to back casts. And even if you're thinking about feeding windows, with the way a lof of guys fish these days aren't they more reaction strikes than actually feeding?

Zelmsdawg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have noticed more times than not that when the pike are going nuts, muskie fishing is very tough. I like the days when I never see or catch a pike the best.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think pike are a deter. This year I caught a 42inch ski, along with 25,27,29inch northern within an hr. Yesterday my partner got a northern and next cast i got a muskie. Also, I've had muskies T-bone pike or bass i'm reeling in. As long as im not using a bulldawg I dont mind the pike.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too dont think small pike run too far from a muskie either. Im sure they will hunker down in the weeds or get out of their way when possible but they wont move to the other side of the lake. Example, when ice fishing Ill see pannies on my camera, a pike will cruise through and the pannies disapere, many times they will be back within 20 seconds. They dont go far just hide.

This year on all my 'ski trips if we didnt even catch a pike we also never saw or caught a 'ski. Every trip we saw or caught a 'ski the pike were biting too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  



  • Posts

    • This was probably one of the most frustrating Muzzy seasons I can remember. There are lots of deer around. Cameras and tracks in the snow confirmed that. We just saw very few in the daylight. The properties we hunt do get hit pretty hard with the rifle guys, but usually with some snow/cold they will start to hit the food sources in the afternoons as the season progresses. But not this year. They would wait until about 5:30 before arriving on the food. Oh well we still had lots of fun. I will go out a few times yet with the bow. Still have a doe tag that would love to fill.
    • We saw some good bucks this weekend but couldn't quite seal the deal on any of them...my son smoked his second one with the ML this afternoon after talking me in to going out when we should have been packing to leave for home...(: found a big deadhead this morning too...deer were super spooky but saw plenty...time to pack all the hunting gear away and focus on ice!! 
    • I know, you hear about them everyday in the News burning and terrorizing the good atheist folks of Belle Plaine MN.
    • Are the houses built on an order basis only?   How long did your build take from order to delivery?
    • The one I installed in my previous house was the same way. Like Tom said, be sure to watch the humidity levels. When they get too high you can start to get mold growth. I always watched the windows. When they'd start to get a lot of condensation on them I'd turn it down.   Be sure to check the filter at least once a year. I lived in town and still had to replace the filter every year because of buildup on the filter. When it would get clogged the water would pretty much run straight down to the drain in the bottom. 
    • Looks different to me, or probably just the light and shade difference.
    • I still planned to shoot my ML some, even not going hunting.  Pretty much out of primers and getting low on white hots so I swung into the Baxter FF on my way to Winnie for the weekend. They were completely out of primers and had just gotten restocked that day with propellants.  The counter guy said they went through a ton of ML supplies this year, owing the surge to scopes being allowed.  I bought some Buckhorn to try out and will have to get primers later. Anyone with a last day story to tell?
    • i think those jackknife couches are 72 inches but not positive, will check on that.  The back dinette bed would be almost 8 feet wide. Here are some more pics of the furnace, batteries, and hydraulic system under the couch.  Also the Biffy and closet in the front, the stereo system with Bluetooth, some USB charging ports next to it, cabinet for the satellite receiver with all connections tucked inside.  Pic of the outside 30 amp generator plug in and propane tanks.  Has lights over the tanks and entry door.  You can connect whatever you want to the tv, so yes a water camera would work on that.  Hoping to get on the ice next weekend!!  Good luck to all...
    • Meh, I can protect myself just fine with or without a $1000 rifle. My $100 Hi-Point .45 will make you just as dead as that AR. It's more than likely one of those crazy arse Christians that I need to protect myself from.
  • Our Sponsors