Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
andy nelson

Gotta have Tonka lures

13 posts in this topic

Hey guys just getting into Musky fishing, went out with a buddy a couple times and now I need to get some of my own stuff. Tonka is mostly where I fish, what are some good lures and colors that work here for you? Thanks and as always any tips help too!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i'm not a tonka regular but there's not much i wouldn't throw there at some point during the season.

last night i jumped in DeBos boat so only brought the good baits and had a suick, topwater, 2 bulldawgs, big blade, small blade, and a phantom. i could make it through the season out there with those i think. probably want to add a rad dog or two and a few cranks to that.

as with any milfoil lake, any point, turn, hole, gap, hump, bump, slot, edge, channel, cup, spine, saddle, island, drop, current area or flat could hold fish. don't forget about the inside edge too, the possibilities are endless so cover water and mark fish you see, they are there for a reason.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's my A list:

Eagle Tails Mag: Chart/chart and brass/brown

M&G spinnerbait: yellow/black

Mag Stomper: Dark color and bright color

Lowrider: dark and bright

Cowgirl: Chart/chart black, nickle/ blue silver

Muskie Treat: Tonka Dream, Crisco

10" Suick: brown/yellow

That will get you through most any condition out there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i'm not a tonka junkie but i know a couple. black bucktails are both their mantra's and those two never met. only other thing i know about tonka that might be helpfull is it's got one name but is really multiple lakes with different water clarity, oxygen levels and lake beds. each "bay" has it's own quirks. so lure color, action and even size can make a big difference. good luck. wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think in the minnesota musky map book, one of the guides interviewed about tonka said he would never leave the dock without a phanthom or jackpot.

That being said, I've had success on tonka with all the main bait categories: hair, top, jerk/glide, plastic and crank.

I think its more important having a lure that your confident in that works well at your given depth/conditions which i think is mostly 12-15 feet weed edge. I know this is specific which you might be hoping for but everything has its place and time. Color might be more important than bait style but I haven't fished the lake lately so can't help there

Zelmsdawg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

any aerodynamic cylinder shaped bait that you can bounce off jet skis and cruisers,,,dont forget "lead em"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Marc, I HATE dawgs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I run a Mag Treat if I want big rubber. Dawgs either have poor hooking % or they totally kill themselves with the thing. Dawgs don't produce for me. I call them my "black cloud" baits. I can fish them for a week straight and never see anything on them, then switch and catch one. I've thrown dawgs for a few hours this year and haven't seen anything. I've thrown Mag Treats for about and hour and seen 5.

I need to amend my line-up to include a Weagle. MUCH better then a jackpot!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Man, how did I forget about the nickle/bluesilver cowgirl. That was my #1 producer the year CG's came out. I need to dig that sucker out.

Tough to beat a Mag Treat in the waves on any lake....that's a secret smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've got some new Mag Treats that are ready for clear coat right now. This batch is the new 3 hook design.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
each "bay" has it's own quirks. so lure color, action and even size can make a big difference

i'm stuck home building lures today and a little bored baby sitting the coating so i have some time to clarify. smile

color can make a difference because of the secchi disk reading. this is the depth a special disk, called a secchi,lol, can be seen by the human eye. the darker the water the brighter, in general, you'd want your lure so it's more visible.

action is important to better match the forage base dominating that area. darker shallower areas won't have ciscoes, as an example, and would have perch, bullhead or pannies and suckers and other minnows like gold shiners and the like. (my rule is if there is bullhead (cats in rivers), there is suckers). a slower, looser action would be more appropriate than a fast, darting, tight erratic action like ciscoes swim. and vise versa, unless you know there is other forage around in the clearer deeper areas.

size can be important for visibility, matching forage size dominating the area, profile match, and as mentioned above, matching the action.

as long as i'm at it i may as well clarify ''lake beds'', tecnicly known as ''lake basins''. they are really different lakes it's just they are not seperated by land but transition while still covered by water. these transition areas are great fishing areas where one type bottom gives way to another, rock to muck, sand to rock and so on. or depths change dramaticly, more than 4 feet, along with bottom types are best. also one of the basins edge may be weedy and the other is not. great spot on a spot.

i heard this awhile back... there's areas that are cleared there through lilly pad fields so people can get their boat out from home. i guess early and late in the day if a guy casts close to shore from outside these fields and reels back to the boat, or from shore i spose, something good usually happens. whistle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Lol at 3 I think I got a little time
    •   Please try and get her to know the difference as soon as you can!  Just saying.
    • You cant be serious, can you?  I think you got that backwards Dave, much like waiting until you become diagnosed  before you open your eyes to bad habits.   Hindsight is always 20/20, guys like you are the reason i take the measures i do now. Im not ripping on you for not knowing because its easy to become unaware of the damage your actually doing to yourself. Learning from others mishaps sticks a lot more than reading about some new trend.
    • Unfortunate your taxidermist could not do all three in a  nice natural  of setting because my guess is it was a female and her two kits. That's just judging from the pictures of course. Would have been a nice family photo, so to speak.
    • Thanks Big Dave. I looked through this stuff and really think a turkey hunt would be something different.  That Mexican bird would be a cool deal.   We will see, I have time!
    •       Because $$$$$$$$$....   You know, free speech and all that..
    • Why not get rid of the cozy relationship that the hospitals,insurance companies, medical device and drug suppliers have and open the market up to competition.    Prime example. You have sleep apnea. Go to the clinic and get a mandated sleep study in their room which costs about $4k for the night.  In an open market private companies could do this for a fraction of the price.   Once you test positive they give you a prescription to buy a machine at their facility and the cost ranges from $1600 to $3600.   You can buy the exact product online for $400-700. But the clinics and doctors don't want you buying there for obvious reasons.    Just one example buy this is what I would like to see changed.  
    • The Rum River is fun anywhere from St. Francis to Anoka. Probably fun north of there to, but I've never done it. It's been quite a few years since I've been on it, but was all no-wake and assume it still is so you don't have to worry much about big boats. 
    •     Why not pass a law that says politicians can't rake in more than 10 percent of the campaign costs of their highest third party competitor?....       wording        
  • Our Sponsors