Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
gn83tm

Pike vs. Walleye

26 posts in this topic

I frequent another fishing forum a state or so south of the land of 10,000 and there's a thread going as to what is considered a "trash" fish. Someone stated that in Minnesota, pike are almost considered a less than desireable fish.

For the first 18 years of my life (up until the mid 1980s) I hung out at my uncle's cabin in Ottertail county. We fished for pike a lot and I really don't remember that we targeted eyes that much. College, family, and life came along and I haven't done much fishing, let alone hanging out up north, until the last few years. Now it seems like walleyes are the most sought after fish and northerns have kind of taken a back seat, if not a ride in the trunk.

Am I remembering things differently than they were? Or have things changed a bit in the last couple of decades? Are the walleye stocking efforts improving the fishery so much that now people are going after them whereas they weren't back in the '70s because there weren't that many? I'd appreciate hearing the thoughts of some of you guys who have been around a while and can shed some light on this.

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I remember when growing up that pike were as described trash fish. My father wont eat them because of the Y bone. I must say that my wife and I just finished a pack of pike and a pack of walleye. She likes the eye as it is lighter i prefer the pike as it is richer and a heavier steak. I like them both and we are going north this weekend to trout fish at 9000 ft so i can throw them in the mix now. If i do not catch anything at least it wont be 117 up there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pike are just about my #1 favorite fish to chase in the midwest/canada.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I still fish for the pike more than walleye, and like the taste better. I catch most of my pike fishing for walleye, or using a spinner bait for bass. One thing you can count on is no matter what your fishing for you will probably catch a pike, snoot, slimmer, jack fish, hammer handle, line cutter, and one of the best for that beside the boat battle of the day. Good Luck and keep it simple.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like big pike, but I can't stand the little snake pike. They are slimy and always mess up my lures

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is what makes it fun to get on some lakes that are over populated with the kids when these are biting fast.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lol just like bass vs walleye.

i like both

pike are more fun too catch tho

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only time I don't like pike is when I'm walleye fishing and catch small pike, like under 25 inches.

If I'm going after pike specifically, or going multi-species for whatever I can catch, then I like pike a lot, especially when they start getting up there in size. Hammerhandles drive me nuts after a while but you gotta like the attitude and willingness to bite of pike in general.

I don't eat pike very often but it is excellent fresh (without being frozen). Try mixing in a pike with shore lunch every once in a while, it's good. We just had a metro pike cooked on the grill not long ago and that was good too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've never thought of Pike as trash fish. Even if you've never kept one you have to admit they're a great sporting fish. For a lot of people Walleye are for eating and Pike and Bass are for fighting.

I think Pike get a bad rap because of the Y bones. Walleyes and Bass have Y bones too they're just not as predominant and easier to remove. They're a very good eating fish but many people are just too lazy or don't know how to remove the Y bones so they consider them trash. Well, it's their loss.

I enjoy the flavor of Pike. People are always so quick to compare it to something else and that makes no sense to me. Hey venison doesn't taste like beef but I love them both! It's pretty much the same difference if you think about it. Just because one may taste a little better doesn't make the other one taste bad, they're both good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the input gentlemen. I didn't really think you northerners considered pike to be a trash fish. I like the agressiveness of them also but it's funny because there are guys around here that like fishing for carp because of the fight. Maybe it's an acquired taste, but I'd much rather eat pike than carp. Carp do make good fertilizer though!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heck i live in arizona so any fish to me is a keeper. not much in phoenix to fish unless you like urban lakes with all the homeless folk. plus at 117 who really wants to fish anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At least the humidity is low.....right?!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't keep pike, but I do know many people who do. Walleye all the way for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

no actually it is monsoon season so our humidity is up. The myth of a dry heat is for a couple months in the summer. From June-Aug, it is just nasty, the heat index alone for this weekend is over 110. does not matter 117 is just hot. oh well i will be in the mountains fishing at 9000 ft elevation. only 75 there. so darn it i will miss the hottest day i hope.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I look at Pike as much more of a game fish than Walleyes. May not be as good to eat, but much more fun to catch.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like pike as much as walleye but seem to target walleye more. I think it's the challenge for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I love pike, don't fish for them much, but love them. I know a lot of guys that don't like them at all though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

love catching both love eating both, as long as the bones are out

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have learned the bone structure of the nortons, and one can easily remove the bones from a fillet after it's cooked..the bones are on the upper half of the fillet, and you can pry open the meat at the sweet spot, and usually the Y bones stay on one side of the meat, and they stick out like a comb..Then just grab them and pull them out! The meat is allways sweeter by the bone, and the part of the flish with the Y bones is the best!..All it takes is a little practice, and soon you can give other people the boneless lower half, and enjoy the best part yourself..If I could figure out how to post photo's, I'd show Ya'll..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Catfisher, If you can figure out the photo thing, pleast post it (go to imageshack or some other site, there's a sticky on the photography forum on how to). I always try to remove the bones before cooking, but this is pretty wasteful.

I like to have a fish fry up at our cabin for all my family at least once a year. I get oohs and ahhs if there is walleye in the fray, and sometimes get the boo hoo's if there is pike in there. Now if I get creative and take bottom boneless pike fillets and cut them to look like walleye fillets, I can fool family members into thinking it was the walleye. Hook, line, and sinker they always fall for it. So, really the only problem with pike is the Y-bones. If I could just figure that one out...

Pike are a lot more fun to actually catch. For small eater sized fish, I still prefer walleye. For the big fish, I'd rather catch a monster pike.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

solbes, I've done that pike for walleye switcharoo myself and they usually fall for it. I've also taken some good bass from a nice cold northen lake and told people it was crappie. People get too carried away with certain species of fish. I like variety. Usually I catch and release but do keep a sampling of various species in my freeze. Right now I have king slamon, silver salmon, halibut, ling cod, northern, walleye, perch, crappie, and sunnies. Love them all. Hmmm, I think I'll go fire up the grill....tasty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Someone tried to help me once using photo bucket or something///I tried, but I am a caveman at the cornputer...Cut and paste? drag icon? no clue...I post photos with no problem on other sites, but this forum don't seem to be as easy...Maybe it could be made more witnit friendly?..Like a thing you can hit that goes right to browse like other sites??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Used to do that too, works well. Learned how to do that growing up. Now I have the Y bone thing down pretty good, with very little waste.

One thing that will taint a northern fillet is letting it touch any slime, it doesn't come off (smell, taste) and probably has scared away many from trying again...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't fillet/keep the fish I target so I'm with Pike all the way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can put your pike in a water/vinegar mixture to cut the slime, then wipe them dry before filleting them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • nice story, fishing has a way of easing the pains we have. even when we hurt like crazy when done for the day we are looking forward to the next outing.
    • way to go, guys yep, the toms not about to give up even though its close to closing time have seen several strutters the past couple weeks and heard gobbles yesterday while fishing
    • great job. makes it 5 for 5 for team 5 congrats on a nice tom, 57 and that willl give our team score a boost
    • One More Cast      Photo by:  Roger Abraham   If any of you out there are regular readers of my tales, you have followed my recent struggles with back and knees.  I can’t put a name to this drive I have to be on the stream as of late.  It borders on obsession. I guess in my mind if I am healthy enough to fish the world is right with me and I am not getting old and feeble.      Today I was a witness to that I am not the only one.  Lots of anglers and hunters live to go out into the outdoors. .  It is what drives them.  It makes them feel alive.  It is their passion.  I told my fishing buddy Abe today my thoughts.  I told him how I was feeling a little old.  I guess my 60th birthday coming up next month makes me feel mortal.  Abe laughed and said I was a young buck compared to him.  Abe turns 76 this year.     Abe told me tales about catching big trout in tiny streams in Wisconsin and out west.  The twinkle in his eye when he reminisced I had seen before in many trout anglers.      We fished a stretch for 2 hours.  I sat down and rested often.  Abe kept on fishing. He got hung up in a box elder branch and lost a lure.  Abe told me box elders trees were his nemesis when he fished.   He asked me which tree was my kryptonite.  I told him, "ones with branches."  We both had a chuckle and continued fishing.   I thought to myself this guy is really driven.  I hope I am like him at 76.     We got to the vehicle and Abe wanted to continue fishing.  Abe’s waders sprang a leak earlier and he fell in the water a couple times.  He was quite wet.  He wanted to change in to dry clothes before we continue.  Abe peeled off his wet shirt and there were two things stuck to his chest.  He could tell by my questioning look he needed to tell me what was up.     Abe told me he had been having heart problems lately and he was supposed to be wearing a heart monitor.  He left it in the car because he was afraid of getting the electronics wet.  Here I have been whining about being old and the guy I was fishing with left his heart monitor in his vehicle.      Abe reassured me that he was in no danger and he could continue fishing.  I started brainstorming on a place to fish where it was not so hard walking.  Now that I knew he was not as healthy as he looked I wanted an easy place to fish.  I knew the place and it was upstream 5 miles.     We arrived at the well manicured field.  It looked like a golf green.  I picked the area because the farmer kept sheep and goats on the land and the weeds and brush were gone because of the goats.  We walked and fished.     Abe told tales of the old days and of fish lost and landed.  I walked a little forward to fish and looked back to check up on Abe.  What I saw when I looked back scared me and I immediately asked Abe if he was ok.  Abe was laying flat on the ground face down.  I thought the worst and he could tell by my face.  He told me to calm down.  His back was acting up and he needed to straight it out and that was the best way to do it.   We fished a little bit more and he took a photo of me.  He liked the lighting. He told me it captured the essence of trout fishing.  He did not have a camera.  I let him use mine.  He was not camera savvy and needed an impromptu lesson on how to use it.   We drove to his car and we talked about our love of the outdoors. We shook hands and headed our separate ways and promised to fish again soon.  As I drove home I smiled and thought about how I am going to be when I am 76.  I hope I am like Abe and my eyes still twinkle when I talk of chasing trout and I am still driven to make one more cast.
    • The past week has had me having multiple close calls and missing a brute at 45 yards.  Tonight I talked my dad to give it another try and there were birds in the field when we got there.  Birds ended up leaving as we tried to sneak in.  A short 20 minutes later they were back and we watched and worked the big group of toms and hens for more than 2 hours before we got one to commit.  Dad shot him with his 20 gauge at 48 yards,(this thing shoots an awesome pattern).  The 3 year old was down and only flopped a few times.   Nice 1+ inch spurs, 10" beard and heavy.  A good evening for sure!
    • Sorry to disappoint guys, but this tom was not my first bird of the season. Apparently that's part of the rules. The score won't count towards the team. I don't have any measurements for the jake I shot so we will have a zero from me.    At least my freezer is full. 
    • Way to  go 1957 !! Congrats!!
    • sugar is not a drug. 
    • Another good day today out on Superior ,,,, Had my first double and triple in the new rig today ,,, the day didnt start out with perfect weather but the fishing more then made up for it ,,, The mud  covers a lot of water but fishing the tea  colored water and edges of the mud paid off ,,, the cohos grew 5 inches  from eating this years smelt,,,, had some go 23 inches today 
  • Our Sponsors