Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
DTro

Is Live Bait Dead?

16 posts in this topic

Nice article by Dennis Anderson in the Star Tribune today about the current state of live bait and the uncertain future. I really wish there would have been a little more focus on the escalating number of regs that puts virtual “handcuffs” on the Mom and Pop bait stores and also Average Joe that wants to get his own bait.

With all the money that these large corporations are dumping into their R&D for soft bait alternatives, to me, the future looks bleak. I’m sure they don’t mind at all if live bait dies.

For me it’s sad to see because there not much that is more satisfying then spending some down time collecting and nursing live bait and then using it on a slip or float rig to catch bigger ones.

Let’s hope the state keeps an open window for those of us that want to do that, rather than making bait stores and the general public jump through hoop after hoop after hoop to be legal, and even when you think your legal there is some weird clause that nobody can interpret.

So......is live bait dead????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably, it might not happen overnight, but just wait another decade or so.

I could see the BWCA being the first area in the state to actually ban live bait, just following the footsteps of what the adjacent Quetico park has already done.

Not that I agree with it (live bait ban), but I can see and agree with the reasons why it's being considered.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

VHS isn't helping either as we get shortages of certain bait. Thinking of shiner farming grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Five years ago, I thought that even the idea of live bait bans came up once in a blue moon. I mean, this is MN, we must be in the Guinness book of records for live bait use.

What would happen to all those red hooks we’ve been programmed to buy lately? I’m guessing the majority of anglers would start to get all surly and such if they weren’t allowed the tradition of live bait fishing.

So much for riding my fat tire bike down by the MN River anymore to try and catch creek chubs. Not to mention, I’d have to search out some moose drool to rub on my crankbaits while fishing the Boundary Waters, anything for that scented edge us non-bait anglers would need in the future.

All I can do is shake my head, stare at the heavens and hope that the suns corona doesn’t burn my eyes out. With all the new castles being built on our waterways, the average fisherman is sure to suffer even more down the line, and that’s not even including this live bait controversy.

Maybe we can have some sort of live bait summit? Where we can spout the positive virtues of Americas live bait history, and do it in such a way that even Sam Adams would be proud. So what’s it going to be, are we to remain Minnesota manly men, or become St. Pauli girls?????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wounded, but not dead. I can't see a total ban on live bait. Certain areas, yes, but not statewide.

There needs to be sensible regulations. I.E. don't bring bait from the southern US to northern MN and let the rusties populate all of the lakes. But these legislators are forgetting that some of the nasty stuff is spread from lake to lake by birds and water movement, not people.

Steve

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wounded, but not dead. I can't see a total ban on live bait. Certain areas, yes, but not statewide.

Steve

Why not??? Has nobody realized these people will do whatever they want?? Nobody will stand up to them. Are you going to take a day off work to [PoorWordUsage] and complain? Sure write a letter to your rep. let me know how that goes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"But these legislators are forgetting that some of the nasty stuff is spread from lake to lake by birds and water movement, not people."

WHAT? Bad things occurring..........Naturally?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: thedeadsea
Wounded, but not dead. I can't see a total ban on live bait. Certain areas, yes, but not statewide.

Steve

Why not??? Has nobody realized these people will do whatever they want?? Nobody will stand up to them. Are you going to take a day off work to [PoorWordUsage] and complain? Sure write a letter to your rep. let me know how that goes.

Whoa, relax! Who is even talking about writing letters?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Five years ago, I thought that even the idea of live bait bans came up once in a blue moon. I mean, this is MN, we must be in the Guinness book of records for live bait use.

What would happen to all those red hooks we've been programmed to buy lately? I'm guessing the majority of anglers would start to get all surly and such if they weren't allowed the tradition of live bait fishing.

So much for riding my fat tire bike down by the MN River anymore to try and catch creek chubs. Not to mention, I'd have to search out some moose drool to rub on my crankbaits while fishing the Boundary Waters, anything for that scented edge us non-bait anglers would need in the future.

All I can do is shake my head, stare at the heavens and hope that the suns corona doesn't burn my eyes out. With all the new castles being built on our waterways, the average fisherman is sure to suffer even more down the line, and that's not even including this live bait controversy.

Maybe we can have some sort of live bait summit? Where we can spout the positive virtues of Americas live bait history, and do it in such a way that even Sam Adams would be proud. So what's it going to be, are we to remain Minnesota manly men, or become St. Pauli girls?????

I should've known better than to try this in Silly Town. laugh

At least someone got it. wink

Quetico....I'm somewhat disappointed in you, Mr. Beer Snob. smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Duffman
Five years ago, I thought that even the idea of live bait bans came up once in a blue moon. I mean, this is MN, we must be in the Guinness book of records for live bait use.

What would happen to all those red hooks we've been programmed to buy lately? I'm guessing the majority of anglers would start to get all surly and such if they weren't allowed the tradition of live bait fishing.

So much for riding my fat tire bike down by the MN River anymore to try and catch creek chubs. Not to mention, I'd have to search out some moose drool to rub on my crankbaits while fishing the Boundary Waters, anything for that scented edge us non-bait anglers would need in the future.

All I can do is shake my head, stare at the heavens and hope that the suns corona doesn't burn my eyes out. With all the new castles being built on our waterways, the average fisherman is sure to suffer even more down the line, and that's not even including this live bait controversy.

Maybe we can have some sort of live bait summit? Where we can spout the positive virtues of Americas live bait history, and do it in such a way that even Sam Adams would be proud. So what's it going to be, are we to remain Minnesota manly men, or become St. Pauli girls?????

I should've known better than to try this in Silly Town. laugh

At least someone got it. wink

Quetico....I'm somewhat disappointed in you, Mr. Beer Snob. smile

Great, now I'm thirsty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's just like the fact you can't leaglly use a quick strike rig unless you put a spinner on it. Come on, if a guy is useing suckers or chubs for pike or muskies this is the best way to ensure a good release. Live bait if used correctly is NOT a killer, couple this with barbless hooks and an imediate hook set and your release rates can be just as high as with artificals. We do have to beware of VHS though, this virus could do allot of damage to our fishery. This is why bait from other states are banned and we have the shortages from time to time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have used both Gulp and live bait. live bait does outfish gulp.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, this will be my starting point in responses to Dennis Anderson's artical. I intend to go on a letter writting campaign to my fellow bait retailers, wholesalers, tackle suppliers, MNDNR, legislators, and of course Dennis Anderson.

It is so true that the corporate tackle industry is lobbying to control live bait distribution to open markets and change the mindset of fishing people. I must say the artificials have a time and a place where they out proform live bait but why is one product called the Mimic Minnow. Doesn't "mimic" mean to imitate? I was also taken aback when one of my suppliers/ manufactures made the statement that "someday, soft plastics might overtake live bait" to me that sounds as if his product will be directly competing with the products of every bait retailer/wholesaler in the state. Don't get me wrong I am very concerned with all the invasive speicies out there, but where are they coming from, I'd say a great percentage of them have been dumped out of the bilges of vessels in Duluth and the Mississippi waterway, not from the minnow buckets of fishing people. I know I'll get in trouble with this next comment, but when the overseers namely the MNDNR, in 2008, stocked a bank executives pond, in Cloquet, with 2000 rainbow trout from Wisconsin, that were infected with IMP virus which had never been found in Minnesota and is known to kill trout and salmon, this gets me a little riled. This pond has a tributary that flows into Lake Superior and what really burns me is not only did our tax dollars pay to kill these fish and restock this muckity mucks pond with Minnesota raised trout but we had fisheries people out there filleting fish for this guy. This past winters shortage of golden shiners had alot to do with the lack of emerald shiners that were missing last fall in the Rainy River and trapping local golden shiners when we have a winter like we had is next to impossible so all the early fishing folks pretty much decimated the populations. The minnows that we would be importing would be from fish farms that have been tested and retested for invasive hitch hikers and would be a fraction of the total minnow sales in the state why would we pay such high prices for imported minnows when the local bait is avalible other than to fill the voids. Bait dealers across the state are a tough breed and are far from dead. Excuse me I have to go scoop some shiners for some happy fishing folks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wounded, but not dead. I can't see a total ban on live bait. Certain areas, yes, but not statewide.

There needs to be sensible regulations. I.E. don't bring bait from the southern US to northern MN and let the rusties populate all of the lakes. But these legislators are forgetting that some of the nasty stuff is spread from lake to lake by birds and water movement, not people.

Steve

Absolutely. Keep putting Democrats in power and there is no doubt that there will be no live bait allowed ever.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Your partially correct Dave. The good morning thread was designed on the food thread as a babbling thread within that forum. Yea some of the posts went sideways a bit but the question got answered.   I don't remember reiny trying to sell anything. He had more knowledge in making different meats then all the rest combined and wasn't afraid to share!
    •     I think Mickey Mouse = Donald Trump
    •   Actually the beef was more about keeping the topics on topic so the info would be searchable and usable. There was one thread that was getting all the traffic and good information and recipes were getting lost in there amongst the silliness and idle chatter.   The situation was between mods and should have probably been handled in private between the mods and Rick or whoever.   You guys can think what you want and LMIT had a harsh way about himself but he was just looking after the best interests of the site in that instance.     RH had something to sell, that's the main reason he was even here.     Time outs were a lot more of a thing around here in the early days of this site when there were a lot more posters than there are now.
    • Somebody should tell conservatives we are under an Obama budget until September 30th, 2017, and that Trump has not had a single policy go through the legislature yet so we are effectively on cruise control from the last administration.
    •             ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------            
    • So in their infinitr wisdom, the Goppers are floating what the refer to as "Plan B"   http://www.planbonestep.com
    • 56 HERE IN THE boat on Hidden Bay, let me repeat that 56 as in above zero! That kind of number in the fall would be a for sure an afternoon in the Puddle Humper working some late green patch of weeds down a shoreline in search of that late fall bass bite. I would have a rod with a buzz bait handy and when I would come up on some down green I would fling that buzz bait across the top and pump it back to the boat. There would be a good chance for a bass to bust it or more likely as not a northen would try to impress me with a splash and a swirl. The rod would bend some and I would work the fish back to the Puddle Humper. With the northern thrashing at the side of the boat like a toddler trying to get away from his mother at the grocery store I would wait for him to settle down. With years of practice I would grab the northern by his shoulders if fish really had shoulders. I would be able to gage if it was a keeper or not just by how wide I would have to spread my fingers for a good grip.   Lifting the fish out of the water drops would fall back and I would be face to face with a fish that always seem to have that attitude about him. I would pull the hook from the corner of his mouth and give him the fish a look over. Twenty inches, not bad but it was too early in the afternoon to be thinking about supper. I would tell the fish thanks for the action then let him slide from my hand back into the water. The fish of course would do nothing for a second or two then dart off to rejoin his buddies. Taking his position he would brag about how no fishermen could hold him. Back in the boat I would pick up one of the wife's new fluffy kitchen towels that I had borrowed to dry my hands and work a little heat back in my fingers. I would stay on the shoreline tossing a spinner bait and staying were the sun was shinning and with the luck be out of the wind because 56 is still 56, yup that is what I would be doing.   So I am sitting in the cabin, I have the den window cracked open and I can smell the outdoors. The cabin is breathing a little and I think it to is enjoying getting some fresh air to exchange with the stuff that has been here all winter. A few clouds in the sky but lots of sunshine coming in all the south windows. Wife is out on the deck with the brown dog, she has a soapy bucket of water and is wiping down deck furniture. Duncan is touring the grounds taking his time and walking slow, his nose deep into the old brown grass. I can’t see them but I can hear a few birds making noise. The wife comes over to the window to tell me she just saw three bees. Does not surprise me as the neighbor down the road has a hive, I am guessing bees get cabin fever to! Told her go to the greenhouse and grab the screen for the den window, don’t need bees in the cabin.   Sunshine Ray was forecasting mid fifties this weekend but today is a surprise, I was not ready for it. Not much ice on Lake Iwanttobethere and this will put a dent on what is left. Grabbing a jacket I made my way out to the deck and sat down on a chair in the full sun shine. It was just like a day like today should feel like. I lean back in the chair and closed my eyes and took a good listen. Some birds, a chain saw, which put a smile on my face that someone was using a day like today to do chain saw work. I am betting they are thinking winter is not done yet and filling the wood box might not be that bad of an idea. I took a moment to check our wood rack which was half full and decided we are good to go. Then I heard it, and you can’t mistake it for anything else. Someone had started their outboard, what lovely sound!   Well the wife went in the cabin and came out with a quilt and covered me up. I had no problem tugging it around me, I pulled my cap down low over my eye and the brown dog came over and laid down at my feet. Sleeping especially good sleep is hard for me to come by these days so I don’t need much of an excuse to close my eyes and think of buzz baits, lapping water and northerns who think they are something here at Lake Iwanttobethere
  • Our Sponsors