Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
panthrcat

question about filters

15 posts in this topic

hello again, Sue here grin

I have 3 lenses I use in my arsenel of "tools" for my picture taking,,

- one of which is a 50mm (with a 58mm filter size)

- one is my 28-135mm (with a 72mm filter size)

- and my 100-400mm (with a 77mm filter size)

my question is this:

I am buying a ND filter, and a polorizer filter (probably in BC now as it's too late to order online) for my trip. (wweeeeeeeeeeeeee I'm going on a trip!! grin)

ok I've settled down again,,

I shoot lots (or try to) of wildlife with my 100-400 lens, but also know I'll be shooting a ton of landscape shots (where these 2 new filters will come in handy)

I am thinking that I should get the filters to fit the 28-135mm lens due to it being the most used for landscapes,, am I right on that?

I guess I'm looking for some advice on which size to buy the filters is all. sorry it's so wordy. blush

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd buy the 77mm. For landscape photographs, which should be shot from a tripod, you've got enough hands free so you can handhold a larger filter over the smaller lenses, but can't do it the other way around. You should also be able to buy add-on filter holders that will mount to your smaller lenses and accept the larger filters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Steve, you really think that's what I should do?

I can buy a holder for the filters then, that will fit onto my other lenses? that's common is it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sue, it just depends on your shooting style. All my landscape work is tripod-oriented, so it's easy to hold a 77mm filter over the end of a smaller lens. I've done it myself often, and seen it done by others many times with excellent results.

However, if the 28-135 is your bread-and-butter landscape lens and the only one you're likely to need those filters for, it may make more sense to buy for that lens alone.

For me, the ability to have one set of two filters that I can use on three lenses outweighs the potential hassle of using them on lenses they are not meant for. But that's just for me. Others have different feelings, and should think it through and do what they think is best for them and for their own needs. smilesmile

This is one of those cases where when I say: "I'd do . . . " it just means that that's what I'd do, not that it's what I necessarily think you or someone else should do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

yes I understand Steve.,, thank you again for your speedy reply, you got me to thinking now,,

your probably right about getting the larger size, it just makes sense to use for all, instead of being confined to one lens,, I just didn't think it was common practice to do that.. way back when I had my pentax EI2000 I had a holder for filters..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sue, I haven't used the holders myself but have seen them. If you opt for that route, definitely check from the seller if there are holders available for the filters you'd like to buy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oops another question:

now if I go with a holder or hand held,, I wouldn't need to buy a "circular" one,, right? that could be done manually either by hand or with a holder

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sue, I'm not understanding your question. confused

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sorry Steve,, ok my understanding is a circular polorizer filter, is attached to a lens, and has the capability to move when you touch it to enhance the scene,, now if I am going to go with a holder (of sorts,, either hand held or an actual holder) then I can make that adjustment by moving the filter?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Handheld it's easy to make that adjustment. With a filter holder I guess it would depend on the holder, but you can always take it out of the holder, adjust it, and put it back in.

I'm sorry I don't know more about specific filter holders and systems. Those holders are a type of gear I haven't fooled with much for many years. I know there are several good ones out there. Some are more generic, but there also are some systems where you have to buy the same brand filter and holder.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Really no reason to hand hold a filter. Buy the 77mm filter and buy a step down ring to 72mm (about $10). Problem solved for those two lenses. I don't recall but I am guessing you can also buy a step down ring to 58 from 72, or just add two together to get down to 58mm. Either way very easy cheap solution.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sue,if you're referring to a "circular" polarizer, then that's a different subject. There are circular and linear, and you will need a circular for your type of camera. All "round" polarizers, as far as I know, have a separate ring to adjust to make you scene look different.

Just wasn't sure if you were referring to a "circular" or a "round" because in this case they mean different things.

Good Luck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ah a step down ring huh? more food for thought,, thank you all for helping me,, I am looking into that now.

as for the circular vs the round, I had no idea,, I think I rattled poor Steve with my questions,, sorry buddy blush

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No prob here, Sue. A step-down ring is one type of holder, but as I've little current experience with holders I didn't want to get too far into things and was too busy with other stuff to do Web searches to educate myself enough to answer your questions. smilesmile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The resharpening doesn't kill my vibe towards the K-drill over the Nils. Babying things aren't part of the average consumers mindset. Durability is what they want.    I'm still on the hunt for an electric version that will suit my newly adapted way of fishing. If I can drill 20 holes in a day I'll be as happy as a fat kid at a cake eating contest. 
    • Oh go back to the Hey eyeguy BBQ post and bug BigDave!
    • Because your usual response is to demand whether I support this of that from some politician or what you claim is "my party", to try to deflect and obfuscicate.   Nobody can make you do anything here, but if you are prescribing policy it seems like you should be able to defend it with facts.
    • You must buy it.... I know you don't catch them!!!
    • I'll have to wait till I find a fresh road kill!! A plug your pie hole ding dong!
    • Hey don't get me involved in your frivolous hokus pokus!
    • Fun fact, CO alarms actually won't go off until 70 ppm is reach over 60 minutes. I believe this stems from Chicago FD responding to too many false CO calls. Law was passed to increase the level of exposure to lower emergency calls. Sofia's law is challenging this on boats and trying to mandate low level CO detectors be installed...I believe the incident happened at much less.That said MN is the first state to require CO detectors on boats with cabins.   Get a CO detector that displays an actual reading or better yet, find a low level CO monitor.   CO has a half life of around 4 hours...meaning if u get exposed with a level of say 20, going outside a few minutes won't help much espically if you go back into your infected fishouse....after 4 hrs of fresh air you'll be down to 10...hence the importance of the CO monitor and not just thinking going outside once an hour is doing much good if u have a leak.   That story made headlines but there was another bad CO incident that happened that same week regarding an ice fisherman...who also did not have a CO detector.
    • Nils extensions go on the bottom of the auger and have the helical.  You remove the blade and put the extension on.  They are made for all models of Nils.   Yes of coarse I've used a Milwaukee Fuel with an 8" Nils and posted video.  Less torque, faster,  but most importantly better battery life using the Nils.   . Yes they weigh a pound or two more then the KDrill because they aren't made from plastic.    If this comes down to blades well let's go there then. Kdrill has free sharpening but takes 3 weeks.   Did you know the material taken off that type blade and mount means less bite and therefore can never cut like new.  That is also why it is up to thier discretion if your blade can be sharpened.   A Nils head is blade and mount and can be adjusted after sharpening to cut as new.   So a nick that would ruin the KDrill blades can be removed from the Nils and still cut like it was intended to. I recently repaired a Nils blade that was used to dig post holes. My point is a Nils should serve its owner for a very long time. In 10 years I've dulled one Nils blade and that was from drilling into some buried trash left on the ice.      
  • Our Sponsors