Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Bottle Fish

Is a farmer liable....

21 posts in this topic

My Dad lives across from a farmers field and with the straight line gusty wind, corn husks from the farmers field blew into his and all of his neighbors lawns. This was the first time this has ever happened because this is the first time the farmer didn't plow his field like he normally does.

Does a farmer have any obligation or liability to help with cleanup of the mess? This is the third time in two weeks we are all mowing, bagging, blowing, raking this [PoorWordUsage] up and off our lawns. madmadmadmad This is no easy job either, it is like snowdrifts some of which are 2-3 feet high made of only corn husks.

I tell you one thing if it were my lawn I guarantee at least a couple of the loads we be dumped on the guys driveway in the middle of the night just to say thanks for helping with the cleanup. grin

Not like it matters but these are all lake shore properties with already more than enough work to be done to maintain. I should also mention 90% of them are retired and elderly including my Dad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Legally, I would say no. As a matter of goodwill between neighbors, I would say yes.

Not really sure what you can do about it, if mother nature is causing the problem. Have you talked to them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my guess would be he is not since they are not on his property any more. You going over and pointing it out is reasonable and hope that he is able to lend a hand or something.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes on a couple of occasions and all he said is sorry. Sorry doesn't clean it up or solve anything.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well if you wanna start something then do as you said, bag them up and dump them in his driveway LOL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe call the Sheriff and see what he says? Maybe you can get him to have a talk with the culprit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If your neighbor doesn't bag his leaves and the wind blows them into your yard, do you expect to have him come and rake it for you? The farmer cant help which way the wind blows. If it blows from his field into someones yard, tuff hop.

Trust me, he has bigger things to worry about than corn leave blowing off the field and into someones yard. Like the topsoil blowing off with them. For all we know they were left on purpose to give back to the soil what they took out.

I am sorry your family and the rest of the neighborhood have to clean the yard, but I am guessing the farm field was there when they built/moved in. It happens, move on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This happens to me quite a bit too. I have a farm south of me and I live on the edge of town. Several times during the fall it would blow into my yard then accumulate on the north side of my house....

It didnt bother me much at all. I figured it is what happens living that close to a field.

I didnt do anything with it and it blew off to someone elses place or rotted during the winter.

I havent had a problem with it in the spring time yet but I guess I would just put the bag on my mower when I mow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with NG, not much you can do or should do. He can't control the wind and the corn was most likely left there on purpose. Does it suck to clean up? Yes. Should you start a Neighbor War over this? I sure wouldn't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will agree with Neighbor_guy. As I understand it, this would be considered an act of God since it is the result of the unusually strong winds.

You are not the only ones cleaning up the corn stalks. I saw many farmers in their own yards yesterday cleaning up the same thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All I would like to see happen is the guy at the very least help in anyway possible to clean it up. I don't want to start something over a wind issue either, but at least offer to help.

I suggested to call the Jail and see if maybe the residents there might want to help out. I know if I were in there I would love to get out even if it is for cleanup purposes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you're out of luck on this one. The weather probably didn't allow him to plow the field. His only other option is to burn the field off then you would have dirt and smoke to blame him for. Mother nature should get the blame for this one. If you want help from him let him get his planting done once a crop is planted and growing the trash blowing will stop. Good luck I hope your problem ends soon and I'm sure it will.

As for CJH's advice I think the sheriff might have more important things to do than get in the middle of the corn husk fued. It would be reasonable to ask the farmer for a truck to haul the corn husks and a good location to dump them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On a windy day in the winter when you neighbors snow blows into your driveway do you call him up and tell him to shovel his snow out of your driveway??? NO It sucks but you cant do anything about it and if I was the farmer I would just say I was sorry too!!! Thats mother nature for you!! I would assume your leaves and stuff like that blow on to his property and he doesnt call you up?? I think your making this a big deal and it really isnt. Look at it this way: Its good exercise!!! If I lived closer I would help you out for the a few hours!! Good luck!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you lived next to a wooded lot and the leaves blow off into your yard in the fall, would you call the owner of the lot and ask him to remove the leaves? I think not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It sounds like you're getting riled up over nothing.

I don't rake my leaves that blow into the neighbors yard the same way he doesn't rake his leaves that blow into my yard.

I think I raked 3-4 times this spring beucase my neighbors didn't rake the leaves in their yard which allowed them to blow into my yard. But I wasn't going to start a fued over it and I certainly wasn't going to call the police over the matter. And I'd guess that the jail wouldn't offer up an inmates to help clean the mess either. The officers that would be required to be their watching them probably have better things to be doing.

Good luck with the mess. Personally I'd just sit back and wait for the wind to shift. Sooner or later it always does.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This happens to me all the time as I live on the edge of town next to as huge field. I moved here after the farmer was already farming so I guess I just clean it up.

No different the the neighbors leaves or the dandelions that blow in my yard as the one neighbor does not spray his yard.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This happens to me all the time as I live on the edge of town next to as huge field. I moved here after the farmer was already farming

smile You hit the nail on the head Harvey! I kinda get a kick out of it when people move into farm country, or hunting country, or lake country... and then complain about the smell, or the early morning shotgun blasts, or the dirty trucks in driveways... the list goes on.

People want that "country lifestyle" but then complain about the very same thing that lured them out there, ha!

This isn't aimed at the original poster, just that you see it a lot. And I am a city boy by birthplace, but certainly don't want to bring the city and manicured lawns to the country. Heck, I love it when I can hear the faint gunshots, when the wind is right, during duck season smile

It would stink to have to clean up like that, but that's part of it, just like people who live on rivers need to deal with flooding. Just my two cents, though, and its not worth much wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All I would like to see happen is the guy at the very least help in anyway possible to clean it up. I don't want to start something over a wind issue either, but at least offer to help.

I suggested to call the Jail and see if maybe the residents there might want to help out. I know if I were in there I would love to get out even if it is for cleanup purposes.

The sentence to serve program only does community service work or work for non-profit organizations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if if if if if .

if a tree falls in the woods and noone is around to hear it does it really make a sound? grin

i live in town (a very small town) IN IN town, not on the edge, and i have corn husks on my lawn. Just be thankful its not someones roof, or car that blew over in the hurricane force winds. It would have been nice though if he'd offered to lend a hand, or if you bagged it he'll thrown them on his burn pile or something.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wait til the wind blows in a different direction- they will disappear. I have same kind of problem- I don't have a single tree on my yard, but every year I have millions of leaves. Gets old. After awhile, they blow away

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The wife and I went on Sunday also. Like Rundrave, a lot of the lodge booths didn't really appeal to me but we talked to quite a few dog people there, maybe learned a few things. Funny how two people that would have nothing in common can talk like old friends for 20 minutes about a dog.Realized that a lot of the game farms are WAY more expensive than the one I'm a member at.  Over all I would say it was worth it.
    •     I think we would be better served by not being suspicious of religions themselves, but by being suspicious of rulers and oppressors who use religion as a tool to serve their purposes.     How Gandhi put it:   I had practiced Hinduism from early childhood. My nurse had taught me to invoke Rama when I feared evil spirits. Later on, I had come in contact with Christians, Muslims and others, and after making a fair study of other religions, had stuck to Hinduism. I am as firm in my faith today as in my early childhood. I believe god would make me an instrument of saving the religion that I love, cherish and practice. In any case, one has to have constant practice and acquaintance with the fundamentals of religion before being qualified for becoming god's instrument. It has been whispered that by being so much with Musalman friends I make myself unfit to know the Hindu mind. The Hindu mind is myself. Surely I do not need to live amidst Hindus to know the Hindu mind when every fiber of my being is Hindu. My Hinduism must be a very poor thing if it cannot flourish under influences of the most adverse. I know instinctively what is necessary for Hinduism. As my instinct is wholly Hindu, I know that what I am about to say will be acceptable to the vast mass of the Hindus. My Hinduism is not sectarian. It includes all that I know to be best in Islam,Christianity, Buddhism and Zoroastrianism. I approach politics, as everything else, in a religious spirit. Truth is my religion and ahimsa is the only way of its realization. I have rejected once and for all the doctrine of the sword. My position is and has been clear. I am proud of being a Hindu, but I have never gone to anybody as a Hindu to secure Hindu-Muslim unity. My Hinduism demands no pacts. I am no politician in the accepted sense. It is because I am sanatani (orthodox) Hindu that I claim to be a Christian, a Buddhist and a Muslim. Some Muslim friends also feel that I have no right to read Arabic verses from the Koran, but such (people) do not know that true religion transcends language and scripture. I do not see any reason why I should not read the Kalma, why I should not praise Allah and why I should not acclaim Muhammad as his prophet. I believe in all the great prophets and saints of every religion. I shall continue to ask god to give me strength not to be angry with my accusers, but to be prepared even to die at their hands without wishing them ill. I claim that Hinduism is all-inclusive and I am sure that if I live up to my convictions, I shall have served not only Hinduism but Islam also. There is mention of terrible punishments in the Bhagavatam, the Manu Smriti and the Vedas. Yet the central teaching of the Hindu religion is that mercy of kindness is the essence of all religion. I want you to bear in mind what Tulsidas has said: "Good and bad, all men are the creation of god. The man of god picks up the good and discards the bad like the proverbial swan which is able to drink the milk and leave behind water, when a mixture of water and milk is placed before it." I am proud to belong to that Hinduism which is all inclusive and which stands for tolerance. Aryan scholars swore by what they called the Vedic religion and Hindustan is otherwise known as 'Aryavarta.' I have no such aspiration. The Hindustan of my conception is all-sufficing for me. It certainly includes the Vedas, but it includes also much more. I can detect no inconsistency in declaring that I can, without in any way whatsoever impairing the dignity of Hinduism, pay equal homage to the best of Islam, Christianity, Zoroastrianism and Judaism. Such Hinduism will live as long as the sun shines. Tulsidas has summed it up in one doha (couplet): "The root of religion is embedded in mercy, whereas egotism is rooted in love of the body." Tulsi says that mercy should never be abandoned, even though the body perishes. Hinduism is not an exclusive religion. In it there is room for the worship of all prophets in the world. It is not a missionary religion in the ordinary sense of the term. It has no doubt absorbed many tribes in its fold, but this absorption has been an evolutionary, imperceptible character. Hinduism tells everyone to worship god according to his own faith or dharma and so it lives at peace with all religions. Though I call myself a sanatani Hindu, I am proud of the fact that the late Imam Saheb of South Africa accompanied me to India on his return and died in the Sabarmati ashram. His daughter and son-in-law are still at Sabarmati. Am I to throw them overboard? My Hinduism teaches me to respect all religions. In this lies the secret of Rama Raj. The die is cast for me. The common factor of all religions is non-violence. Some inculcate more of it than others; all agree that you can never have too much of it. We must be sure, however, that it is non-violence and not a cloak for cowardice. Hinduism with its message of ahimsa is to me the most glorious religion in the world -- as my wife to me is the most beautiful woman in the world -- but others may feel the same about their own religion. Religion is outraged when an outrage is perpetrated in its name. Almost all the riots in the unhappy land take place in the name of religion, though they might have a political motive behind them. There is no room for goondaismin any religion worth the name, be it Islam, Hinduism or any other. If religion dies, then India dies. Today, the Hindus and the Muslims are clinging to the husk of religion. They have gone mad. But I hope that all this is froth, that all this scum has come to the surface, as happens when the waters of two rivers meet. Everything appears muddy on top and underneath is crystal clear and calm. The scum goes to the sea of itself, and the rivers mingle and flow clear and pure.          
    •   thanks all for the replies - how does this Aqua Vu HD 700i display show up outside?  So from the replies I'm sure I narrowed my search down for either the Marcum VS825SD or Aqua Vu HD 700i.  Not just have to see if I can find some year end ice specials.
    • Add some Liptons Beefy Onion soup mix to your burger. Adds a great taste.
    •     Must be Milwaukee or Ryobi because DeWalt already has 6amh batteries and they do make car chargers as well.
    • "They" As in Milwaukee?
    • During the past century we were also concerned with Germany, Japan, Korea and Vietnam. You blaming them too?
    • The MN DNR Eagle Cam pair already has three eggs and is over half way done incubating them. http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/features/webcams/eaglecam/index.html
    • Google;   Sayyid Qutb  and you can then read and decide on your own where and how todays Islamic Fundamentalists originated. 
    • Also check out discount ramps dot com
  • Our Sponsors