Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

looking for a good coney recipe

3 posts in this topic

I been looking for a good coney island sauce recipe, I'm looking for something made from "scratch" I pretty much given up trying to google a decent one, usally too much tomato sauce flavor for me, I'm looking along the lines of a "meat sauce" kind of like what the the Original Coney use to make, or the Gopher Bar, the closest I've come is one called the Almost Flint-Style Coney Sauce, which is pretty good, I just added a little less tomato sauce, and a pinch of celery salt, does anyone have a favorite one of their own they care to share?

Thanks, J.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Original Coney Island Sauce

2 lbs Lean Ground Beef - Brown lightly and crumble, add in 1 tsp shortening.

4 Med onions chopped fine

Add onions to beef and cook about 5 min.

Pour mixture into a kettle.


½ Tbsp “Pressed” garlic DO NOT! use fresh or garlic powder it will ruin it.

3½ Tbsp chili powder

¼ Tsp cinnamon

½ Tsp Red pepper

¼ Tsp Cumin

½ Tsp Allspice

1 ½ Tbsp White Vinegar

1 Tsp Salt

1 quart water

1- 5 oz. can tomato sauce

Mix well and simmer for 3-4 hrs

Note: DO NOT remove grease for about the first 2 hrs.

If sauce gets too thick add a little water (1/4 cup at a time is good).

Let cool and it freezes in individual containers real well.

Makes 30 –35 coneys

Prep for Coney (This is the secret)

Paint mustard "lightly" on bun first. If you do not do this 1st step it will not taste the same.

Add hot dog (all beef is a must for the right taste)

Add Coney sauce, onions, and another dash of mustard and cheese if you wish.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Posts

    • Seen on the channel 5 news the other night, plans to remove a dam in River Falls. They didn't specify which dam, or if it would be both dams. The movement is gaining popularity, especially with residents. And more input meetings will be planned. However, if the project is ok'd, it doesn't sound like it will be in the near future. I'm all for the dam removal! Both of them!
    • Hey Dave, I am sorry to hear that. If you need anything you have my number.  Send me a PM or text and let me know whats going on. Recurring infection? Low blood supply?     
    • Yes. But he has a great plan to utilize the excess rail capacity in the country by relocating those who disagree with him. It's gonna be a real gas. 
    • 100% A-OK is how that's working out, but I'm not surprised by the continued confusion. Even beside Texas vs Johnson, the idea of stripping citizenship from people hasn't stood up in court.
    • You must have been on some sh*tty ice for it to do that... Love my heavy spud bar, if it doesn't go through in a couple wacks I feel pretty darn confident in stepping...Spud bar,picks,pfd,rope, common sense all ya need
    • Protecting the rights of the id-oits, for the purpose of teaching others how not to be an id-iot is paramount. It goes both ways.........
    • What? You don't like the 1st amendment?
    • there is a seat belt law, why not have a ice picks law? if you are caught out ice fishing before the 1st of the year without picks, you get a "stupid" ticket.
    • So burning a Quran, or pouring bacon grease on it must be protected as well?  And flying the Stars and Bars?  How is that working out? 
  • Our Sponsors