Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
WyoChris

Stunted fish

12 posts in this topic

This may seem like a dumb question to some of you.... but what does "a stunted fish population" mean? I've heard this a lot but not exactly sure what it means?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

im not an expert but what i think of is typically a stunted sunfish population. which i also think of as a lake that has a very high population of sunnies, which in turn results in the lack of food for the high population. this causes them to either die off, or not consume a substantial amount of food to grow. so in short, very high population causes little fish...

im no expert but thats what i think of it as.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you're on the right track. a body of water that isnt capable of producing larger fish,

too many=lack of forage=slow growing/smaller fish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks that cleared it up

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Stunted" populations can also occur in places where angler harvest is high. If anglers keep all fish above 7" the population will be driven to maturity at an earlier stage and smaller size. This leads to lower growth rates since energy that would go toward growth is now going to reproduction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

mn_bowhunter, Interesting theory! What if the angler harvest is low or 'non-existant'? I'd always been told that if the predator populations are high, the panfish will be large, but few. If the predator populations are low, the panfish will be small, but plentiful (stunted). It goes back to what Burnham and crothmeier stated and as a former keeper of the waters (aquariums), I agree, The fish will grow to the size that their habitat/surroundings will allow. If you put a lone sunnie into a 10 gallon aquarium, he'll only grow so big. Put his brother into a 50 gallon aquarium right beside him, he'll grow to 4-5X the size of his brother. Given the right conditions, an 'aquarist' could potentially grow a MONSTER Sunfish, given the right conditions and a healthy fish from the start. There's a challenge for the Aquarists on FM!! Phred52

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Stunted" populations can also occur in places where angler harvest is high. If anglers keep all fish above 7" the population will be driven to maturity at an earlier stage and smaller size. This leads to lower growth rates since energy that would go toward growth is now going to reproduction.

Also, if you are keeping all the +7" fish, you are effectively eliminating the genetic pool of fish capable of reaching +7". Thus, you are left with a gene pool capable of only growing 6.9" fish and smaller.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To Phred52, predators can help to control sunfish populations and also increase size structure to a degree. Largemouth bass are what is found to be most effective for pond management. This is not a rule by any means and there are too many variables to go into. Some of the largest bluegills produced have been in ponds managed for large gills so yeah, it's basically a 10-20 acre aquarium.

To raider4ever, you would not necessarily eliminate the genetic pool. Most of the size structure balance has to do with competition between fish of the same species. I'll use bluegills as an example again as there has been a ton of research on them. The "bulls" or large males that guard nests get eggs in there nests. The largest males are in the center of the colony, and they recieve the most eggs. Smaller males may try to sneak in and fertilize eggs or mimic females to also fertilize eggs. As these large males are eliminated smaller males can take their place on nests and get eggs from females. This drives the fish to mature at a smaller size/younger age. The genetics are essentially the same, they are just responding to a lower number of breeders. When larger males return growth rates increase and it is basically back to normal. You should do a google or youtube search for cuckholdry and sneakers for bluegills. You can see the small males sneak in, its pretty cool.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

MN Bow,

I've heard from my friends at the DNR that the stunted gills are a little different genetically, almost a subspecies. I've been told that there was a study done on pike as well that shows the same thing.

That makes sense after talking to someone in the DNR. They took some scale samples of pike on Tonka and the growth rates were all over the board. Sex didn't seem to matter nor did the section of the lake the samples were taken from.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Food the the source of growth. Too may fish for the food + lack of space to grow=small fish. Pounds of fish per acre of water. Upper red, is a good example. Competiton for food.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wasn't trying to say that gentics couldn't be different for stunted fish. I know that they can be different genetically. I meant that for the short term, like 5-6 generations you could get them to go back to normal. This is what I've read in many journal articles about bluegills.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been thinking on the genetic size/relationship issues a lot. In the TC Metro, we seem to only have small sunfish in all types of lake and even the rivers. I am convinced that generations of harvest have altered the gene pool. I would like the DNR to investigate the benefits of breeding a population of genetically superior gills. Maybe reclaim a lake and introduce large gills from outside our metro, protect that lake from fishing, and use these gills to stock lakes that have the right characteristics for promoting good growth. They may want to do some trapping/netting to remove inferior gills first, and drop these fish in drainages and winterkill lakes for kids fishing opportunities. I'd love to be able to give my daughter one good sunfish experience a year without driving an hour plus.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Keep voting democrat, Minnesota.....
    • Human nature. Especially when one is emotionally invested in elections.   I haven't commented too much on this Russian stuff. Could be true. Could be all just many upset about the election results.    At the very least, Trump may be just getting a taste of his own medicine(the claim he had evidence BHO was not a citizen, the National Enquirer stories about Cruz)
    • Did "YOU" and the "WIFE" enjoy growing up in the cities?  Me personally I grew up in a farm town in southern MN and have lived in Shakopee for the past 25 years.  I absolutely cannot stand living in the cities.  Everything is amped up 500%.  Driving is nuts. Traffic is nuts.  Ever ride your bike down Minnehaha falls on the weekend?  Kids sports is outrageous.  In general if you want to fish, sled, atv, your driving up north...with everyone else on a Friday night.  Unless you get lucky as heck most neighbors are either phony as heck or you never see them.  Seems as though most folks never leave the house.  Unless you have lots of space/land you will have neighborhoods doing fireworks whenever, dogs barking, snowblowing at 10:00PM etc...  Kids rarely go out and play in the cities.  I've discovered that they are constantly being shuttled to event after event, so the notion that the kids on the street will play together is few and far between.  The schools, at least in Shakopee have been great from an educational standpoint!  However because they shift classes and actual schools every few years, my girls have never had the same classmates.  In the town I grew up in we only had 120 kids in the class, so you pretty much knew every kid.  Bussing can be quite limited when your kid wants to do afterschool activities and sports.  Talk about income inequality...in my hometown the farmer was generally the "rich guy" but you never really knew it.  In the cities you definitely know who the rich folks are and boy does it bring out the competition in folks.  And I'm not talking CEO's and big wigs, I'm talking 2 professionals pulling down 6 figures each.    That's the other thing most people skim over when talking about the greatness of the metro.  Sure if you can afford $125 tickets for the wild game, or $85 tickets for a play, or "shopping" as your activity it IS a great place.  But if your not willing to pony up the money for those events it can be a little boring.  That's why I enjoy Shakopee in that I can head down to the river and take a nice long walk in peace and quiet.  Especially in the winter!   Maybe because I'm getting older and older but this notion that life is all about money, money, money seems less and less important.  Granted I understand you have to make a living and provide for your family, which is why I deal with it, but ultimately you have decide what your family wants out of life.  That is why I am encouraging my kids to seek a life away from the big metro area.  Especially since they enjoy being outside so much.  Full disclose we bought a small cabin last year as our way to "deal with it".  Now I have a place to go to get away AND in 6 years when my youngest graduates high school I will be out of here...  Good luck!!!!
    • True, but we have liberal corporate run media and the fact you are seemingly blind to that fact shows your bias.     
    • my old house was a 6.5 x 12' (No V front) with an outside 2x4' in front for bathroom.   I really didn't notice any difference in towing it.  I know a guy who had his house built with about 2' wide V in front which opens the entire area up quite a bit and he wishes now he would have went 3' wide.  And this still gives you plenty of space on the V to put your LP tanks.     Wish I would have done that on my new 8x16'.   The little gas the V front may save you, to me is not worth the value of that extra space.    
    • I thought there was no point?
    • The US doesn't have state controlled media at all. Well, didn't have. Now we have Bannon and Breitbart in the White House, and of course at Trump's press conference there was only a single reserved seat: front and center for Breitbart.   As far as psychological manipulation: you are subjected to it daily, but usually for commercial purposes. You can easily go the whole day without seeing anything politics related, but good look avoiding advertising for a day.
    • Worst buy I ever bought. I sold it the next week. I like 13 products but not this line of products
  • Our Sponsors